Auditing Stock You Do Not Hold
Secondary stock is finished goods that a brand has invoiced to its distributors and that now sit in their godowns, waiting to be sold on to retailers.
Verifying it is unusual audit work: the brand counts goods on somebody else's premises, recorded in somebody else's books. The reason to do it is commercial. A sale to a distributor moves stock into a pipeline; it does not show that a consumer bought anything. A brand that reads its performance from dispatches alone cannot tell real growth from a channel quietly filling up. The count also protects the claims process, because damage, expiry and scheme claims are all raised against stock the brand otherwise has to take on trust.
What the exercise can establish is what is physically present at each distributor visited, its age and batch profile, how much of it can no longer be sold, and whether it agrees with what the distributor itself reports. That is a useful amount of information about stock the brand cannot otherwise see.
Read a distributor count as a picture of the channel on one date, never as a measure of what consumers bought. Goods already moved on to retailers are outside it, and treating the count as offtake is the mistake this work most often invites.
Primary Against Secondary Stock
Everything in channel verification rests on keeping two kinds of stock apart, and confusing them gives a view of the business that is consistently too optimistic.
Primary stock
In the brand's own depotsNot yet sold, carried in the brand's inventory, and known precisely because the brand keeps the records. Stock held by its carrying and forwarding agents on its behalf belongs here too.
Secondary stock
At the distributor, after invoicingShown as sold in the brand's books and held in the distributor's godown, so its quantity is only what the distributor reports.
Retail offtake
Sold on to shops and consumersThe demand the brand actually wants to measure, and the one figure that neither primary nor secondary stock shows directly.
When stock stops being the brand's inventory is a question for the terms of sale in the distribution agreement and the accounting standards the brand reports under. Under an outright sale, the goods leave the brand's inventory when ownership passes, which under section 19 of the Sale of Goods Act, 1930 is when the parties intend it to, so the agreement and delivery terms decide, not the invoice alone. Goods sent on sale-or-return terms stay the brand's until the distributor accepts them, acts as owner or keeps them past the agreed period (section 24), and goods on consignment stay the brand's until the distributor sells them, which is also how Ind AS 115 treats a consignment.
The practical consequence does not wait for that answer. A quarter of strong primary sales can coincide with a channel filling up while consumers buy less, and the brand's own figures will show growth the whole time. The correction comes later, as returns, claims, discounts to clear the channel, or a quarter with almost no primary sales. The distributor's reported secondary sales are meant to warn of this, and verifying secondary stock is how a brand finds out whether those reports can be believed.
Right of Access and Cooperation
Counting a distributor's stock means asking for access to a business the brand does not run, so the basis for the visit is the first question, not an afterthought.
The distribution agreement is the governing document. A well-drafted agreement lets the brand verify stock on reasonable notice, requires the distributor to keep stock and sales records in a stated form, and obliges cooperation with the brand's representatives or an auditor acting for it. Where the agreement says nothing, the visit is a favour and the distributor may decline it. Three clauses decide what is possible:
- A verification clause giving the right to count stock on stated notice, at the main premises and at any other godown the distributor uses.
Read before scheduling anything - A record-keeping clause requiring stock and secondary sales to be kept in a form a count can be reconciled to.
Without it there is nothing to compare against - A cooperation clause covering access for the brand's own staff or an independent auditor appointed by the brand.
Settles who may attend
Notice is a practical negotiation. An announced visit is easier to arrange and gets a cooperative count, but it leaves time to tidy the position; short notice gives a more representative picture and more friction. Many programmes announce the cycle of visits without announcing the date of each.
Plan for a refusal before it happens rather than improvising one. A refusal is information in itself, particularly where the distributor's reported figures were already in question, and the responses available, from escalation within the distributor's management to holding back further supplies, depend entirely on what the agreement provides.
Counting Across a Distributor Network
A network of hundreds of distributors cannot be counted in full, so the design of the sample carries the credibility of the whole exercise.
- Value first. The largest distributors are chosen because that is where the stock, and the exposure, sits.
- Risk next. Distributors whose reported positions have been inconsistent, whose claim rates are rising, or whose reported sales look out of line with their purchases.
- Time since the last visit. Anyone not visited within a set period is added, so no part of the network goes unexamined indefinitely.
- Spread. Selections across regions and trade formats, so the sample describes the network rather than one market.
Simultaneous counting matters wherever stock can move between the parties being compared. Distributors that supply each other, or a distributor and its sub-stockists, are counted on the same date: in a staggered count the same cartons can be counted at two premises or missed at both, and goods turning up at two distributors is a known pattern in a channel under pressure. The selection logic behind any such sample is explained in how auditors select items without counting everything.
The count becomes useful when it is reconciled. Opening stock, plus goods supplied, less secondary sales reported, gives the stock that should be on the premises. Set against the stock found, it shows whether the reported offtake is real. A distributor reporting strong secondary sales while holding stock consistent with almost none is the finding the whole exercise exists for.
What a Distributor Count Reveals
A count at the distributor's premises establishes three things the brand cannot otherwise see.
Finding one
Stock on hand against stock reportedDistributors report holdings for scheme calculations, replenishment and forecasts. Consistent overstatement flatters the brand's view of the channel; consistent understatement usually comes with an urgent request for more supply.
Finding two
Age and near-expiry profileChannel stock ages out of the brand's sight. Recording batch and date at the count puts a figure on stock close to expiry, which is a claim not yet raised rather than a sale achieved.
Finding three
Damaged and unsaleable goods on siteDamaged goods are often held rather than reported, because reporting starts a claim. The count is frequently the first time the brand sees the quantity.
All three answer one question: how much of what was invoiced can still be sold. That is why the count records more than quantity. A count sheet that captures batch, expiry date and condition alongside the number of cases can be turned into an exposure figure; one that records cases alone cannot.
What one distributor visit records
Every item above, in the order it is used. Each is explained in the section it belongs to.
Before the visit
- Agreement clause that allows the count
- Latest reported stock and secondary sales
- Goods supplied since the last reconciliation
At the premises
- Cases counted by product and batch
- Expiry dates captured against each batch
- Damaged and unsaleable goods counted apart
- Stock at any other godown the distributor uses
Afterwards
- Expected stock reconciled to stock found
- Over- or understatement by product
- Near-expiry and damaged quantities as exposure
Commissioning a Distributor Audit
Three decisions shape a distributor audit before anybody travels: scope, notice and coverage.
- Scope settles whether the work counts stock only or also tests claims, scheme calculations and secondary sales reporting. The wider scope is usually what the brand needs, because a count alone cannot say why a figure is wrong.
Count only, or count plus claims and schemes - Notice is weighed as set out under access above, and decided before the first visit so every distributor is treated alike.
One rule for the whole cycle - Coverage follows value and risk rather than an even spread across the network.
Largest and longest-unvisited first
Use the exercise to fix the agreement for next time. A clause allowing verification on reasonable notice, a stated frequency for stock and secondary sales reports, and defined evidence requirements for claims remove most of the friction for good.
Who does the counting matters as much as how. A distributor will rarely accept a count made by the brand's own sales team where the result affects claims or scheme payouts, and the sales team has targets of its own riding on the figure. Where the findings will be used in those discussions, an independent FMCG stock audit gives both sides a count that neither of them produced.
