Sufficient and appropriate
The auditor must obtain sufficient, appropriate audit evidence: enough of it, and relevant and reliable.
Standards on Auditing on ICAIStock audit glossary · Records and evidence
noun · the subject of Standard on Auditing 500
Audit evidence is the information an auditor uses to reach a conclusion. It must be sufficient, meaning there is enough of it, and appropriate, meaning it is relevant and reliable. In a stock audit it includes the count sheets, the stock register, purchase and sale records and what the auditor sees on the floor. Evidence the auditor obtains first-hand, such as stock counted personally, is generally more reliable than records the business prepares about itself.
Meaning
Audit evidence is anything that helps an auditor decide whether a figure or a statement is right. For a stock balance that means the count sheets written on the day, the stock register, purchase invoices, delivery records, confirmations from warehouses holding goods, and what the auditor sees on the racks. Two questions decide what each piece is worth: is there enough of it, and is it good enough?
The two answers work together rather than replacing each other. A large pile of weak material does not become strong because there is a lot of it, and one strong document may still cover too little of the stock to support a conclusion. This is why attending the physical count matters so much in a stock audit: it is one of the few procedures where the auditor produces the evidence directly, instead of reading a record the business has prepared.
In the file
The value of evidence depends on who produced it and how it reached the file.
In practice
For stock: that it exists, that the business owns it, that it is in usable condition and that its value is supportable.
Attending the count for existence, purchase records for ownership, inspection for condition, selling prices for value.
First-hand and outside evidence counts for more than internal records and spoken answers.
A large or high-risk balance needs more and better evidence than a small, routine one.
The working papers should let a person who was not present reach the same conclusion.
Worked example
One verification, five sources, ranked by who produced them.
| Source | Strength | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Auditor’s own count | Strongest | Obtained directly by the auditor |
| Confirmation from a third-party warehouse | Strong | Comes from outside the business |
| Supplier invoice from the trader’s file | Moderate | Made outside, but kept by the trader |
| Stock register printout | Weaker | Made by the business being checked |
| Spoken assurance from the storekeeper | Weakest | Not written down, not backed up |
Take a stock verification at a steel trader, where all five sources describe the same stock. A neatly printed register can still be the weakest paper in the file, because the business under review produced it.
If the register and the count disagree, the count is usually preferred unless there is a specific reason to doubt it. A difference supported only by the last two rows will not stand up in review, so the auditor looks for stronger support before leaving the site.
Framework
The rule comes from Standard on Auditing (SA) 500, Audit Evidence, issued by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India. SA 500 requires the auditor to obtain sufficient, appropriate audit evidence and explains which sources are generally more reliable. These are general guides applied with judgement, not a fixed ranking: a poorly controlled outside source can be weaker than a well-controlled internal record.
The auditor must obtain sufficient, appropriate audit evidence: enough of it, and relevant and reliable.
Standards on Auditing on ICAIOutside sources over internal ones, evidence obtained directly over indirectly, written over spoken, originals over copies.
Standards on Auditing on ICAIInspection, observation, external confirmation, recalculation, reperformance, analytical procedures and inquiry, usually in combination; inquiry alone is ordinarily not enough.
SA 500 text on ICAIWatch out
Most failures are about the quality of the evidence, not the quantity.
A large pile of weak evidence is still weak.
The report only repeats what was entered.
The more reliable version is set aside for convenience.
A management statement records a claim, not a fact.
The file looks full while the large, risky balance has little support.
A schedule the business prepared is still its own record, however it was requested.
Questions
SA 500 describes seven ways of obtaining audit evidence: inspection of records or assets, observation (for example, watching a stock count), external confirmation, recalculation, reperformance, analytical procedures and inquiry. They are normally used together, and asking questions on its own is ordinarily not enough to support a conclusion.
A count sheet completed by the auditor while counting the stock is a common example. Others are a confirmation sent straight to the auditor by a warehouse holding the goods, and the supplier invoices showing the business bought them. Of these, the count sheet is usually the strongest because the auditor produced it directly.
Patron Accounting LLP. Statements on SA 500 on this page signed off by CA Sundram Gupta: 23 October 2026
Sources: Standard on Auditing 500, Audit Evidence (ICAI; SA 500 text). General information, not professional advice; check the current position before acting.
Need help with audit evidence? See our stock audit service. A stock audit gathers first-hand evidence of the stock on the floor.