Is Physical Verification of Fixed Assets Mandatory?
No Indian statute sets a fixed timetable for verifying fixed assets. The obligation arrives indirectly, and for most companies it arrives with real force.
Through the auditor
CARO 2020, clause 3(i)(b)Where the order applies, the statutory auditor reports whether management physically verified property, plant and equipment at reasonable intervals, and whether material discrepancies were noticed and properly dealt with in the books.
Through the lender
The sanction termsA bank holding a charge over plant and machinery can ask for evidence that the security exists, on whatever terms its sanction letter sets.
Through the insurer
The declared valueCover is bought against a declared value, and an insurer settling a claim will usually expect that value to be supportable.
The duty to report sits with the auditor, but the practical duty to have done the work sits with management, because there is no comfortable answer to clause 3(i)(b) if nobody has verified. So verification is not mandatory in the way a filing deadline is mandatory. For a company that is audited under CARO 2020, financed against its plant or insured on a declared value, it is very hard to avoid.
Company law adds a second layer. Section 128(1) of the Companies Act, 2013 requires every company to keep books of account that give a true and fair view, on the accrual basis and by double entry, and section 2(13) says those books include records of the company's assets and liabilities. They must be kept for at least eight financial years (section 128(5)), although the Act itself never uses the words 'fixed asset register'. The same CARO clause, in its sub-clause 3(i)(a), also asks whether the company keeps proper records showing full particulars, including quantitative details and situation, of its property, plant and equipment, and a verification is how those particulars are kept true.
What CARO 2020 Clause 3(i)(b) Requires
CARO 2020 is the Companies (Auditor's Report) Order issued by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs on 25 February 2020 (S.O. 849(E)) under section 143(11) of the Companies Act 2013, and it applies to audits of financial years beginning on or after 1 April 2021. Clause 3(i)(b) asks the auditor three questions about property, plant and equipment.
- Were they physically verified by management at reasonable intervals? Management verifies; the auditor reports. A company that has not verified does not escape the clause; it produces an answer nobody wants.
- Were any material discrepancies noticed on that verification? The test is materiality. The clause sets no percentage at all.
- Have those discrepancies been properly dealt with in the books of account? Finding a difference and leaving it unposted is the weakest position of all, because the records then show the company knew.
This is where the most common confusion arises. The 10 per cent figure people attach to fixed assets does not belong to this clause. The inventory clause, 3(ii)(a), asks about discrepancies of 10 per cent or more in the aggregate for each class of inventory, and a 10 per cent figure in clause 3(i)(d) concerns revaluation, not verification. Importing either into clause 3(i)(b) gives the wrong test in both directions: it excuses differences that are material and flags ones that are not. Whether a discrepancy is material is a judgement against the financial statements as a whole. A handful of missing high-value machines can be material where a long list of missing low-value furniture is not.
Clause 3(i) concerns property, plant and equipment; clause 3(ii) concerns inventory. The inventory clause is explained in CARO 2020 and inventory.
What Reasonable Intervals Means in Practice
The order does not define reasonable intervals, and that is deliberate: what is reasonable for a single-site business with a hundred assets is not reasonable for a manufacturer with several plants and tens of thousands. In practice it is read as a programme that covers the whole estate over a defined and documented cycle, not as a requirement to see everything every year.
- A cycle that reaches everything. Every class and every location is reached within a stated period. A programme that simply verifies whatever is convenient has nothing to be tested against.
Defined period, full reach - Weighted by value and risk. High-value classes and assets that move easily are seen more often than low-value fixtures. Concentrating effort where the carrying value sits is not a shortcut; it is the same logic that governs sampling anywhere else.
More often where it matters - Written before the work. Coverage, basis of selection, who performs it and who reviews it are recorded in advance. A schedule reconstructed afterwards cannot show that verification happened by design rather than by accident.
Planned, not reconstructed
How such a programme is planned, sampled and reconciled stage by stage is set out in how to conduct fixed asset verification.
Who Is Outside the Order
CARO 2020 applies to companies under the Companies Act 2013, including foreign companies, with listed exclusions. LLPs, partnership firms and proprietors are outside it altogether, because it applies only to companies.
Excluded by type
Five kinds of companyBanking companies, insurance companies, section 8 companies, one person companies and small companies.
Excluded by size
Certain private companiesPrivate companies that are not a holding or subsidiary of a public company and stay within the order's limits: paid-up capital and reserves of ₹1 crore, borrowings from banks and financial institutions of ₹1 crore at any time in the year, and revenue of ₹10 crore.
Not companies
LLPs, firms and proprietorsOutside CARO 2020 entirely; any verification they carry out is driven by lenders, insurers or their own controls.
A company outside the order has no auditor's comment on fixed asset verification. What exclusion does not do is remove the reasons to verify. A lender holding a charge over plant and machinery can still ask for evidence under its sanction terms, and an insurer will still expect the declared value to stand up. Applicability is also worth re-reading each year rather than settling once: the size limits are tested for the year being audited, so a company that grows, takes on borrowing or changes status can move into the order without anybody noticing until the audit, by which time the verification either happened or did not.
What the Auditor Asks to See
Three things are asked for, and a company that cannot produce them has a reporting problem however well its assets are actually looked after.
- The verification programme and the evidence it produced. What is covered, over what period, on what basis items are selected and who does the work, written before the event; then the count sheets, dates and signatures it generated.
- The reconciliation back to the fixed asset register. What was verified, tied to the register as it stood at the cut-off. A count that was never reconciled establishes nothing about the balance in the accounts.
- The treatment of discrepancies in the books. The entries posted, with their approval. Differences identified but never posted leave the register carrying assets the company knows it does not have, and that is the point where verification stops supporting the accounts and starts contradicting them.
The CARO report forms part of the auditor's report filed with the Registrar of Companies with the financial statements, so whatever the auditor says on this clause becomes public. A lender, investor or buyer reading the accounts reads it too.
Building a Programme That Passes
Design the cycle against the size of the asset base, not the calendar. A small estate can be covered completely each year and should be. A large one is covered in phases, with high-value classes and locations reached more often, so the whole estate is verified over a defined period and every class can be shown to have been reached within it.
Evidence that survives review
What an auditor looks for before, during and after the work.
Before
- Programme written before the work
- Cycle reaches every class and site
During
- Count sheets prepared and controlled
- Dates and signatures on every sheet
After
- Results reconciled to the register
- Differences posted with approval
Programmes most often fail on the last step: the work is done and the accounts are left unchanged. A short written policy prevents that. It usually sets out which asset classes and sites are covered and how often, how items are selected, who carries out the count and who reviews it, how count sheets and the cut-off are controlled, and who approves the entries for any differences. In most companies the policy is approved by the board, or by a senior officer the board has authorised, and is reviewed when the asset base changes.
An independent verifier is worth bringing in where the estate spans several sites, where the previous cycle was not completed, or where the statutory auditor has already raised the point. A fixed asset verification carried out externally settles the coverage question and the independence question at once.
