Which Claims Survive Scrutiny
A claim is an entitlement only when its evidence would persuade someone who was not there; otherwise it is a request.
The claim form proves nothing on its own. It is a statement by the party being reimbursed about goods that, in a damage or expiry claim, are usually no longer available to inspect. What turns it into something an auditor can accept is evidence created outside the claimant's control and in the right order: the goods themselves or a witnessed record of their destruction, batch records tying them to a dispatch, and an approval given before disposal by someone entitled to give it.
Claims fail for a consistent set of reasons, and most can be found without visiting anyone:
- Quantity above what was ever dispatched to that party in the batches claimed.
Fails on the dispatch records - Batch numbers that never went to that territory.
Fails on batch traceability - Expiry claimed on stock still within shelf life on the date it was returned.
Fails on the date of the batch - Damage the packaging cannot have produced, such as crushed contents inside an undamaged outer case.
Fails on physical plausibility - Destruction certified after the reimbursement had already been paid.
Fails on sequence
The discipline is the order of the evidence, not the volume of paperwork. A thick file assembled after settlement proves less than one batch number checked before it.
How Damage Claims Arise
Damage claims enter the system from three directions, and each carries different evidence.
Source one
Transit and handlingCases crushed in loading, cartons soaked in an unsheeted vehicle, goods dropped at unloading. Usually raised on receipt with the transporter's acknowledgement, and easiest to substantiate when noted at the point of delivery.
Source two
Damage at trade levelFound later at a retailer or in a distributor's godown, sometimes much later, when the link to any one consignment has weakened. The claim describes a condition rather than an event.
Source three
Unsold stock turned into a claimGoods that stopped moving and are presented as damaged. Not dishonest as a class, but it is the source that a process approving claims on assertion attracts most.
The commercial pressure behind the third source is why the whole area needs discipline. A claim is a form of credit. A distributor under margin pressure, holding stock that has not moved, has an obvious incentive to turn it into a claim, and claim volumes tend to rise exactly when trading is difficult. A process that pays on assertion will see more claims every time conditions tighten; one that asks for evidence first will not.
Keep saleable returns out of this flow altogether. Goods returned in sellable condition go back into stock; mixing them into the damage population inflates the claim figures and hides stock that can still be sold.
Expiry and Near-Expiry Stock
Expiry claims are governed by policy rather than negotiation, and the policy has to exist before the stock ages.
A shelf-life and returns policy says when stock becomes returnable, who bears the cost and how much notice is needed. A policy stating that goods with less than a defined share of shelf life left may be returned within a stated window is testable; an arrangement resting on custom produces a different answer every time it is used. The policy then has to settle in whose custody the stock expired, and the dispatch records answer that:
- Sent with adequate shelf life, not sold in time. The goods expired in the distributor's custody, and the policy decides whether any of the cost comes back.
Distributor's risk, subject to the policy - Sent too close to expiry. The stock was the brand's problem from the day it was dispatched, whatever the claim says.
Brand's problem from dispatch - No dispatch date or batch on record. Neither side can show which case applies, and every expiry becomes a negotiation.
The gap the policy exists to close
The accounting runs alongside. While near-expiry goods still exist, the question is what they can still be sold for: under AS 2 and Ind AS 2 inventory is carried at the lower of cost and net realisable value, so stock that will expire unsold is written down while it is still on hand. Destruction then removes it. Two errors recur: a provision made with no record of which goods it covers, so later destruction evidence cannot be matched to it, and a second provision made for goods already destroyed and written off.
Destruction Records and Witness
Destruction is the moment goods and their value leave for good, so its evidence has to be made at the time; it cannot be rebuilt later.
- An independent witness. Someone other than the person who raised the claim and the person whose stock it was records what was destroyed, how much, by what method and on what date. Destruction certified only by the party being reimbursed is not evidence, however honest that party is.
- Photographs with legible batches. The goods before destruction with batch numbers readable, and the method being carried out, tie the certificate to identifiable stock rather than to a quantity on paper.
- A batch list on the certificate. The batches destroyed are listed, so they can be reconciled to what was dispatched to that party.
- Compliance papers for the disposal. Where a category needs a particular route or supervision, its documents go in the same file.
Until destruction, goods awaiting it are held as quarantine stock in a separate, marked area, so they cannot drift back into saleable stock or be claimed twice. Food products are subject to the Food Safety and Standards Act 2006, which is why storage conditions and remaining shelf life are recorded when they are counted. Where food is recalled, the Food Safety and Standards (Food Recall Procedure) Regulations, 2017 require food that is unfit to eat to be disposed of in consultation with the Chief Executive Officer of FSSAI, with a complete record of the disposal. Outside a recall, no specific rule requires an official to supervise the destruction of expired or damaged stock. But it must follow the waste laws that apply to the material, and a destruction record (quantities, batches, date, method, witnesses and the waste handler's receipt) should be kept.
Destroyed goods also carry a tax consequence. Under section 17(5)(h) of the CGST Act, input tax credit must be reversed on goods lost, stolen, destroyed, written off, or given as gifts or free samples, so the same destruction record supports the tax entry as well as the claim.
What Makes a Claim Verifiable
A claim becomes verifiable when three links hold.
Link one
Batch traceability to dispatchThe batches on the claimed goods appear in the dispatch records to that party, in at least the quantity claimed. This test alone disposes of a large share of disputed claims without any judgement about good faith.
Link two
A quantity that could existSupplied, less sold onward, less still in stock, sets the most that could have been damaged or expired. A claim above that ceiling is arithmetically impossible, whatever the paperwork says.
Link three
Approval before disposalGiven within the approver's authority and before the goods were destroyed. A claim approved after destruction cannot be verified by anyone, because the evidence has gone.
An example with invented figures: a distributor received 1,200 cases of one batch, reports secondary sales of 950 cases and holds 180 at the count. At most 70 cases of that batch can be damaged or expired, so a claim for 140 cases fails on arithmetic before anyone looks at a photograph.
Where all three links hold, the claim is supported. Where any one fails, it rests on the claimant's word, which is exactly what the process exists to avoid relying on.
Tightening the Claims Process
Ask for the evidence before approval, because the goods stop existing once the claim is settled and no later diligence brings them back.
- Batch numbers on every claim, matched against what was dispatched to that party.
- A quantity that reconciles to supply, less onward sales, less stock held.
- Photographs of the goods in the condition claimed, batch codes legible, taken before disposal.
Then verify a sample physically rather than trying to check every claim. A published policy that a share of claims will be inspected before settlement, applied genuinely and at random, changes behaviour across the whole population far more than exhaustive checking of a few. Weight the sample toward larger claims and toward parties whose claim rate is above the norm; the principles are those of any audit sample selection.
The claim file in one place
Every item above, in the order it is used. Each is explained in the section it belongs to.
On the claim
- Batch numbers and quantities
- Reason: transit, trade damage or expiry
- Photographs taken before disposal
Checked before approval
- Batches traced to dispatch to that party
- Quantity within supply less sales less stock
- Expiry against dispatch date and policy
- Approver acting within authority
At destruction
- Independent witness record
- Batch list on the certificate
- Disposal compliance papers where required
- Input tax credit reversal entry
Once a claim is approved and the goods destroyed, the stock write-off closes the record. Independent verification is worth commissioning before that point when claim volumes have risen with no matching cause, when one territory stands out from the rest, or when a disputed claim involves a relationship that matters. An FMCG stock audit can then test the claims population alongside a count of the stock behind it.
