Talk to an expert

Tell us what you need and we will call you back.

🇮🇳 +91

    Stock audit glossary · Textiles

    Seconds and Rejects

    noun · seconds are also called B-grade goods; rejects are sold as waste or scrap

    Definition

    Seconds are goods with a defect that still leaves them saleable at a reduced price; rejects fail specification so badly that they cannot be sold as the intended product. The line between them is a valuation line: seconds are carried at what the discount channel will pay, rejects at scrap or recovery value. Recording them together hides which of the two the stock really is.

    • Reviewed by CA Sundram Gupta · Chartered Accountant
    • Last reviewed 23 October 2026
    • 6 min read

    See related terms

    At a glance

    Seconds
    Flawed but saleable At a reduced price
    Rejects
    Not saleable as the product Material with a recovery value
    Valued at
    What each grade will realise Where that is below cost
    Graded
    At inspection, on the line Not weeks later at the count
    Kept
    Under separate codes And in separate places

    Meaning

    01 What seconds and rejects are

    Production always yields some output short of specification; the useful question is by how much. Goods with a visible flaw that a buyer will accept at a lower price are still merchandise, sold through outlets, discount channels or bulk buyers. Goods that fail outright are not merchandise at all; they are material with a recovery value.

    Grouping the two is where valuation goes wrong, because they sit at opposite ends of the range and their average describes neither. Under AS 2 and Ind AS 2, inventory is carried at the lower of cost and net realisable value, so seconds come down to what the discount channel actually pays and rejects to scrap or reprocessing value. There is a control angle too: graded-down output leaves the normal sales flow, so a reject rate that climbs with no change in the process deserves a closer look.

    Where it arises

    02 Where seconds have a market, and where they do not

    The terms matter where flawed goods can still be sold.

    Where seconds have a market

    • Textiles and garments. A weaving fault or stitching flaw still leaves a saleable article.
    • Tiles, sanitaryware and crockery. Output is graded into quality bands sold at different prices.
    • Footwear and leather goods. Cosmetic marks are often accepted at a discount.

    Where there is little middle ground

    • Machined components. A part meets tolerance or it is scrap.
    • Food and medicines. Goods failing specification cannot be sold at any price.
    • Specification chemicals. An off-specification batch is reprocessed or disposed of.
    Same cost, very different value. A first, a second and a reject cost the same to make; only the grade says what each is worth.

    In practice

    03 How seconds and rejects are handled in practice

    UnitsLower unit valueCarried at
    Input Where it comes from Sample
    Units graded as seconds The quality inspection record for the run 960
    Unit cost (INR) Production cost of the run 420
    Realisable price (INR) What earlier seconds sold for, less selling costs 250
    Carrying value (INR) 960 at 250, the lower figure 2,40,000

    960 × 250 = 2,40,000, against 4,03,200 at cost. Sample figures for illustration only.

    From inspection to disposal

    1. Inspect at a set point

      Output is checked against the quality specification, and failures are pulled from the main flow.

    2. Classify each failure

      A cosmetic or minor defect a buyer will accept makes a second; a unit that cannot serve its purpose is a reject.

    3. Separate and code

      Seconds and rejects are stored apart and recorded under different codes.

    4. Value each grade

      Seconds at what the clearance route returns, backed by earlier disposals; rejects at recovery value.

    5. Watch the rates

      A failure rate rising with no process change is followed up, and disposal routes are documented so value cannot leave outside the sales ledger.

    Worked example

    04 One production run, three grades

    Sample figures.

    One run of shirts graded at the end of the line; every unit cost 420 to make
    Grade Units and basis Carrying value (INR)
    First quality, sells at 690 8,400 at cost 35,28,000
    Seconds, sell at 250 960, written down 2,40,000
    Rejects, sold by weight at 40 310, written down 12,400
    Total 9,670 units 37,80,400

    At cost, the run would be overstated by 2,81,000

    Carried at the 420 production cost, the 9,670 units would show 40,61,400, which is 2,81,000 more than they will bring in, because seconds and rejects sell below cost. Seconds still recover far more than scrap; rejects are sold as material.

    The grading has to happen on the line and travel with the stock record. A count taken weeks later cannot reliably tell a second from a first, so an ungraded heap is either valued too high or argued over.

    Watch out

    05 Common mistakes with seconds and rejects

    Most errors start with mixing two very different values.

    One heading for both grades

    A blended value fits neither.

    Code seconds and rejects separately.

    Rejects at absorbed cost

    Material worth scrap is carried as product.

    Value rejects at what the material recovers.

    Hopeful grading

    Goods graded as seconds sit unsold for years.

    Test each grade against actual disposals.

    Missing a rising reject rate

    A control problem is read as a quality problem.

    Track the rate and ask why it moves.

    Informal disposal

    Value leaves without passing through the sales ledger.

    Sell rejects through documented, invoiced routes.

    Seconds that compete with firsts

    Recovery on seconds costs sales on the main range.

    Use a channel that reaches different buyers.
    CA Sundram Gupta

    Reviewed by CA Sundram Gupta · Chartered Accountant

    Patron Accounting LLP. Statements on AS 2 and Ind AS 2 on this page signed off by CA Sundram Gupta: 23 October 2026

    Last reviewed: 23 October 2026 Applies to: textile, garment and other manufacturers that grade output into first quality, seconds and rejects

    Sources: AS 2 and Ind AS 2, Inventories (ICAI). General information, not professional advice; check the current position for your business before acting.

    Need help with seconds and rejects? See our textile stock audit service. A textile stock audit counts first quality, seconds and rejects under separate codes.

    Talk to an expert

    Tell us what you need and the right person calls you back.

    🇮🇳 +91

      By sending this form you agree to our privacy policy.