Glossary · Audit & Assurance
Internal Audit Independence and Objectivity
Definition
Independence in internal audit means the function is free from conditions that would stop it from doing its work without bias, chiefly through a reporting line to the audit committee or board rather than to the managers it audits. Objectivity is the individual auditor's unbiased state of mind: judging facts on evidence, without letting personal interests or relationships affect the conclusion.
At a glance
- Category
- Audit & Assurance
- Main provision
- Section 138, Companies Act 2013
- In this entry
- What it means Where the law or the standard sets it · A simple example
In detail
01 What it means
The two ideas work at different levels:
- Independence is organisational. Who does the head of internal audit report to? Who sets the budget, approves the plan, and can remove the head? Can internal audit access any record without permission?
- Objectivity is personal. Is the auditor reviewing work they did themselves? Auditing a former team, a friend or a relative? Under pressure to soften a finding?
Common threats, and usual safeguards:
| Threat | Safeguard |
|---|---|
| Reporting to the CFO whose area is audited | Functional reporting to the audit committee |
| Auditor reviewing a process they designed | Assign another auditor; wait a cooling-off period |
| Internal audit running controls itself | Charter bars operational duties |
| Pressure to change a rating | Direct access to the audit committee chair |
Independence can be lost in appearance as well as in fact: if the audit committee or a regulator would reasonably doubt it, the safeguard has failed.
The provision
02 Where the law or the standard sets it
Where internal audit is required under section 138 of the Companies Act 2013, read with Rule 13 of the Companies (Accounts) Rules 2014, the internal auditor may be a chartered accountant, a cost accountant or another professional decided by the Board, and may or may not be an employee. For the statutory auditor, the law separates the roles: section 144 bars the company's statutory auditor from providing internal audit services to it. ICAI's Standards on Internal Audit, issued by its Internal Audit Standards Board, address independence and objectivity. As at November 2026 they are recommendatory: the ICAI Council has not notified a date from which they become mandatory.
Worked example
03 A simple example
An example, not advice on your facts.
A company's internal audit head reports to the CFO. This year's plan includes treasury, which the CFO runs. To protect independence, the audit committee changes the charter: the head now reports functionally to the committee chair and administratively to the CFO. The auditor who worked in treasury until last year is assigned to another audit.
In detail
04 Why it matters to a company
An internal audit report is only as useful as it is unbiased. Boards, statutory auditors and regulators give more weight to internal audit work when its independence is designed in, not assumed.
Need help with internal audit independence and objectivity? See our Internal Audit Service.
Review and sources
Sources: Companies Act 2013 s.144 (India Code); ICAI Compendium of Standards on Internal Audit (as on 1 Oct 2022), Preface.
