Low Value, High Leakage
Consumables stock verification is the count and review of the low-value items a plant uses up rather than builds into its product: cutting inserts, drill bits, abrasives, gloves, coolant, oils, welding rods, fasteners and packing material. Because no single item is worth controlling, most of them are issued freely and recorded loosely, and the loss only shows when they are added up. The verification therefore works at two levels: a physical count of what the stores hold, and a test of whether consumption is reasonable for the output it supported.
The leakage is rarely theft on a scale anyone notices. It is an insert changed early because a fresh one was within reach, coolant topped up from a drum nobody logs, gloves taken by the box, a drawer of half-used tools at every machine. Each choice is sensible on the day; across every line, shift and month, consumption drifts upward without any change in output, and the stores balance is always roughly right and never exactly right.
What Counts as a Consumable, and Why It Matters for the Books
Accounting Standard 2 includes in inventories the materials or supplies to be consumed in the production process or in rendering services. Consumables still in the stores at the period end are therefore inventory and belong in the closing stock; once issued and used, they are an expense. The verification has to fix that line: what is in stores, what has been issued to a machine or a sub-store but not used, and what has gone.
Production consumables
Used up in making the productInserts, drills, taps, grinding wheels, coolant, cutting oil, welding wire and gas, shot-blasting media. Consumption should move with machine hours or output.
General consumables
Used by people, not machinesGloves, masks, cleaning material, stationery, packing tape and stretch film. Consumption should move with headcount, shifts or dispatches.
Not consumables
Tools, spares and materialReusable tools issued from a tool crib, machine spares and raw material each need their own controls; mixing them into consumables hides both.
Why Consumables Escape Control
- They sit below every threshold. Requisitions, approvals and counts are set up for items worth watching, and each consumable is worth too little on its own. The judgement is right item by item and wrong in total.
No approval - They are issued on request. Stopping a machine for paperwork costs more than the item, so issue is informal and nobody records who took what, for which machine.
No issue record - They are rarely counted. A full count costs a lot of effort for a small value, so it is put off; when it happens, differences are adjusted, not investigated, because an unrecorded issue cannot be traced.
No reconciliation - They hide in an expense line. Consumption is booked straight to the profit and loss account, so it never looks like an asset going missing.
No attention
The Consumable Stock Register
A consumable stock register is the running record of each consumable the stores hold: what came in, what went out, to whom, and what should be left. It can be a page per item in a book, a sheet per item or the consumables module of the ERP; the format matters less than keeping it current. A register that is useful at a count holds, for each item:
- the item, its code and its unit of measure (piece, box, litre, kilogram), with the conversion where it is bought in one unit and issued in another
- receipts, with the date and the supplier's document
- issues, with the date, the quantity and the machine, cost centre or job it went to
- returns to stores of unused or part-used items
- the running balance after each entry
- the minimum and reorder levels, and the person who may approve issues above the agreed limit
The register is the consumables version of the stores ledger. Where the stores also keep a bin card at the rack, the two should agree before the physical count is compared with either; why they so often do not is covered in the stores ledger and bin card guide.
Measuring the Leakage: Consumption Ratios
Individual issues cannot be controlled economically, so the evidence that consumption is reasonable is a ratio, not a count. The ratio links what was consumed to what it was consumed for, and it can be watched without anyone recording a single issue.
- Inserts per thousand parts For each machining operation, using the plant's own measured history.
- Coolant per machine hour Litres topped up against hours run on each machine group.
- Gloves per shift Pairs issued against shifts worked in each department.
- Packing per dispatch Film, tape and cartons against units or cases shipped.
- Consumables per unit Total consumables cost against units produced, as the overall check.
One period's ratio proves little: a hard batch of material, a new operator or a different product mix will move it. The finding is a ratio that drifts upward over several periods while output and process stay the same, with no trace of a cause elsewhere: no change of supplier, material, machine condition or product. That is reached by elimination, and it points to where an issue control is worth adding. The same comparison of planned and actual use for production material is covered in reconciling the bill of materials to shop-floor issues.
Set norms from your own history, not from a supplier's tool-life claim. A supplier's figure assumes ideal cutting conditions; your measured figure includes your materials, machines and operators, and it is the one variance should be judged against.
Counting Items Nobody Counts
A full count of every washer to the standard of every carbide insert is effort spent in the wrong place. A proportionate count looks like this:
- Rank the lines by annual consumption value. The few lines that carry most of the money (often inserts, grinding wheels, welding consumables, oils) are counted unit by unit. The long tail is counted in bulk or tested on a sample, and the basis is written down. How a sample is chosen is set out in the guide to sampling methods.
- Weigh or measure bulk items. Coolant, oils, adhesives, welding wire and abrasive media are weighed or dipped, not counted. Deduct the container's tare weight, use a calibrated scale, and record the conversion to stock units.
- Agree the rule for part-used items before the count. An opened box, a part-drawn drum, an insert with edges left: either record them as fractions on a stated basis, or exclude them and say so. Deciding during the count produces a different rule in every aisle.
- Count the floor stock, not only the stores. Drawers and trolleys at machines, line-side bins and sub-stores often hold more than the main stores. Stock issued but not used is still inventory at the period end; at minimum, measure how much there is.
- Count the exchange bin. Where the plant uses an old-for-new rule, the used inserts or worn wheels handed back are evidence of consumption. Compare them with the issues for the same period.
- Reconcile and investigate. Compare the count with the register, explain each difference by line, and post the adjustment only once the difference is understood. A stores that always writes off the difference teaches everyone that the register does not matter.
Controls That Survive the Shop Floor
Universal control on consumables costs more than it saves and is usually abandoned within months. Controls that last are selective:
- A value threshold. Above it, an issue needs a request naming the machine or job; below it, control is by ratio.
Proportionate - Old for new. A fresh insert, wheel or blade is issued only against the worn one, which also gives the stores a record of real consumption.
Evidence of use - Kits and set issues. A fixed kit per job or per shift replaces open-ended issue for the lines that matter.
Predictable - A monthly ratio review. Someone outside the stores looks at the five ratios each month and asks about any that moved.
The real control - A periodic count of the top lines. Counting the high-value lines every quarter, and everything once a year, keeps the register worth trusting.
Baseline
Leakage in consumables can also be a symptom of something wider: where stores records are routinely adjusted to match the count and nobody asks why, the same habit tends to cover larger losses, which is the pattern discussed in the forensic stock audit guide.
When the consumables register has drifted too far to be a reliable opening position, or consumption ratios keep rising with no explanation, a stock audit for engineering and machine tool plants can count the stores alongside production material and set a baseline that every later variance can be measured from.
