Glossary · Audit & Assurance
Auditor Eligibility
Definition
Auditor eligibility is the set of conditions a person or firm must meet to be appointed, or re-appointed, as a company's statutory auditor: the right professional qualification, and none of the relationships or limits that the law says would compromise independence. Under the Companies Act 2013, these conditions are in section 141.
At a glance
- Category
- Audit & Assurance
- Main provision
- Section 141(3), Companies Act 2013
- In this entry
- What it means Where the law or the standard sets it · A simple example
In detail
01 What it means
Eligibility has two sides:
- Qualification: who can be an auditor at all. The basic qualification is set in section 141(1) and (2). Only a chartered accountant can be appointed; a firm, including an LLP, can be appointed in its firm name if a majority of its partners practising in India are chartered accountants, and only the partners who are chartered accountants may act and sign for it.
- Disqualification: who cannot be the auditor of a particular company, even if qualified, because of a link to the company or a limit the law sets. These are listed in section 141(3).
The company checks eligibility before appointment, and the auditor confirms it in writing. Eligibility is not a one-time test: it has to hold for as long as the auditor is in office.
The provision
02 Where the law or the standard sets it
- Section 141. Sets out eligibility, qualifications and disqualifications of auditors. Section 141(3) bars: a body corporate other than an LLP; an officer or employee of the company, or a partner or employee of such a person; a person who, or whose relative or partner, holds securities in, is indebted to, or has given a guarantee for the company or its group beyond the prescribed limits; a person or firm with a prescribed business relationship with the company or its group; a person whose relative is a director or key managerial personnel of the company; a person convicted of an offence involving fraud, until ten years have passed; and a person who provides the company, its holding company or its subsidiary any service listed in section 144. Under section 141(4), an auditor who becomes disqualified after appointment vacates office, and the vacancy is treated as a casual vacancy.
- The 20-company limit. Under section 141(3)(g), a person cannot be appointed or re-appointed as auditor if, on that date, he holds audit appointments of more than 20 companies. In that count, one person companies, dormant companies, small companies and private companies with paid-up share capital below ₹100 crore are not counted (G.S.R. 464(E), 5 June 2015).
- Appointment. Under section 139(1), the auditor is appointed at the annual general meeting, and the company files a notice of appointment with the Registrar within 15 days of the meeting (form ADT-1).
- Services the auditor may not provide. Section 144 bars the auditor from providing certain other services to the company, such as accounting and book keeping, internal audit or management services.
- Listed entities. Under Regulation 33(1)(d) of the SEBI LODR Regulations, the limited review or audit reports a listed entity files with the stock exchanges may be given only by an auditor holding a valid ICAI Peer Review Board certificate.
Worked example
03 A simple example
An example, not advice on your facts.
A private company wants to appoint a partner of a CA firm as its auditor. Before the meeting, it obtains the firm's written consent and its certificate that it is eligible under section 141. It also checks that the firm does not keep the company's books, because section 144 would bar it from also doing the audit. The appointment is approved at the AGM and ADT-1 is filed within 15 days.
In detail
04 Why it matters to a company
If an ineligible auditor signs the accounts, the audit itself can be challenged, and the company and the auditor face penalties. A simple pre-appointment check, plus the auditor's written certificate, avoids that.
Need help with auditor eligibility? See our Statutory Audit Service.
Review and sources
Sources: Companies Act 2013 s.139(1), s.141(3)(g), s.144 (India Code); SEBI (LODR) Regulations 2015 Reg 33(1)(d).
