Reading despatches as demand
A quarter of filling distributors is reported as growth.
Stock audit glossary · Sales and distribution
noun · the counterpart of primary sales
Secondary sales are sales made by a distributor onward to retailers. Primary sales are the manufacturer’s own sales to the distributor. Primary sales show how much stock entered the channel, which can rise while shopper demand is flat; secondary sales show whether goods are actually moving through, and they rely on the distributor reporting them.
Meaning
A manufacturer that measures performance from despatches alone is measuring how much it has pushed toward the market, not what shoppers bought. The two can split apart: a quarter of strong despatches can come with distributors filling their godowns and retail sales falling, while the accounts still show growth.
The correction comes later, as returns, expiry claims, clearance discounts or a quarter with few orders. Because secondary figures come from the distributor’s own books, they are tested from time to time with a physical count at the distributor: stock on hand, set against goods supplied and sales reported, shows whether the reported movement was real.
Where it is used
It needs an independent distributor between the maker and the shop.
In practice
The manufacturer invoices a distributor; the goods leave its stock and become the distributor’s.
Over the following weeks the distributor sells to retailers and records it in its own books.
The distributor reports those sales back, usually monthly and from its own system.
If primary keeps running ahead of secondary, the channel is filling up rather than the market growing.
Distributor stock is counted and set against goods invoiced in and sales reported out.
Worked example
Sample figures.
| Month | Primary / secondary (INR) | Distributor stock (INR) |
|---|---|---|
| First month | 3,20,00,000 / 2,90,00,000 | 1,10,00,000 |
| Second month | 3,60,00,000 / 2,80,00,000 | 1,90,00,000 |
| Third month | 4,10,00,000 / 2,70,00,000 | 3,30,00,000 |
Primary sales rose by more than a quarter over the three months, so the sales report looks strong. Secondary sales fell each month. The last column shows where the difference went: distributor stock tripled, from 1,10,00,000 to 3,30,00,000.
That is channel loading, not demand, and it reverses when distributors stop ordering. A count at the distributors shows it early; primary figures alone keep reporting growth until the channel is full.
Watch out
Most of these come from trusting one figure without the other.
A quarter of filling distributors is reported as growth.
Self-reported figures are taken at face value.
Sales are borrowed from the next quarter.
How long it will take to clear stays hidden.
Stock at depots or with sub-dealers is missed.
A count shows what is present, not what moved.
Patron Accounting LLP. This page makes no regulatory statement.
Sources: general distribution and sales-reporting practice; no statutory statement is made on this page. General information, not professional advice.
Need help with secondary sales? See our FMCG stock audit service. An FMCG stock audit can count stock at distributors to test the sales they report.