Blaming buying for every miss
Many misses are lines the system wrongly shows in stock.
Stock audit glossary · Quick commerce and distribution
noun · also called fill rate or order completeness
Order fill rate is the share of customer orders supplied in full from stock, with no line short, substituted or left waiting. It measures availability, not correctness: an order that arrives complete but with a wrong item still counts as filled, which is why it is read alongside pick accuracy. When it falls while the system shows plenty of stock, the stock record itself is often wrong.
Meaning
Availability and correctness fail for different reasons, and fill rate exists to isolate the first. An order picked perfectly but missing one line lowers the fill rate and leaves pick accuracy untouched; an order complete in quantity but carrying a wrong item does the opposite. A business that tracks only one of the two will keep fixing the wrong part of its operation.
The measure also depends on the stock record being right. A line the system shows as available but which is not on the shelf produces a failed pick and a fill-rate miss, and the cause is record accuracy, not buying. A line on the shelf but recorded at the wrong location is just as unavailable in practice. So a fill rate reported with no recent count behind it describes the system rather than the shelf, and a fall in it is often the first sign of phantom stock.
Where it is used
Who watches it, and what a drop tells them.
In practice
Before any amendment; measuring against a revised order hides the failures.
Complete, short, substituted or unavailable.
Substitutions are excluded, because the customer did not get what was ordered.
Shown as available but absent is a record problem; shown as zero is a buying problem.
Availability and correctness fail independently, so one without the other misleads.
Worked example
Sample figures.
| Measured by | Calculation | Fill rate |
|---|---|---|
| Orders complete | 8,640 of 10,000 | 86.4% |
| Lines supplied in full | 43,900 of 46,000 | 95.4% |
| Units supplied | 1,84,000 of 1,90,000 | 96.8% |
| Value supplied (INR) | 4,62,00,000 of 4,80,00,000 | 96.3% |
Order fill is the harshest, because one missing line fails the whole order, and it is the one the customer experiences. Unit fill is the kindest and the one most often quoted inside the business. A distributor reporting 96.8% while its customers experience 86.4% has a reporting problem before it has a supply problem.
Which basis applies should be written into the supply agreement, because the gap between them widens as orders carry more lines.
Watch out
Most of these point the fix at the wrong part of the operation.
Many misses are lines the system wrongly shows in stock.
The figure flatters the service the customer received.
The shortfalls are edited out before they are counted.
Nobody can tell a stock problem from a picking one.
The rate describes the database, not the aisle.
Steady lines hide the ones customers could not get.
Question
Divide the number of orders supplied in full from stock by the number of orders received in the same period, and multiply by 100. For example, 8,640 complete orders out of 10,000 gives 86.4%. Count an order as filled only if every line was supplied in the quantity ordered, without substitution, and measure against the order as it was first placed.
It is the percentage of customer orders that a business supplies complete from the stock it holds. It shows how often a customer gets everything they ordered first time, and a sudden fall is often an early sign that stock records and shelves no longer agree.
There is no single good figure. The right target depends on the product, the number of lines in a typical order and what the customer has been promised, and it is often written into the supply agreement. Two things matter more than the number: the basis it is measured on (orders, lines, units or value) and whether a recent count stands behind the stock data it relies on.
OTIF means on time in full: an order counts only if it is complete and arrives by the agreed date. Fill rate looks at completeness alone. An order delivered complete but two days late passes fill rate and fails OTIF, so OTIF is always the same or lower than the order fill rate for the same orders.
Patron Accounting LLP. This page makes no regulatory statement.
Sources: general stock-counting and trade practice; no statutory statement is made on this page. General information, not professional advice.
Need help with order fill rate? See our dark store stock audit service. A dark store stock audit tests whether the stock record behind the fill rate is right.