Glossary · Audit & Assurance
Disclaimer of Opinion
Definition
A disclaimer of opinion is an audit report in which the auditor states that it does not express an opinion on the financial statements, because it could not obtain enough appropriate evidence and the possible effect of what it could not check is both material and pervasive. Along with an adverse opinion, it is one of the two most serious audit outcomes, and it tells readers the accounts could not be verified.
At a glance
- Category
- Audit & Assurance
- Main provision
- SA 705 (Revised)
- In this entry
- How it works in an audit Where the law or the standard sets it · A simple example
In detail
01 How it works in an audit
A modified opinion comes from one of two problems: the accounts are misstated, or the auditor could not get the evidence. A disclaimer belongs to the second kind.
| Problem | Effect material, not pervasive | Effect material and pervasive |
|---|---|---|
| Accounts misstated | Qualified opinion | Adverse opinion |
| Evidence not obtained | Qualified opinion | Disclaimer of opinion |
"Pervasive" means the effect is not limited to one item; it could touch many parts of the accounts, or it is so central that it undermines the whole set.
Common causes are records destroyed or missing, management refusing access to key information, or many balances that cannot be confirmed. The report replaces the opinion paragraph with a disclaimer, and the basis section explains what could not be checked. When the auditor disclaims an opinion, key audit matters are not reported unless law or regulation requires it.
The provision
02 Where the law or the standard sets it
Modified opinions, including the disclaimer, are governed by SA 705 (Revised), Modifications to the Opinion in the Independent Auditor's Report, issued by ICAI. The auditor disclaims an opinion when sufficient appropriate evidence cannot be obtained and the possible effects of undetected misstatements could be both material and pervasive (paragraph 9); the Opinion section is then headed 'Disclaimer of Opinion' (paragraph 16).
Worked example
03 A simple example
An example, not advice on your facts.
A company's accounting server failed in January and the backups were incomplete. Sales, purchase and stock records for eight months cannot be reconstructed, and customers and suppliers did not reply to confirmations. The auditor cannot test revenue, receivables, payables or stock. Because these touch almost every figure, it issues a disclaimer: "We do not express an opinion on the accompanying financial statements..."
In detail
04 Why it matters to a company
A disclaimer is read as a red flag by banks, investors, tax officers and counterparties. It can trigger loan covenants and make fund-raising or tenders difficult. Most disclaimers come from missing records or restricted access, which a company controls. Keeping backups, reconciling regularly and giving the auditor full access are the practical safeguards.
Review and sources
Sources: ICAI Checklist on Standards on Auditing (22 Jun 2023): SA 705 (Revised), SA 701.
