Talk to an expert

Tell us what you need and we will call you back.

🇮🇳 +91

    Glossary · Audit & Assurance

    External Audit Confirmations

    Definition

    An external confirmation is audit evidence obtained as a direct written reply to the auditor from a third party, such as a bank, customer, supplier or lawyer, confirming a balance, a transaction or the terms of an agreement. Because it comes from outside the company and straight to the auditor, it is usually stronger evidence than the company's own records.

    • Written by CA Suyash Agrawal, reviewed by CA Puja Pradhan

    Read the full entry

    At a glance

    Category
    Audit & Assurance
    Main provision
    SA 505
    In this entry
    How it works in an audit Where the law or the standard sets it · A simple example

    In detail

    01 How it works in an audit

    The auditor, not the company, controls the process:

    1. Select

      the items to confirm: bank accounts, loans, large customer and supplier balances, stock held by third parties, pending legal cases.

    2. Prepare

      the request on the company's letterhead or through an approved platform, with the company's authorisation, asking the third party to reply directly to the auditor.

    3. Send and control

      the requests: the auditor checks addresses and sends them itself, so replies cannot be intercepted.

    4. Evaluate

      replies: agree them to the books and investigate differences, for example goods in transit or payments not yet received.

    5. Follow up

      non-replies with second requests or alternative procedures, such as checking payments received after year end against invoices.

    Two common forms:

    • Positive confirmation: the third party is asked to reply in every case, either agreeing the stated balance or stating its own figure. Stronger evidence.
    • Negative confirmation: the third party replies only if it disagrees. Weaker, used only for many small, low-risk balances.

    If management refuses to let the auditor send a confirmation, the auditor considers the reason and whether it points to a risk, and may treat it as a limit on the audit.

    The provision

    02 Where the law or the standard sets it

    Confirmations are governed by SA 505, External Confirmations, issued by ICAI, and form part of audit evidence under SA 500, Audit Evidence. SA 505 requires the auditor to keep control of the requests: deciding what to confirm, choosing the confirming party, designing the request so the reply comes directly to the auditor, and sending it with follow-ups. If management refuses to allow a request, the auditor must ask why, seek evidence that the reason is valid and perform alternative procedures.

    Worked example

    03 A simple example

    An example, not advice on your facts.

    A company shows trade receivables of ₹6 crore from 140 customers. The auditor sends positive confirmations to the 25 largest customers (₹4.2 crore) and a sample of 20 others. Thirty-eight reply. One reports ₹8 lakh less than the books; it turns out to be a credit note the company had not recorded. For the seven non-replies, the auditor checks receipts in April and May against the invoices.

    In detail

    04 Why it matters to a company

    Confirmations are one of the main reasons audits wait on outside parties. Keeping customer and supplier addresses current, reconciling key balances with counterparties during the year and asking important customers to reply promptly all shorten the audit.

    Need help with external audit confirmations? See our Standards on Auditing (SAs) guide.

    Review and sources

    Written by CA Suyash Agrawal, reviewed by CA Puja Pradhan

    Sources: ICAI Checklist on Standards on Auditing (22 Jun 2023): SA 500, SA 505 titles.

    Talk to an expert

    Tell us what you need and the right person calls you back.

    🇮🇳 +91

      By sending this form you agree to our privacy policy.