No fixed timetable
No statute fixes how often inventory must be counted; CARO 2020 asks whether it was verified at reasonable intervals.
CARO 2020 (MCA order)Stock audit glossary · Counting methods
noun · in Hindi, भौतिक सत्यापन (bhautik satyapan)
Physical verification means checking, by actually seeing and counting, that the stock or assets in the books really exist, in the quantity, condition and place the records show. It is different from reconciliation, which only compares one record with another and can be done from a desk. In a stock audit it is the step that turns a figure in the register into evidence.
Meaning
A stock record is only a claim. A system that has been told an item exists will keep reporting it whether or not the item is still on the rack. Someone has to go and look, and physical verification is that visit: the goods are counted, inspected and located, and the result is compared with the books.
It checks more than presence. Damaged or unsaleable goods do not support their book value, and an item nobody can find is not available, whatever the record says. It also works in two directions. Going from the record to the goods finds what has gone missing; going from the goods to the record finds what was never entered. Only the second direction catches goods received but never booked.
On the day
Verification is a record of what was seen, not of what was reported.
In practice
Take a copy of the stock records at a cut-off date, so the figures do not change while the work goes on.
Give most weight to high-value items, which are often checked in full.
From the records to the goods, and from the goods back to the records.
Note condition, location and custodian at the same time as the quantity.
Recount differences, reconcile to the frozen records and report anything unresolved with its value.
Worked example
Sample figures; no client is described.
| Location | Book / counted | Difference |
|---|---|---|
| Main store | 4,180 / 4,166 | −14 units, ₹1,26,000 |
| Bonded area | 900 / 900 | Nil |
| Shop floor (work in progress) | 610 / 648 | +38 units, ₹2,58,000 |
| Despatch bay | 320 / 296 | −24 units, ₹2,16,000 |
Added together, the four lines show no difference in units at all (−14 + 0 + 38 − 24 = 0) and a net shortage of only ₹84,000. Read line by line, they show a surplus on the shop floor next to a shortage at the despatch bay, which usually means goods were moved but the movement was never posted.
That is why each location is reported separately, and by value as well as quantity. A netted figure would have closed the count without anyone asking where the despatch-bay goods went.
Framework
No statute sets a fixed timetable for counting stock. For companies covered by the Companies (Auditor’s Report) Order, 2020 (CARO 2020), the auditor reports on whether management verified inventory, how well and how often. The duty to verify sits with management; the duty to report sits with the auditor.
No statute fixes how often inventory must be counted; CARO 2020 asks whether it was verified at reasonable intervals.
CARO 2020 (MCA order)Under clause 3(ii)(a) the auditor reports whether the coverage and procedure of management’s verification were appropriate.
CARO 2020 (MCA order)The auditor reports whether discrepancies of 10% or more in aggregate for each class of inventory were noticed and properly dealt with in the books.
CARO 2020 (MCA order)Watch out
Most failed verifications were counted, just not counted properly.
Going from records to goods never finds stock that was never entered.
Receipts and issues posted during the count make the book figure a moving target.
Damaged or obsolete goods are counted as if they were sound.
The people answerable for the stock are checking themselves.
Surpluses in one place hide shortages in another.
Differences are accepted that a second count would have cleared or confirmed.
Questions
Freeze the stock records at a cut-off date and take a copy. Count the items, giving most attention to high-value lines, and check both from the records to the goods and from the goods to the records. Note the condition and location of what you find, recount any differences, reconcile the count to the frozen records and report anything unresolved with its value.
It runs in three stages. Before the count, the records are frozen and the items to be checked are chosen. On the day, the goods are counted and inspected, with condition and location noted. Afterwards, differences are recounted, reconciled to the frozen records and reported by location and by value, so that nothing is netted away.
Patron Accounting LLP. Statements on CARO 2020 on this page signed off by CA Sundram Gupta: 23 October 2026
Sources: Companies (Auditor’s Report) Order, 2020, clause 3(ii)(a) (MCA). General information, not professional advice; check the current position before acting.
Need help with physical verification? See our stock audit service. A stock audit is built on physical verification.