Counting Stock You Do Not Own
Consignment stock is stock that one business (the consignor) places at another business's premises (the consignee) so the consignee can sell it, while ownership stays with the consignor until the goods are sold to an end customer. Verifying it means proving three things at once: the goods are physically there, they are the consignor's and not the consignee's, and every unit that has gone has been reported as sold.
Electronics make this harder than most goods. A television, a refrigerator or a phone carries a high value in a small box, the same model is often bought outright by the dealer and also held on consignment, and the boxes look identical on the shelf. Display units are unpacked, demonstration units are used, returned units come back in opened cartons, and a unit sent for repair is neither on the floor nor sold. Each of these is a place where the count and the records can part company.
Both parties need the count, for different reasons. The consignor has a material part of its inventory in someone else's custody and has to show that it exists. The consignee has to keep the goods out of its own stock figure, which is only right if the consigned units are identified and separated. The meaning of the term on its own is in the consignment stock definition; this guide is about checking it.
How Consignment Is Treated in Accounting
Delivery to the consignee is not a sale. That one rule decides the accounting on both sides, and the standards say it directly.
- Consignor, Accounting Standards. AS 9 lists consignment sales, where the recipient undertakes to sell the goods on behalf of the consignor, among its examples and says revenue should not be recognised until the goods are sold to a third party. Until then the goods stay in the consignor's inventory.
AS 9, Examples - Consignor, Ind AS. Ind AS 115 says an entity does not recognise revenue on delivering a product to a dealer or distributor if the product is held on consignment. Its indicators: the entity controls the product until a specified event such as the dealer's sale; it can require the product back or move it to another dealer; and the dealer has no unconditional obligation to pay, though it may pay a deposit.
Ind AS 115, para 38(c), B77-B78 - Consignee. The goods are not the consignee's inventory. In an agency relationship the consignee's revenue is the commission, not the gross amount it collects from customers.
AS 9, para 4.1 - Valuation of unsold stock. The consignor values the stock lying with the consignee like any other inventory: at the lower of cost and net realisable value, where cost includes the costs of bringing the goods to their present location and condition.
AS 2, paras 5-6
GST follows the same shape. Under Schedule I of the CGST Act, goods supplied by a principal to an agent who undertakes to supply them on the principal's behalf are a supply even without consideration. CBIC's circular on the point makes the test whether the agent issues the invoice to the customer in its own name: if it invoices in the principal's name, the movement to the agent is not covered by that entry. Matching the consigned quantities with what the returns report is a separate exercise, covered in how to match physical inventory with GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B.
Calculating the Stock on Consignment
The quantity the consignor expects to find is built from its own records and the consignee's reports, not from the count. Work it out per model, and for electronics per serial number:
- Start with the units sent. Opening stock with the consignee plus every unit dispatched to it in the period, taken from the consignor's dispatch records.
- Take off what has left. Units the consignee has reported as sold, units returned to the consignor, and any loss recorded and agreed between the two (transit damage, theft, a unit written off).
- The remainder is the expected closing stock. That is the figure the count is compared with. Every serial number in it should be on the consignee's premises, or at a named place such as a service centre, on the count date.
- Value it. Cost of the unsold units plus their share of the costs incurred to get them to the consignee (freight, transit insurance, unloading). The consignee's commission and selling costs are not part of cost. Then compare with net realisable value: an old model that will only sell at a heavy discount is written down.
120 units of one model are sent at a cost of 20,000 each, with 36,000 of freight for the whole lot. 90 are reported sold. The 30 unsold units carry 6,00,000 of cost plus a quarter of the freight, 9,000, so 6,09,000 in total, before the net realisable value test.
The Double-Counting Risk
Consignment is the one arrangement where the same goods can turn up in two sets of accounts, or in none, and both happen.
On two balance sheets
The consignee counts consigned units as its ownThe goods are on its floor, so they get counted with its purchased stock. The consignor still reports them, as it should. Both stock figures are overstated, and if both borrow against stock, two lenders are relying on the same units.
On neither
The consignor books a sale on dispatchThe consignee rightly leaves the goods out; the consignor has already removed them and recognised revenue early. The units exist and appear nowhere, and the consignor's sales are overstated for the period.
Sold but not reported
The consignee sells and reports lateThe units are gone, the consignor still shows them, and the money is with the consignee. A count that only looks at what is on the floor will call this a shortage; the sales records show what it really is.
The way to catch all three is to work from the physical goods outward: each unit found is traced to whoever claims it, the claim is tested against the agreement and the sales records, and the counterparty confirms its side. A count that establishes quantity but not title has not dealt with the risk.
Verifying Consignment Stock at the Dealer's Premises
- Prepare from the consignor's side. Take the agreement, the dispatch list by serial number and the consignee's latest stock and sales statement. Agree the count date and time with the consignee in writing, under the access clause of the agreement where there is one.
- Look at segregation first. Before counting, see where the consigned goods are kept. If they share racks with the dealer's own stock of the same models, identification will depend on serial numbers alone, and the dealer's records become the thing being tested.
- Count by model, then match serials. Count the units of each model and record or scan every serial number. Match the list against the consignor's expected serials. A count that agrees in total but not by serial means units have been swapped, sold and replaced, or mixed with the dealer's own.
- Record condition. Note sealed, open-box, display, demonstration and damaged units separately. Each may need a different value, and damage while in the consignee's custody may be the consignee's to bear, depending on the agreement.
- Account for units elsewhere. Units at a service centre, at a customer's home on approval or at a sister outlet should be supported by a job sheet, a delivery note or a transfer record, and confirmed where the value justifies it.
- Reconcile and get it signed. Compare the count with the expected stock, list each difference with its explanation, and have the consignee's representative sign the count sheet so that the result is agreed, not just observed.
Checks Specific to Electronics on Consignment
Serial and IMEI
The unit, not just the boxCheck the serial on the device against the carton and the dispatch record on a sample of units. A carton label that does not match the device inside is a substitution, not a counting difference. What a serial record has to hold is set out under serial number tracking.
Display and demo units
Out of the box, still consignedA unit on the shop floor is still the consignor's. The agreement should say whether display use is allowed and who bears the loss of value; the count records which serials are on display.
Open-box returns
Back from a customer, not yet back with the consignorA customer return reverses a reported sale. It should reappear in the consignee's statement as stock; if it does not, the unit is in the shop and missing from the records.
Service centre units
Away for repair on the count dateNot on the floor, not sold. Supported by the service job sheet, and followed up if the unit has been away for longer than the repair should take.
Superseded models
Present, but worth lessElectronics lose value quickly when a model is replaced. The count notes the age of each model so the consignor can test net realisable value; the dealer's floor price is a useful signal.
Accessories and bundles
Remotes, chargers, standsA unit sold without its bundled accessories leaves loose parts behind, and a unit returned without them is incomplete. Count accessories where the agreement makes them part of the unit.
What the Consignment Agreement Should Settle
Most disputes after a count are about terms nobody wrote down. Settle these while the relationship is going well:
- When title passes, normally on sale to the end customer.
Ownership - How often the consignee reports opening stock, receipts, sales, returns and closing stock, and in what detail (model and serial).
Reporting - Who bears loss or damage while the goods are with the consignee, including display wear.
Risk - The consignor's right to count on reasonable notice, by its own staff or an independent auditor. This is the term most often left out and most often needed.
Access - Separate storage or marking of consigned goods where the consignee also stocks the same models.
Segregation - Return of unsold stock at the end of the arrangement or when a model is withdrawn.
Exit
Where there is no written agreement, the position is whatever the parties' conduct and correspondence show, which is a weak footing for both of them. If the consigned stock is also offered to a bank as security, what a lender's auditor will ask for is covered in the guide for working capital borrowers.
When your stock is spread across dealers you do not control, serial lists stop matching, or consignees' statements no longer agree with your dispatches, a stock audit for electronics and white goods can count the consignment locations with the rest of your inventory and reconcile them to one date.
