Impaired when book exceeds recovery
Carrying amount above recoverable amount (AS 28; Ind AS 36), with signs looked for at each balance sheet date.
AS 28 on ICAIStock audit glossary · Fixed assets
noun · also “impairment test”
Impairment testing checks whether an asset is carried in the books at more than the business can get back from it. An asset is impaired when its carrying amount is higher than its recoverable amount, which is the higher of what it would fetch if sold, after selling costs, and its value in use. Where the asset is impaired, it is written down and the shortfall is recognised as a loss.
Meaning
Depreciation spreads an asset’s cost over its life on the assumption that it keeps earning. Impairment testing asks what happens when that assumption breaks: the product it makes loses its market, the plant is damaged, a newer process makes it obsolete, or the machine simply stands idle. The figure in the books then says more than the asset can return.
The test compares two numbers. One is the carrying amount, broadly cost less the depreciation charged so far. The other is the recoverable amount: whichever is higher of selling the asset, net of selling costs, or keeping and using it. A sensible business would take the better of those two routes, so the asset is impaired only if even the better route falls short of the book figure.
On the register
The register is where a test starts and where its result is kept.
In practice
Idle plant, damage, a falling market, or what the last verification found.
From the asset’s own register line, or from the group of assets that earns together.
What the asset would fetch if sold, after selling costs, and what it is worth to keep using.
The higher of the two is the recoverable amount; set it against the carrying amount.
Write the asset down on its line and keep the workings, so the figure can be checked later.
Worked example
Sample figures for one line, tested as a whole.
| Step | Amount (INR) | Why it is there |
|---|---|---|
| Carrying amount of the line | 6,80,00,000 | What the books say |
| Value in use (estimated) | 5,10,00,000 | Keeping the line and running it |
| Sale value after selling costs (estimated) | 5,60,00,000 | Selling the line |
| Recoverable amount | 5,60,00,000 | The higher of the two |
| Impairment loss | 1,20,00,000 | Carrying amount less recoverable amount |
The machines on the line earn only together, so the sample test is run on the line as a whole rather than machine by machine. The line is a cash-generating unit: the smallest identifiable group of assets whose cash inflows are largely independent of those from other assets (AS 28 paragraph 4.10; Ind AS 36 paragraph 6). An asset whose recoverable amount cannot be estimated on its own is tested as part of its unit.
Had the value in use been taken alone, the sample loss would have come out at 1,70,00,000, which overstates it, because the line is worth more sold than kept. The comparison is always with the higher figure.
Framework
Two accounting standards cover the test: AS 28 and Ind AS 36, both titled Impairment of Assets. Under both, an asset is impaired when its carrying amount exceeds its recoverable amount, and the recoverable amount is the higher of net selling price (fair value less costs of disposal under Ind AS 36) and value in use. A business looks for signs of impairment at each balance sheet date and estimates the recoverable amount where a sign exists.
Carrying amount above recoverable amount (AS 28; Ind AS 36), with signs looked for at each balance sheet date.
AS 28 on ICAIGoodwill and certain intangibles are tested every year, sign or no sign, and a goodwill impairment is not reversed. AS 28 has no yearly goodwill test.
Accounting standards on ICAIWhether, and how far, an earlier impairment of an asset other than goodwill can be reversed. It is reversed when the estimates used to work out recoverable amount have changed, but only up to the carrying amount, net of depreciation, that the asset would have had if no impairment had been recognised (AS 28 paragraph 101; Ind AS 36 paragraph 117). The reversal goes to profit or loss unless the asset is carried at a revalued amount, and later depreciation is based on the new carrying amount.
Watch out
The test is skipped more often than it is done badly.
Plant idled in one quarter is forgotten by the balance sheet date.
Using value in use alone, or sale value alone, misstates the loss.
Idle and damaged assets on the floor are where a test should start.
The write-down cannot be traced to any asset.
A later reviewer cannot tell whether the figures were estimated or assumed.
Depreciation spreads cost; impairment recognises a fall in what can be recovered.
Questions
It is the check, at each balance sheet date, of whether there is any sign that an asset may have lost value, such as damage, idleness or a fall in the market for what it produces. Where there is a sign, the recoverable amount is estimated and compared with the carrying amount. Under Ind AS 36, goodwill and certain intangible assets are tested every year whether or not there is a sign.
An impairment means an asset is worth less to the business than the figure shown for it in the books. Under AS 28 and Ind AS 36, that is the case when its carrying amount is higher than its recoverable amount. The shortfall is recognised as an impairment loss.
Work out the recoverable amount as the higher of the asset’s sale value after selling costs and its value in use, which is what keeping and using it is worth. Compare that with the carrying amount in the register. If the carrying amount is higher, the difference is the impairment loss.
Patron Accounting LLP. Statements on AS 28 and Ind AS 36 on this page signed off by CA Sundram Gupta: 23 October 2026
Sources: AS 28, Impairment of Assets, paras 4.1 and 6 (ICAI); Ind AS 36, Impairment of Assets (ICAI accounting standards). General information, not professional advice; check the current position for your entity before acting.
Need help with impairment testing? See our fixed asset verification service. A verification records idle and damaged assets for the accounts.