Talk to an expert

Tell us what you need and we will call you back.

🇮🇳 +91

    GSTAT Appeals and Representation Support

    GSTAT Advance Ruling Appeal (NAAR): Resolving Conflicting Rulings

    When appellate authorities in two States give opposite advance rulings on the same question, a business operating in both is left with two answers. A national appeal exists to settle that conflict. We check whether your rulings qualify, compare them point by point, and prepare the appeal papers.

    GSTAT advance ruling appeal: Advance ruling went against you?
    National advance ruling appeal, at a glance CGST Act, 2017
    Patron professional fee Starting from ₹24,999 (Exl GST and Govt. Charges) Final fee depends on the number of States and rulings to compare, the question, and whether a hearing follows; told to you before we start
    • Two or more States, one question The national appeal applies only where appellate authorities in two or more States have given conflicting rulings on the same question
    • Who hears it The national appellate authority provided in the Act; check that it is hearing appeals before you file
    • Time limit Check the period for your case before filing
    • Adverse ruling, no conflict This route does not apply; a High Court writ is usually the option
    Any government fee for the appeal is paid to the government and is separate from our fee.

    In short

    National advance ruling appeal at a glance

    An advance ruling is decided State by State, first by the Authority for Advance Ruling, then on appeal by the Appellate Authority for Advance Ruling (AAAR) of that State. When AAARs in two or more States give conflicting rulings on the same question, the law provides a national appellate authority to resolve the conflict.

    PointWhat it means for you
    When it appliesConflicting appellate rulings from two or more States on the same question
    Who hears itThe national appellate authority
    Time limitCheck the period for your case before filing
    Form and feeCheck the form and fee for your case before filing
    No conflict, just an adverse rulingThis route does not apply; a High Court writ is usually the option
    Our feeStarting from ₹24,999 (Exl GST and Govt. Charges)

    Definition

    What the national appellate authority for advance rulings does

    State A
    1. Authority for Advance Ruling
      Rules on the question for the applicant registered in that State
    2. Appellate Authority (AAAR)
      Decides the appeal against that ruling
    Answer A on the same question
    State B
    1. Authority for Advance Ruling
      Rules on the same question for the registration in that State
    2. Appellate Authority (AAAR)
      Decides the appeal against that ruling
    Answer B on the same question
    The national appellate authority

    Hears the appeal only where appellate authorities in two or more States have reached conflicting answers on the same question, and settles which answer stands.

    Check that it is hearing appeals before you file.

    GST is one law applied by many States, and each State has its own Authority and Appellate Authority for Advance Ruling. That structure means the same product or service can be classified one way in one State and another way in the next. For a business registered in both, that is not a theoretical problem: it means charging different tax on the same supply.

    The national appellate authority was added to the law to settle these conflicts. It does not hear every adverse advance ruling, only cases where appellate authorities in two or more States have reached conflicting answers on the same question. For a long time it was not set up. Section 101A(1A), added by the Finance Act 2026, lets the Government empower an existing authority, including a Tribunal, to hear these appeals until it is; we check which body hears them before any filing.

    The national appellate authority is a different thing from an ordinary GSTAT appeal.

    Ordinary GSTAT appeal

    Appeal under Section 112

    Filed against a first-appeal order on a demand, refund or penalty, within 3 months of the order being communicated.

    This page

    Advance-ruling appeal

    About the meaning of the law for a future or current transaction, and only where appellate rulings from two or more States conflict.

    Is it for you

    When a national advance ruling appeal fits your case

    The route is worth considering when:

    You are registered in more than one State

    and the appellate authorities in two of them have given conflicting rulings on the same question.

    The question is classification, credit, valuation or exemption

    the kinds of question advance rulings answer, and the difference matters on every invoice.

    A conflicting ruling from another State on the same transaction

    Who, other than you, may hold the conflicting ruling for the appeal to lie is a point of law we confirm before filing.

    When it does not fit

    It does not fit when your own appellate ruling is simply adverse and no other State has ruled differently. In that case the remedy lies outside the advance-ruling system. Our page on applying for an advance ruling in the first place, GST advance ruling (AAR and AAAR), explains the State-level steps.

    Step by step

    How we prepare and file a national advance ruling appeal

    1. Collect the rulings

      We gather the advance rulings and appellate rulings from each State on the same question, with the applications behind them.

    2. Test whether they really conflict

      An appeal to the national authority is available only where appellate authorities in two or more States have given conflicting rulings on the same question. A ruling that is merely against you, with no conflicting ruling elsewhere, does not qualify; the route then is usually a High Court writ.

    3. Check the time and the forum

      We confirm the date the appellate ruling was communicated and the time allowed, and which body hears the appeal today.

    4. Draft the appeal

      The appeal sets out the question, the conflicting rulings side by side, the points on which they differ, and the reasons one view is right.

    5. File and pay the fee

      The appeal is filed in the prescribed form with the fee. The Tribunal's fee for an ordinary appeal under Section 112 is ₹1,000 for every ₹1 lakh of tax, credit, fine, fee or penalty, minimum ₹5,000 and maximum ₹25,000. Whether the same fee applies to this appeal is a point we confirm before filing.

    6. Hearing papers and the order

      Written submissions and a comparison table of the rulings for the hearing. The law lets you appear yourself or through an authorised representative such as a practising chartered accountant or an advocate.

    7. Apply the result in every State

      A ruling from the national authority settles the question for the applicants concerned. We help you apply it in each registration where the conflict arose.

    Compare

    Advance ruling routes compared

    PointAAAR appeal (State)National appealHigh Court writ
    Used forAn adverse ruling from your State's AuthorityConflicting appellate rulings from two or more StatesAn adverse ruling with no conflict, or a legal defect in the ruling
    Who decidesThe State's Appellate AuthorityThe national appellate authorityThe High Court
    Time30 days from communication of the ruling, plus up to 30 more for sufficient cause (section 100(2))Check the period for your case before filingNo fixed period we can state

    Method

    Building the comparison of conflicting rulings

    The heart of a national appeal is the comparison. The authority has to see, quickly, that two appellate authorities answered the same question differently, not two different questions. A useful comparison sets out:

    1. The question as each applicant framed it, word for word.
    2. The facts each ruling relied on, so it is clear the transactions are the same in substance.
    3. The answer each ruling gave, and the provision, notification or entry it turned on.
    4. The reasoning, point by point, showing where the two rulings part ways.
    5. The consequence of each answer (the rate, the credit or the registration position) for the same supply.
    6. The view you ask the authority to adopt, with the authorities that support it.

    Before you file: if the facts in the two rulings differ in a way that explains the different answers, the rulings may not truly conflict, and the appeal is likely to fail on that ground alone. We test this before you spend time and fees on filing.

    Meanwhile

    Until the conflict is resolved

    A national appeal takes time, and in the meantime you still have to invoice and file returns in every State. Points to settle with your advisers:

    Which ruling binds where

    An advance ruling binds the applicant and the officer who has jurisdiction over that applicant, in that State. A ruling given in one State does not bind officers in another.

    How to invoice

    Charging the higher rate everywhere protects you against demands but may hurt sales; charging different rates in different States follows each ruling but needs clear records.

    What to record

    Keep the rulings, the dates and your reasons for the rate charged in each State, so that any later notice can be answered from the file.

    Tax you choose to pay

    If you decide to pay tax for past periods in a State while the question is open, pay it through DRC-03 so it is recorded against the right period.

    Avoiding conflicts in the first place

    A business applying for advance rulings in more than one State can reduce the risk of conflicting answers by describing the transaction and framing the question in the same way in each application, and by telling each authority about rulings already given elsewhere.

    Pitfalls

    Common reasons a national advance ruling appeal fails

    ReasonWhat it meansHow to avoid it
    No real conflictThe rulings differ because the facts differ, not because the law was read differentlyCompare the facts first; file only where the transactions match in substance
    Wrong ruling relied onA first-level ruling is compared with an appellate ruling, or a ruling has since been set asideUse the final appellate rulings and check their current status
    Question too broadThe appeal asks for a general statement of law rather than an answer to the question ruled onKeep to the question the appellate authorities actually answered
    Late filingThe appeal is filed after the time allowedCount from the date the ruling was communicated
    Incomplete papersThe applications, rulings or facts behind them are missingFile the full record from each State

    Weigh it first: a failed national appeal still leaves the State rulings in place, so the decision to file should weigh the cost against the benefit of a single answer across States.

    Checklist

    Documents for a national advance ruling appeal

    1
    The conflicting appellate rulings from each State, with the dates they were communicated
    2
    The advance ruling applications (Form GST ARA-01) and the first rulings behind them
    3
    A comparison of the rulings showing exactly where they differ
    4
    Registration details for each State involved
    5
    Contracts, product literature and invoices describing the transaction
    6
    Circulars, notifications and rulings relied on
    7
    Authorisation for your representative if one files or appears for you

    Fees

    Fees for a national advance ruling appeal

    Patron professional fee

    Starting from ₹24,999 (Exl GST and Govt. Charges)

    We tell you the fee before we start. Any government fee for the appeal is separate.

    Fixed quote once we have read the rulings

    What the final fee depends on

    • The number of States and rulings to compare
    • The question ruled on
    • Whether a hearing follows

    The final fee depends on the rulings and the work involved.

    Evidence

    How we check this page

    Where the figures come from

    • Time limits, filing fee and admission rules on this page are taken from the CGST Act, 2017 (as consolidated on India Code) and Notification 12/2024-Central Tax. The sources are listed at the foot of the page.
    • The national appellate route, its time limits, form and fee are confirmed by a Chartered Accountant from the official text before they are stated here.
    • Figures that are still being checked are marked on the page rather than stated.

    Written and reviewed

    Written by Subham Jhunjhunwala.

    Reviewed by CA Sundram Gupta

    FAQ

    Frequently asked questions

    How do I complete a GSTAT advance ruling appeal?

    First confirm that appellate authorities in two or more States have given conflicting rulings on the same question, without that, the national route is not open. Then collect the rulings and the applications behind them, prepare an appeal that sets the rulings side by side and explains which view is right, and file it in the prescribed form with the fee within the time allowed.

    Get a quote

    Talk to us about your case

    Send us the conflicting rulings and the dates they were communicated. We will tell you whether a national appeal lies, how much time you have, and our fee for preparing the appeal papers.

    Patron professional fee: Starting from ₹24,999 (Exl GST and Govt. Charges)

    Get a quote

    Leave your details and we will call you back.

    🇮🇳 +91

      By sending this form you agree to our privacy policy.

      Talk to a CA

      What you get back

      1. Whether a national appeal lies on your rulings, or whether the route is elsewhere
      2. How much time you have, counted from the date the rulings were communicated
      3. Our fee for preparing the appeal papers
      Written by Subham Jhunjhunwala Reviewed by CA Sundram Gupta

      Sources used on this page

      • CGST Act, 2017, sections 101A to 101C: the national appellate authority for advance rulings and appeals to it where appellate authorities in two or more States have given conflicting rulings on the same question; section 103: who an advance ruling binds. India Code, read 3 November 2026.
      • CGST Act, 2017, section 112(1): appeal to the Appellate Tribunal within 3 months of communication (used only to contrast the two routes); section 116(2): who may appear as an authorised representative. India Code, read 3 November 2026.
      • CGST Rules, 2017, Rule 110(5) (Notification 12/2024-Central Tax): Tribunal fee of ₹1,000 for every ₹1 lakh of tax, input tax credit, fine, fee or penalty involved, minimum ₹5,000, maximum ₹25,000, for appeals under section 112; whether it applies to an advance-ruling appeal is not yet confirmed. CBIC tax information portal, read 3 November 2026.
      • CGST Rules, 2017, Rule 142 and Form GST DRC-03: voluntary payment of tax for a period while a question is open. CBIC tax information portal, read 3 November 2026.
      • The forum that hears the national appeal today, its time limit, form and fee are referred to on this page; the figures under them are not yet confirmed and are shown as such.
      • Every figure above is checked by CA Sundram Gupta before publishing.

      Get a quote

      Leave your details and we will call you back.

      🇮🇳 +91

        By sending this form you agree to our privacy policy.

        Get compliance due-date alerts on WhatsApp. Join →