A pretext no real customer would have
Staff spot the visitor and behave differently from then on.
Stock audit glossary · Mystery audits
noun · also called a shopping scenario or visit brief
A visit scenario is the situation a mystery shopper is briefed to create during a visit, so that staff can be seen handling a set condition instead of whatever happens to occur. Asking for an item that is out of stock, returning a purchase without a receipt or raising a complaint are typical scenarios. Each one fixes what the visitor says and does, when the visit takes place and where the visitor must stop, so that visits to different outlets can be compared.
Meaning
Some behaviour shows only under particular conditions: an item is missing, a customer wants a refund, a question needs real product knowledge. Waiting for those moments to arise by chance would take more visits than any programme can pay for, so the scenario creates them. Staff are then seen handling a defined situation, not judged from an ordinary sale that happened to go smoothly.
A scenario has to hold up in a real outlet. A reason for being there that no genuine customer would have gives the visitor away at once, so it is ordinary enough to pass unnoticed and specific enough to produce the exchange the scorecard needs. Timing is part of the design, because the same outlet on a quiet weekday morning and on a busy weekend afternoon is running a different operation.
Scoring
The first question is not how well staff did, but whether the test happened at all.
In practice
How a refusal is handled, whether alternatives are offered, how a return is processed.
Plausible enough that a real customer might create it, specific enough to force the exchange.
Vary day and hour across the round, or the results describe one trading condition.
Whether to buy, whether to ask for a manager, and what may be noted or recorded, all settled before anyone travels.
Against the scorecard; a visit where the situation could not be created is marked and repeated.
Worked example
Sample round.
| Scenario | Visits | What it tests |
|---|---|---|
| A plain purchase enquiry | 18 | Baseline service |
| Asking for an out-of-stock item | 18 | Whether alternatives are offered |
| A return without a receipt | 12 | Whether the returns policy is applied the same way |
| A complaint about an earlier purchase | 12 | How complaints are escalated |
| A price query against a competitor | 18 | Discounting discipline |
| The round | 78 | Five scenarios |
The out-of-stock and no-receipt visits are the revealing ones. They put staff in a situation the policy covers but training may not, and that is where practice differs most between outlets. A plain enquiry rarely separates a well-run outlet from a poor one.
Running every scenario at every outlet would be cleaner and is usually too costly, so the return and complaint scenarios run at 12 of the 18 outlets. A small set is rotated between rounds: often enough that staff cannot learn the script, rarely enough that one round can still be compared with the last.
Watch out
Most of these make results impossible to compare.
Staff spot the visitor and behave differently from then on.
The round measures one trading condition and reports it as the outlet.
One visitor buys, another walks out, and the visits stop being comparable.
Visitors note or record different things, or things they should not.
The outlet is marked on a test that never took place.
Nothing can be compared with the round before.
Patron Accounting LLP. This page makes no regulatory statement.
Sources: general mystery-audit practice; no statutory statement is made on this page. General information, not professional advice.
Need help with a visit scenario? See our mystery audit service. A mystery audit runs set scenarios and scores the response against your standard.