What an Auditor Physically Inspects
An auditor inspecting fixed assets is establishing four things at each line selected: that the asset exists, what condition it is in, where it actually stands, and who is answerable for it.
Existence is the first point and the one everything else depends on, so the walk starts from the register and ends at the asset rather than the other way round. Condition matters because an asset that exists but cannot run is still carried in the books as if it can. Location and custodian matter because an asset nobody is answerable for is the one that goes missing next. Identification is tested alongside all four: whether a tag exists, whether it is readable, and whether the number on it is the number in the register. The work then runs in the opposite direction as well, selecting assets on the floor and tracing them back, which is how equipment that was never recorded comes to light.
- Exists The register line leads to a real asset on site.
- Condition Can it run, or is it carried as if it can?
- Location Where it actually stands, at a level somebody can walk to.
- Custodian Who is answerable for it.
- Identification A tag exists, is readable, and its number is the register's number.
Before the Visit: Register Readiness
Much of the friction in a verification comes from a register that was not ready, and three things make the difference.
- Populated fields. Every line needs an identifier, a description specific enough to match, a location at a level somebody can walk to, and a custodian. Lines missing any of those cannot be verified, only searched for.
- Location and custodian currency. Fields that were correct at some point in the past are worse than empty ones, because a team sent to the wrong place records an asset as not found and somebody has to investigate a difference that never existed. A quick internal review of locations before the visit removes many of the exceptions the visit would otherwise raise.
- Recent additions and disposals posted. Assets acquired since the last close and not yet recorded will be found on the floor with no register line; assets disposed of and not yet removed will be looked for and not found. Both are avoidable by closing the register to the cut-off date before anybody travels.
On the Floor: What Gets Checked Item by Item
For each line selected, the work is a short fixed sequence rather than a general inspection.
- Tag legibility and match to the register line is first: the label exists, it can be read, and the number on it is the number in the register. Each failure is recorded as its own exception type, because an unreadable tag and a wrong tag are different problems with different remedies.
Exception types: no tag · unreadable tag · wrong tag - Condition and whether the asset is in use follow. An asset in good condition but idle is recorded separately, so management can decide what to do with it. Condition is recorded against a defined scale rather than as free text, so the results can be added up afterwards.
Recorded on a defined scale, never free text - Assets present but not recorded are captured as the team walks, which requires the walk to run floor-to-register as well as register-to-floor.
Floor to register, not only register to floor - Anything on the floor with no tag and no obvious line is recorded with its description, serial number, location and a photograph, and checked afterwards against purchase and repair records.
Description · serial number · location · photograph
An unreadable tag and a wrong tag are different problems with different remedies, which is why each is its own exception type rather than one entry of "tag issue".
Capital Work-in-Progress and Assets Not Yet in Use
Capital work-in-progress is verified differently from completed assets because there is often nothing single to point at.
Case one
Stage of completion against the amount recordedWhat has physically been built, delivered or installed, set against what has been added to the account. A balance that has grown while nothing visible has changed on site is the finding this test exists to produce.
Case two
Items complete but never transferred outAn asset that is finished and in use but still recorded as capital work-in-progress is often not being depreciated, so the date it became available for use is noted for management and the auditor.
Case three
Idle and decommissioned assetsEquipment taken out of service but not disposed of is neither in use nor gone, and it needs a clear decision from management: return to use, hold as a spare, or write off.
Evidence the Auditor Retains
The working papers from a verification have to let somebody who was not there reach the same conclusion.
- Count sheets come first, showing what was selected, what was found, who performed the check and on what date, with the selection basis recorded before the walk rather than described afterwards.
- Photographs support the lines where the finding may be questioned: an asset in poor condition, an asset without a readable tag, an asset found at an address the register does not name. A photograph showing a visible identifier is worth much more than one showing a machine that could be anywhere.
- Exception lists are grouped by type rather than kept as a single list, because the accounting treatment differs by type.
- Management representations are obtained on what is left: the assets that could not be located and could not be explained. That representation is not evidence that the asset exists. It records what management states about items the verification could not resolve, so they stay visible.
The checklist in one place
Every item above, in the order it is used. Each one is explained in the section it belongs to.
Before the visit
- Identifier, description, location and custodian on every line
- Locations and custodians reviewed and current
- Additions and disposals posted; register closed to the cut-off date
At each asset
- Tag exists, is readable, matches the register line
- Condition on the defined scale; in use or idle
- Location and custodian as found
- Unrecorded items: description, serial, location, photograph
- Work-in-progress: stage against amount; finished items not transferred; idle equipment
Kept afterwards
- Count sheets with the selection basis, the checker and the date
- Photographs where a finding may be questioned
- Exception lists grouped by type
- Management representations on what could not be resolved
Using the Checklist Before the Auditor Arrives
Running the checklist yourself first turns an audit from a discovery exercise into a confirmation. Take a sample weighted toward value, walk it register-to-floor and floor-to-register, and record what you find in the same form the auditor will use. That gives you a list of differences you knew about before anybody asked, and most of them will be the findings that recur in almost every verification.
Fix what can be fixed properly: locations corrected, custodians updated, unrecorded assets recorded with the supporting invoice, tags replaced where unreadable. Disclose what cannot. Do not close a gap by changing the register to match the floor without evidence. If the exceptions are large, the register cannot be tied to the ledger, or the same items were unresolved last year, consider an independent fixed asset verification.
