Valuing Unsold Collections at Season End
Fashion stock loses value on a schedule the market sets, and the write-down belongs to the period in which that value fell, not the period in which the goods are finally cleared.
The pattern is familiar: full price during the season, discounting at its close, clearance through outlets or bulk buyers afterwards, and in the end sale by weight. Under AS 2 and Ind AS 2, inventory is carried at the lower of cost and net realisable value, so at each balance sheet date the remaining stock is measured against what it will now fetch, in the condition and channel it is actually in. The write-down is the difference between that figure and cost.
The evidence behind the number is specific: what comparable stock realised in earlier clearances, offers received for the current lot, ageing by collection and the sell-through achieved. Each is covered below, after the calendar that drives it.
The Apparel Season Calendar
Apparel value is governed by a calendar rather than by physical condition, which sets the category apart from most inventory. A collection is designed, bought, delivered to stores, sold at full price for a planned window, then discounted and cleared. The garment is identical at every stage and worth less at each one. Nothing has deteriorated.
In season
Full priceThe style sells at the ticket price through its planned window.
Season close
MarkdownDiscounts move what the full-price window left behind, at a thinner margin.
After the season
ClearanceOutlet stores, bulk buyers, online liquidation and finally sale by weight, each recovering a smaller share of cost.
The date a style becomes previous season is a commercial judgement with a fairly precise date attached: the point at which full-price selling effectively stops. After it, the merchandise competes with newer stock on the same floor and moves only on price. The buying calendar fixed that date long before the goods arrived.
This is why ageing by months held misleads. A garment bought late in a season and one bought early look different in a date-based ageing report but sit in the same market. Ageing by collection follows what buyers will actually pay; ageing by calendar date is the most common error in this category.
Net Realisable Value in Practice
The principle is simple and the judgement is in applying it. Net realisable value is the estimated selling price in the ordinary course of business less the estimated costs of completion and the estimated costs necessary to make the sale. Finished apparel has nothing left to complete, but its costs to sell are real: transport to an outlet channel, handling, re-ticketing and the commission or margin a clearance route takes.
The selling price depends on the channel. Season-end stock sells at whatever its clearance route achieves, and an outlet store, a bulk buyer, an online liquidation channel and a sale by weight each recover a very different share of cost. The estimate means nothing until the channel that will actually be used is identified.
Example (figures invented to show the arithmetic): a style cost ₹800 a unit. The outlet channel that will take it has paid about ₹700 for comparable styles, and getting the goods there costs about ₹60 a unit, so net realisable value is ₹640 and each unit is written down by ₹160. If the realistic route is a bulk buyer paying ₹400, the write-down rises to more than half of cost, which is why the channel has to be settled first.
The business's own earlier clearances are the strongest support for the selling price. What the same category realised through the same channel in previous seasons, as a share of cost, is objective and testable, and a provision that assumes materially better recovery this season needs a stated reason.
Size and Colour Broken Ranges
A quantity of apparel is only a saleable quantity if the assortment within it is intact, and this is the factor a unit-based valuation misses.
At season end a style may have many units left that are almost all extreme sizes, because the middle of the size curve sold first. Those units do not sell at an ordinary discount, since the customers who wear the middle sizes have already bought. A clearance buyer discounts a broken curve heavily because the same problem passes to them, and a lot made up only of the ends of the range may attract interest only as bulk. Colour behaves the same way: the popular colourways go first and the unpopular ones stay.
- Count by size and colour, not only by style. The count sheet has to show the assortment, or the valuation cannot see the break.
Assortment visible on the count - Value broken ranges separately. Apply the recovery a broken range actually achieves, not the style's average.
Separate rate for broken curves - Flag single-colour residues. A style left only in its least popular colourway is valued as that colourway.
Colour treated like size
One provision percentage applied to all the units left assumes they are a representative sample of the style. By definition they are the units nobody wanted, so the percentage overstates their value.
Evidence a Write-Down Requires
An auditor looks for three things behind an apparel write-down, and each can be prepared before the year end.
- Actual clearance recovery from earlier seasons, by category and channel, as a share of cost. Where a category cleared at a similar share in each of the last three seasons, that share is the starting point; a materially better assumption needs a reason on paper.
- Ageing by collection, not by date received. Stock from two collections ago sits in a different market from last season's, and an ageing report grouped by calendar date hides the boundary that matters.
- A policy applied the same way across periods. A write-down policy applied one way in a good year and another in a difficult one produces earnings that reflect the policy rather than the trading, and that pattern is what an auditor checks first.
Offers received for the current lot and the sell-through achieved during the markdown period support the estimate further. A general policy percentage on its own is the weakest support, because it was set before the season and cannot know how the season went.
Getting the Season-End Number Right
Age and grade the stock before the count. Stock grouped by collection and condition can be valued; stock held as one balance cannot, because the season is rarely visible in the item code. Sorting physically at season end, while the merchandise is identifiable and the buyers who chose it are still there, is far cheaper than rebuilding the picture from purchase dates a year later.
Build the provision percentages from your own recovery data by category, set them before the year end and apply them the same way in good and bad years. Policies revised each year to reach an acceptable result are what reviewers look for, and the revision usually shows in the numbers even when it is not disclosed.
Where the balance is material, the clearance channels have changed or the auditors have challenged the basis before, an independent view settles the argument. A stock audit of textile and apparel stock covers the physical position and the ageing in one exercise.
