The Six Parts of the Deliverable
A verification report has six parts, and a reader should be able to find each one without searching. The order below is the order in which a reader needs them.
- Scope. Which locations and which asset classes were covered, and which were not, named rather than left to be inferred.
- Method. How lines were selected, whether the walk ran from register to floor, from floor to register or both, and what evidence was captured at each asset.
- Date and coverage. When the work was done, the cut-off it describes, and what share of register value and of register lines it reached.
- Findings. Three populations reported separately: assets found and agreed, register lines not found, and assets found with no register line, plus condition observations.
- Reconciled difference. What the three populations do to the carrying value in the register, tied back to the opening figure.
- Treatment and sign-off. The corrections recommended for management to approve, and the signature block saying who did the work and on what basis.
The main body carries the exceptions, not every matched line. The full verified schedule, often thousands of lines, belongs in an annexure where it can be searched; putting it in the body buries the few findings that need action. Where CARO 2020 applies, the report is also the evidence the statutory auditor will look at when answering clause 3(i)(b), whether property, plant and equipment were physically verified at reasonable intervals and material discrepancies properly dealt with, so it is kept with the year's audit file rather than filed away.
The Scope and Method Statement
The opening section tells the reader what the report covers, and it decides how much weight everything after it can carry. A report silent about a location invites the assumption that the location was visited.
- Sites and classes covered, and those excluded. Each exclusion is named with its reason: a site being closed, a class verified through another process, items below a stated value.
Exclusions named, never implied - Coverage by value and by lines. On a skewed register the two figures are usually very different, so both are stated; quoting only the flattering one misrepresents the work.
Two figures, side by side - A selection method someone else could repeat. The value above which every item was examined, how the rest was divided into bands, and what was added by judgement.
Reproducible, not described afterwards - The cut-off date and movement during fieldwork. A verification describes a position at a moment. Where the work ran over several days, the report says how assets that moved in that window were treated.
A date, not a period
The sampling basis is reported wherever full coverage was not achieved. How that basis is chosen in the first place, and how the verification is planned and sampled, is a separate guide; the report only has to state it clearly enough to be tested.
The Exception Listing
The exception listing is the substance of the report. It holds three populations that must never be merged, because they have opposite accounting effects and a net figure hides both.
Population one
In the register, not locatedListed line by line with asset code, description, carrying value, recorded location, custodian and the search made. A count without values says nothing about materiality, and a total is not enough evidence for a write-off decision.
Population two
Located, not in the registerEach described well enough to be found again: make, model and serial number where they exist, location, and a photograph where the description is not distinctive. These are possible additions, not losses.
Population three
Agreed, but condition does not support the valueIdle equipment, assets awaiting disposal and visibly damaged items, each with its carrying value beside the observation, so management can consider whether the value still holds.
Identification exceptions sit alongside these: tags missing or unreadable, lines whose description is too vague to match a unit, locations and custodians that were out of date. They are listed by type because each type has a different remedy. CARO 2020 clause 3(i)(a) asks whether proper records are kept showing full particulars, including quantitative details and situation, of property, plant and equipment, and these are the exceptions that speak to it. What usually fills each list is described in the eight findings that recur in verifications.
The exception listing on one page
What each line of each list carries, so it can be acted on without going back to site.
Not located
- Asset code and description
- Carrying value
- Recorded location and custodian
- Where and how it was searched for
Not in the register
- Description, make, model, serial
- Location found and custodian
- Photograph where needed
- Purchase or project record, if traced
Condition and identification
- Idle, awaiting disposal or damaged
- Carrying value beside the observation
- Tag missing, unreadable or wrong
- Description too vague to match
Sign-Off, UDIN and Who Signs
The sign-off block is short, and it is usually checked before anybody reads the findings. Where a Chartered Accountant signs, the block carries the name and signature of the partner or proprietor taking responsibility for the engagement, with the date and place of signing. It also shows the firm's name with the words 'Chartered Accountants', the firm registration number allotted by ICAI (required on all attestation reports and certificates issued on or after 1 October 2010), the signer's designation as partner or proprietor, and their ICAI membership number.
The UDIN, the Unique Document Identification Number, is written after the signature and membership number. It is generated by the signing Chartered Accountant on the ICAI portal and quoted on the document. ICAI has required it on all certificates since 1 February 2019, on GST and tax audit reports since 1 April 2019, and on all other audit, assurance and attestation reports since 1 July 2019. Its purpose is external checking: a reader enters the number on the UDIN portal and compares the particulars returned with the document in hand, which confirms that the member named actually issued it.
- The signature block names who signed and in what capacity, and the field team is identified separately so the reader knows who performed the work.
Who stands behind it - The UDIN is checked against the portal before the findings are considered.
Can it be verified? - The template, where a lender or a group finance team has issued one, is compared with the report's layout. Where a lender keeps a panel of approved firms, it also confirms the signatory is on it.
Is it in the expected shape?
What Makes a Report Get Sent Back
Reports come back for three reasons, and all three are avoidable while the report is being drafted.
- No reconciliation. A report that lists what was found and what was not, without tying both back to the opening register, leaves the reader to do the arithmetic, and the reader commissioned the work precisely so as not to.
- Exceptions stated but not valued. "Thirty assets could not be located" means nothing until their carrying value appears beside it: thirty fully depreciated chairs and thirty items of plant are different problems. Without values the reader cannot judge what is material.
- The wrong shape. Where a template has been issued, a report in another layout can be returned unread, however sound the work. The recipient's own process expects particular fields in particular places, and a report that does not supply them cannot be processed.
The quickest test before a report goes out: can someone who was not on site take the opening register value, add and subtract the three populations, and arrive at the closing figure the report states?
Reading Your Own Report
When the report arrives, sort its findings into three piles before responding to any of them, because they need different people and different timetables.
Pile one
Needs a book entryWrite-offs of assets not located, additions of assets found, values to be reconsidered. They have a deadline set by the reporting calendar, and they belong to finance.
Pile two
Needs a process changeMovements not recorded, disposals not notified, custodians never updated, tags not maintained. They have no deadline unless one is set, which is why they recur; they belong to whoever runs the sites.
Pile three
You think the finding is wrongSettle it now, with evidence: an invoice, a transfer note, a photograph. Left alone, it comes back as the same finding next year.
The CARO report forms part of the auditor's report filed with the Registrar of Companies, so how the first pile is handled before the year end is visible to anyone who reads the accounts. A follow-up is worth commissioning where the first report could not reach a material part of the estate, where the corrections were large enough to need independent confirmation, or where a lender has asked for one. A fixed asset verification by an independent team re-tests exactly those areas.
