Talk to an expert

Tell us what you need and we will call you back.

🇮🇳 +91

    Glossary · Audit & Assurance

    Adverse Opinion

    Definition

    An adverse opinion is an audit report in which the auditor concludes that the financial statements do not give a true and fair view, because misstatements in them are both material and pervasive. The auditor had enough evidence; the evidence showed the accounts are wrong in ways that affect them as a whole.

    • Written by CA Suyash Agrawal, reviewed by CA Puja Pradhan

    Read the full entry

    At a glance

    Category
    Audit & Assurance
    Main provision
    SA 705 (Revised)
    In this entry
    How it works in an audit Where the law or the standard sets it · A simple example

    In detail

    01 How it works in an audit

    An adverse opinion is one of the three kinds of modified opinion. Which one applies depends on the nature of the problem and how widely it spreads:

    ProblemMaterial, not pervasiveMaterial and pervasive
    Accounts misstatedQualified opinionAdverse opinion
    Evidence not obtainedQualified opinionDisclaimer of opinion

    "Pervasive" means the effect is not confined to one item, or it is so central, such as the basis of preparation itself, that the accounts as a whole are misleading.

    In the report, the opinion section says the statements "do not give a true and fair view", and a "Basis for Adverse Opinion" section explains each matter and, where practicable, its financial effect. An adverse opinion is rare: most disagreements are resolved by the company correcting the accounts before the report is signed.

    The provision

    02 Where the law or the standard sets it

    Modified opinions, including the adverse opinion, are governed by SA 705 (Revised), Modifications to the Opinion in the Independent Auditor's Report, read with SA 700 (Revised), Forming an Opinion and Reporting on Financial Statements. Both are issued by ICAI. Under SA 705 (Revised), the Opinion section is headed "Adverse Opinion", the section explaining it is headed "Basis for Adverse Opinion", and the auditor states that, because of the significance of the matters described there, the financial statements do not give a true and fair view in accordance with the applicable financial reporting framework.

    Worked example

    03 A simple example

    An example, not advice on your facts.

    A group company does not consolidate a subsidiary it controls, which holds most of the group's debt. Leaving it out understates liabilities by ₹90 crore and changes almost every key ratio. Management refuses to consolidate. The auditor concludes the effect is material and pervasive and issues an adverse opinion, explaining the omission and its effect in the basis section.

    In detail

    04 Why it matters to a company

    An adverse opinion tells every reader not to rely on the accounts. Banks may call loans, investors may withdraw and regulators may look closer. It almost always follows a disagreement the company could have resolved by correcting the accounts. Raising difficult accounting questions with the auditor early is the best protection.

    Need help with an adverse opinion? See our guide to Audit Report Types, or our Statutory Audit Service.

    Review and sources

    Written by CA Suyash Agrawal, reviewed by CA Puja Pradhan

    Sources: ICAI Checklist on Standards on Auditing (22 Jun 2023): SA 700 (Revised), SA 705 (Revised) titles.

    Talk to an expert

    Tell us what you need and the right person calls you back.

    🇮🇳 +91

      By sending this form you agree to our privacy policy.