What Gets Written Off and What Gets Questioned
An auditor looking at scrap asks one question first: how much scrap should this process have produced, and how much did it actually record?
Scrap expected against scrap recorded is the test because scrap is the easiest way for material to leave a factory without a sale. Recorded scrap that sits consistently below the process standard suggests material leaving unrecorded; recorded scrap consistently above it suggests good material being written off and taken away as scrap.
Rework carries a different risk. Items sent for rework leave the finished goods count and enter a category with no natural deadline, and rework that never finishes collects cost in a corner of the floor while nobody writes it down. A lender watches both, because each reduces the real security without reducing the reported stock value, and because scrap sales are one of the few places where cash can enter a business without passing through the sales ledger.
Normal Against Abnormal Loss
Every machining process loses material, and the accounting turns on whether the loss was expected.
Built into the standard
Normal lossSwarf, offcuts, setting-up pieces and the share of output that fails inspection at the rate the process inherently produces. Its cost stays inside the cost of the good units, so it never appears as a separate charge.
Beyond the norm
Abnormal lossLoss above what the process should produce. Under AS 2 and Ind AS 2, abnormal amounts of wasted materials, labour or other production costs are excluded from the cost of inventory and charged as an expense of the period.
What can be sold
Saleable scrapWhere scrap is immaterial, AS 2 and Ind AS 2 allow it to be measured at net realisable value and that value deducted from the cost of the main product, so it is not counted twice.
The distinction matters because absorbing an abnormal loss into inventory carries forward a cost that will never be recovered, overstating both closing stock and the profit of the period in which the loss happened. A business without a measured norm cannot tell the two apart, so every loss is treated as normal by default and the balance sheet absorbs whatever went wrong.
The norm itself has to be evidence, not a habit: a scrap rate per part or per operation, set from engineering data or from a measured run, reviewed when the process, the tooling or the material changes. A rate that has not been revisited since the line was commissioned measures nothing about the line as it runs today.
Rework Stock That Never Moves
Rework is a legitimate category that becomes a problem through inertia rather than through any decision. A rejected batch leaves the production flow and enters an area with no schedule attached. Nothing forces a decision, no deadline arrives, and the line runs on new work that is easier and more urgent. The rework area is often the oldest stock on a factory floor.
- Cost carried: the cost absorbed up to the point of rejection, plus any rework already attempted.
What the books hold - Value recoverable: what the finished part would fetch, less the cost still needed to complete and sell it.
What it is worth - When the arithmetic fails: the parts are worth scrap value and are being carried at many times that.
Write down to recoverable value
Ageing the rework pool makes this visible. Reporting the balance by the date each batch entered rework, rather than as one figure, separates material waiting for a scheduled operation from material that simply stopped, and the second group is usually the larger.
Scrap Sales and Their Recording
Scrap sales get disproportionate attention because the material is easy to move and its value is easy to understate. The test is a three-way reconciliation.
- Expected against generated. The output produced implies a scrap quantity at the process norm; the scrap recorded as generated is compared with it. Generation well below the norm suggests material leaving unrecorded.
- Generated against sold. Sales well below recorded generation suggest scrap piling up, being disposed of informally, or being sold without the proceeds arriving.
- Weighment and rate. The weighbridge slip fixes the quantity, the invoice fixes the rate, and together they let the realisation be tested against the market for that material. A rate well below market on a large quantity is a finding in its own right.
The failure this area exists to catch is scrap leaving without a record: taken by the contractor who clears it, removed during a shutdown, or handed over in exchange for a service. Under GST, registered businesses other than composition dealers keep stock accounts that include scrap and wastage (CGST Rule 56(2)), so an unrecorded removal is a gap in a statutory record as well as a loss.
Evidence a Write-Off Needs
Because scrap write-offs are easy to declare, the evidence expected for them is specific.
- Approval within authority, before disposal. The person approving must have had the power to approve a write-off of that value, and the approval must predate the disposal. Approvals signed after the material has gone are ratification, not authorisation, and are the most common weakness.
- Physical evidence. The item was seen in its scrapped condition, its disposal was witnessed, or the weighbridge slip and the dealer's invoice tie to the quantity written off. A write-off supported only by an internal note records an intention.
- Reconciliation to production. Scrap arises from production at a rate the process implies. A write-off well above what the output could have produced is not a valuation question; it is a question about what was actually scrapped.
A write-off also has a tax side. Under section 17(5)(h) of the CGST Act, input tax credit has to be reversed on goods lost, stolen, destroyed or written off; a write-down to net realisable value is not on that list. Where the movements sit in the stores records, and why the stores ledger and the bin card so often disagree on them, is covered in the guide to reconciling the stores ledger and the bin card.
Cleaning the Scrap and Rework Balance
Segregate and quantify before the count instead of leaving a corner of the floor to be resolved on the day. Scrap awaiting disposal, rework awaiting a decision and material that is simply in the wrong place look the same in a heap and carry very different values. Separate them, weigh or count each, and record what each is. The exercise usually shows that much of what was assumed to be rework has waited so long that nobody intends to rework it.
Write-off decisions survive review when the approval predates the disposal, sits within the approver's authority and is backed by evidence in proportion to the value: for scrap, the weighbridge slip and the dealer's invoice tying to the quantity; for rework abandoned as uneconomic, a costing that shows the rework would exceed the recoverable value.
Independent verification is worth commissioning where recorded scrap has drifted from the process norm, where the balance has built up over years, or where a lender has a charge over the stock. A stock audit for engineering and machine tool plants covers the scrap and the rework populations in the same visit.
