Measuring an aspiration
“Prompt service” turns every finding into a debate.
Stock audit glossary · Mystery audits
noun · also called service standards compliance
Service level compliance is the extent to which an outlet met the standards its organisation has written down, expressed as standards met rather than as a customer’s impression. It can be measured only where each standard is in writing and specific enough to be observed, which is why measuring it starts with the standard, not with the visit.
Meaning
The measure asks a narrower question than customer satisfaction and gets a firmer answer. Instead of whether the visit felt good, it asks whether each thing the organisation said would happen did happen. That turns an opinion into facts that can be evidenced and put to the outlet: a friendly outlet that misses its standards and a brusque one that meets them both show up clearly.
Everything depends on the standard being specific. “Serve customers promptly” cannot be measured; “acknowledge a waiting customer within 30 seconds” can. The phrase is also used for contracts, where service level agreement compliance asks whether a supplier met the levels written into its agreement. The logic is the same: a written commitment tested against what actually happened.
Scoring
Each checkpoint is binary; the visit result is a ratio.
In practice
Each is tested for whether it can be observed; vague ones are made specific or dropped.
With a pass condition two observers would apply the same way.
With evidence captured for anything likely to be disputed.
Outlet, region and network, because different people act on each.
Findings go back with the evidence, a fix is agreed, and the same points are tested again next round.
Worked example
Sample figures.
| Standard (target) | Result | Met? |
|---|---|---|
| Acknowledged within 30 seconds (95) | 89 | No |
| Billing accurate (100) | 100 | Yes |
| Trial or demonstration offered (90) | 94 | Yes |
| Queue under 4 minutes (90) | 71 | No |
| Overall | Four standards | 2 of 4 met |
Compliance answers whether each standard was met, not how well the outlet did overall, which is a scorecard’s job. Here two of four standards were met, and the queue result needs the most care.
A result of 71 against a target of 90 looks like a staffing failure. But if most visits fell in the lunchtime peak, the standard may never have been staffed for those hours. A compliance figure is fair only where the visit times match the conditions the standard was written for.
Watch out
The measure is only as firm as the standard behind it.
“Prompt service” turns every finding into a debate.
One number that neither risk nor operations can act on.
Staff are held to rules they were not told about.
A friendly visit is marked as meeting standards it missed.
Visits keep testing a rule that no longer applies.
Results reflect the hour, not the outlet.
Patron Accounting LLP. This page makes no regulatory statement.
Sources: general mystery-audit and service-standards practice; no statutory statement is made on this page. General information, not professional advice.
Need help with service level compliance? See our mystery audit service. A mystery audit measures each outlet against the standards you have written down.