Booking returns without inspection
Unfit units are carried at cost.
Stock audit glossary · Distribution
noun · the opposite of unsaleable or non-saleable returns
Saleable returns are goods sent back through the distribution chain that are still in a condition, and have enough shelf life left, to be sold again. Non-saleable returns are damaged, expired or otherwise unfit. The difference decides whether returned goods go back into stock at value or are written off when they arrive.
Meaning
Everything that comes back has to be sorted into two piles, and the sorting decides the accounting. Goods within shelf life and fit to sell rejoin stock at value. Goods that are spoiled, opened, out of date or unfit are blocked and written down or off. If the sorting is put off and all returns sit in one pile, unfit goods are carried at full value until someone looks.
Sorting on receipt matters for a practical reason too. A return put straight back on the pick shelf can go out to another customer, come back again and get worse each time. So the grading rules have to be clear enough that two people reach the same answer, and each decision is recorded against the goods.
Where it arises
The volume depends on the channel; the test does not.
In practice
Returns from a customer, retailer or distributor are booked in apart, not straight onto the pick shelf.
Packaging, remaining shelf life and physical condition, unit by unit.
Units that pass go back into stock at value; units that fail move to a blocked location.
Grade and reason are recorded against the goods with the grader named.
Blocked units are written down or off by reason; a rising share of unfit returns can point to handling, transport or packaging.
Worked example
Sample figures.
| Reason for return | Units | Value (INR) |
|---|---|---|
| Wrong size ordered, unopened | 640, saleable | 8,32,000 |
| Damaged in transit | 210, not saleable | 2,73,000 |
| Opened, seal broken | 180, not saleable | 2,34,000 |
| Expiry within ninety days | 96, not saleable | 1,24,800 |
| Total returned | 1,126 | 14,63,800 |
The split matters more than the total, because each line is treated differently. The unopened returns rejoin stock at cost; the rest do not. Putting everything back in the main location overstates stock with goods that cannot be sold, and the gap surfaces at the next count as an unexplained difference.
The expiry line is a judgement call. Goods with ninety days left are physically fine, but a channel that needs a longer shelf life will not take them, so they are graded against the channel, not against the calendar alone.
Watch out
Most errors come from valuing returns before anyone has looked at them.
Unfit units are carried at cost.
They go out again and come back worse.
Two graders give one unit different answers.
The stock value rests on memory.
Customer, trade and warranty returns arrive in different states.
A rising share of damaged returns goes unexplained.
Patron Accounting LLP. This page makes no regulatory statement.
Sources: general distribution and returns practice; no statutory statement is made on this page. General information, not professional advice.
Need help with saleable returns? See our FMCG stock audit service. An FMCG stock audit checks how returns are graded and where unfit returns are held.