What Belongs on the Balance Sheet
Returned stock is not new stock, and carrying it at the cost of new stock is one of the most common misstatements on an electronics balance sheet.
A unit that has left the warehouse, reached a customer and come back has changed category, whether or not it was ever switched on. Condition drives what it is worth, and condition here is a graded judgement rather than a yes or no. Each grade fetches a different price, in a market where returned and refurbished electronics are routinely sold below the price of new.
The accounting rule is short. Under AS 2 and Ind AS 2, inventory is carried at the lower of cost and net realisable value, and net realisable value is the estimated selling price in the ordinary course of business less the estimated costs of completion and the costs needed to make the sale. For a returned unit, that means the price its grade will fetch, less any repair still needed and the cost of selling it.
In practice the cleanest point to make that assessment is when the unit is received back and graded, not when someone finally decides to sell it, because that is when the information about its condition first exists. Refurbished stock, meaning a returned unit that has been repaired and tested for resale, is then carried at no more than its own grade supports.
The Returns Pipeline
Returned goods reach a business through several channels, and treating them as one population is the first mistake.
Channel one
Customer returnsCome back from the end user, usually within a stated return window, and may be unopened, opened, used or faulty. They typically arrive at a service point or a returns centre, one or a few at a time.
Channel two
Channel returnsCome back from retailers and distributors, often in bulk at the end of a period and under a credit note. They can include goods that were never sold at all alongside goods that were.
Channel three
Warranty returnsArrive because something failed, often through a repair network that may sit outside the inventory system altogether. They raise a warranty question that is dealt with separately from the stock valuation.
Units judged fit to sell again without any work, often called saleable returns, can go back to stock quickly, but only once someone has checked them. Everything else waits for grading.
Stock still in the pipeline at the count date is what causes reconciliation problems. Goods sent back by a customer, lying at a collection point, in transit to a returns centre or waiting to be graded sit somewhere between the customer and the stock records. Each stage has to be identified and listed, because a unit that falls between two records is the one most easily missed, or counted twice. Where returned units carry serial numbers, matching them to the original sale is the quickest way to prove a return is the unit that was sold and not a substitute.
Grading Returned Stock
Value in a returns pool is a function of condition, so grading is the whole exercise rather than a step before it. Grades have to be defined so that two people grading the same unit reach the same answer, and each grade has to say what it means physically rather than by impression. A workable set has five:
- Sealed and unopened: outer seal intact, no sign of handling.
Closest to new stock - Opened but unused: seal broken, contents complete, no sign of use.
Contents checked first - Used and fully working: signs of use, every function tested and working.
Sold as used or refurbished - Working after repair: a fault fixed and tested since.
Valued net of the repair - Beyond economic repair: repair would cost more than it adds to the selling price.
Parts or scrap value only
Refurbishable or unsaleable is the decision that follows, and it is economic rather than technical. A unit that can be repaired is worth repairing only if the repair costs less than the difference it makes to what the unit will fetch, which for older models is often not the case. Grading a unit as repairable when nobody will ever fund the repair simply puts off the write-down.
Refurbishment cost against recovery is therefore compared per grade and per model, not set as one general policy. Where parts and labour approach what a refurbished unit sells for, the honest grade is beyond economic repair, and pools that never move are usually pools where that judgement was avoided.
Refurbished Units and Their Value
Once a unit has been refurbished, the question is what it may be carried at, and there is a ceiling that is easy to breach. The accumulated cost is the carrying value of the returned unit plus the parts and labour spent on it, and adding those together can produce a figure higher than the unit was worth new. The arithmetic is correct and the answer is wrong.
Net realisable value is the constraint. The carrying amount cannot exceed what the refurbished unit will fetch in the channel it will actually be sold through, less the cost of selling it. Where the accumulated cost is higher, the excess is written down rather than carried until the unit sells.
Figures invented to show the arithmetic: a returned unit carried at ₹9,000 has ₹2,500 of parts and labour spent on it, which takes its carrying figure to ₹11,500. Its refurbished grade sells for ₹10,000, with ₹600 of selling expenses, so its net realisable value is ₹9,400. It is carried at ₹9,400, and ₹2,100 is written down.
Refurbished units that are never resold show whether the policy works. A pool of restored units that has aged without moving means either the refurbishment was uneconomic or the sales channel does not exist, and in both cases the carrying value rests on an assumption the evidence contradicts.
Evidence Supporting the Carrying Value
The carrying value of a returns pool rests on a grading judgement, so the evidence has to show who made it and whether it holds.
What supports the value of a returns pool
Grading records say what was decided; recovery history and ageing say whether the decision holds.
Grading records
- Unit, grade, date and grader
- The criteria the grade was judged against
- Weakest when graded by the team the value affects
Recovery history
- What each grade actually fetched last period
- Real disposals, not list prices
- The strongest test of a grade's value
Age of the pool
- How long units have waited, by grade
- Models replaced in the market while they wait
- A long tail is worth less than its grades suggest
Recovery history is the most persuasive of the three. Where units graded as fully working last year realised a fraction of the value given to that grade, the grade itself is mispriced, and prices achieved on real disposals are far better evidence of realisable value than any internal scale.
Ageing matters more for electronics than for most stock, because the model is being replaced in the market while the unit waits for a decision. A valuation that ignores the age of the pool is defending a figure the market has already moved past.
Cleaning Up the Returns Balance
Segregate and grade before the count, not during it. A returns pool held as one mixed pile cannot be valued, because value here depends entirely on grade, and grading a large pool while a counting team waits is the most expensive way to do it. Four steps turn the balance from an estimate into a schedule:
- Separate the grades physically and mark each area, so the count records grade as well as quantity.
- Record the grading decision against each unit, with its serial number where it has one, at the moment the decision is made.
- List what is still in the pipeline at the count date: at collection points, in transit, or waiting to be graded.
- Set the write-down for each grade from recovery data, and state the policy before the count rather than after it.
A write-down policy survives review when it is stated in advance, applied consistently and checked against what disposals actually realised. A policy that sets a percentage by grade without reference to recovery data will meet one question first: what did last year's stock in the same grade actually fetch? Build the policy from that answer.
An independent check is worth commissioning where the pool is material, where it has grown across periods without clearing, or where the statutory auditors have queried it before. An electronics stock audit that takes in the returns pool tests returned units alongside saleable stock, so both are verified on the same basis.
