This page was written by Patron Accounting’s AI from the official release and reviewed before publishing. It explains the document in plain language. It is not the document itself. Where this page and the original differ, the original governs.
The short version
- The company moves spectacles, lenses and contact lenses to its branches in other States.
- The question was which value to use for these transfers between the company and its own branches.
- The original authority said the 90 per cent option under the first proviso applied.
- The Appellate Authority set that ruling aside.
- Invoice value can be used where the receiving branch can claim full input tax credit.
In short
This GST advance ruling by the Tamil Nadu Appellate Authority for Advance Ruling asked what value a company should use when it moves goods to its own branches in other States. The company is registered in Tamil Nadu and its branches sell the goods to customers.
What has changed
How it worked before
The position was not settled for this company. The original authority had ruled that the open market value under Rule 28(a) applied, with the 90 per cent option under the first proviso available. Businesses making similar transfers were left to work out which route applied to them.
What has changed
The Appellate Authority held that the company may use the Second Proviso to Rule 28 of the CGST/TNGST Rules. Under it, the value on the invoice is treated as the open market value when the receiving branch can claim full input tax credit. The two provisos work independently, so the first proviso is not a step that must be checked before the second. In practice, a company whose branch can take full credit may use its invoice value and need not work out the open market value. The order does not decide the position where the receiving branch cannot take full credit.
Who this affects
Businesses that move goods to their own branches or units in other States, where those branches can claim full input tax credit. Opticians and retailers of spectacles, lenses and similar goods are the closest match, but any registered business making transfers of this kind has the same question.
An example
A Chennai company sells eyewear and sends stock to its Bengaluru branch, which sells it to customers there. The company asks whether it can bill the transfer at the invoice price. If the Bengaluru branch can claim full input tax credit on that stock, this ruling suggests the invoice value can be used, without first checking the 90 per cent option. If the branch cannot claim full credit, the ruling gives no answer and the company needs other advice.
What you should do
Do not treat this order as a law that automatically applies to you. A ruling binds only the company that asked and its own tax office, so another officer may take a different view of your transfers. Check whether each receiving branch can claim full input tax credit, and discuss your transfer pricing with your tax adviser. If you need certainty, you can apply for your own advance ruling.
If you do nothing
If you assume this ruling covers your transfers and it does not, a tax officer may treat the transfer value as the open market value and reassess your tax. You could then owe the difference in tax, and possibly interest and penalties. Relying on a ruling that binds only another company is a risk you carry yourself.
The terms explained
- distinct person
- A business's own branch or unit in another State, which the law treats as a separate person for GST even though it is the same company.
- open market value
- The price the same goods would fetch when sold between unrelated buyers and sellers, which GST law uses to value transfers where no normal sale price exists.
- input tax credit
- The GST already paid on purchases that a business can set off against the GST it owes on its own sales.
- advance ruling
- A written decision by a GST authority on one business's specific question, which binds only that business and its own tax office.
The ruling in detail
Appellate Authority for Advance Ruling
Specsmakers Opticians Private Limited (appellant), GSTIN 33AAPCS6371Q1ZH
ORDER-in-Appeal No. AAAR/09/2019 (AR), dated 13.11.2019 (A.R. Appeal No. 7/2019/AAAR) · Tamil Nadu
Questions before the authority
- What value should the appellant adopt for supplies of spectacle frames, sun glass lenses, contact lenses, reading lenses and complete spectacles to its distinct-person branches located outside Tamil Nadu?
Facts
The appellant, headquartered in Tamil Nadu, deals in spectacle frames, sun glass lenses, contact lenses and reading lenses, which it buys locally and imports. It transfers these goods to its branches in other States, which then supply them to customers, and those branches are eligible for full input tax credit on the transfers. The original authority held that the open market value under Rule 28(a) applies, with the 90 per cent option under the first proviso available, and the appellant appealed against that holding.
Ruling
| Question | What the authority ruled |
|---|---|
| Value for supplies to out-of-State distinct-person branches (frames, lenses, sun glasses, contact lenses, reading glasses, complete spectacles) | The appellant may adopt the value under the Second Proviso to Rule 28, i.e. the invoice value is deemed the open market value Applies where the recipient distinct person is eligible for full input tax credit. The ruling does not fix any rate or HSN. |
The Appellate Authority set aside the original ruling. It held that the appellant may adopt the value under the **Second Proviso to Rule 28** of the CGST/TNGST Rules, under which the value declared in the invoice is deemed to be the open market value where the recipient is eligible for full input tax credit. The two provisos are independent of each other and are not to be applied sequentially.
Reasoning
The Authority read Rule 28 by its plain language and found no provision requiring the provisos to be applied in sequence. The first proviso applies only to goods supplied 'as such' and gives the supplier an option of 90 per cent of the recipient's price to unrelated customers. The second proviso applies whenever the recipient is eligible for full input tax credit and deems the invoice value to be the open market value, without any such restriction. Because the second proviso stands independently, the appellant may use it. The Authority also noted that the rules are not to be applied seriatim and that the taxing provision must be read by its natural meaning.
Provisions relied on
- Section 15 of the CGST/TNGST Act, 2017 (value of supply), as referred to in the order
- Section 25(4) and 25(5) of the CGST/TNGST Act, 2017 (supplies between distinct persons), as quoted in Rule 28
- Rule 28 of the CGST/TNGST Rules, 2017, including its first and second provisos
- Rule 28(a), (b) and (c) and the Explanation to Chapter IV (open market value and like kind and quality), as quoted in the order
- Rules 30 and 31 (residual valuation methods), referred to in Rule 28(c)
- Section 100(1) of the TNGST/CGST Act, 2017 (appeal to the Appellate Authority)
For the practitioner
This order helps Tamil Nadu businesses that transfer goods to distinct-person branches in other States where the branches can take full input tax credit. It establishes that the Second Proviso to Rule 28 can be used independently of the first proviso. It does not decide the valuation where the recipient cannot take full credit, nor does it address the Rule 28 position for supplies made through an agent. The order is binding only on the applicant and the concerned authorities, and it is not a precedent for other taxpayers.
Source
This is a summary prepared from the published order, which is a scanned document. It is a reading aid and not the authority: where the two differ, the order governs. Verify every provision against the original before relying on it.
Original order: https://www.gstcouncil.gov.in/sites/default/files/2024-02/aaar-09-2019.pdf
Legibility of the scan, as read: high.
Prepared 14-11-2026.
About Patron Accounting LLP
Patron Accounting LLP is a CA and CS-led accounting and compliance firm that has been working with businesses across India since 2019. We handle the work that keeps a company correct with every department it answers to: day-to-day bookkeeping and accounting, GST registration and returns, income tax filing and assessments, TDS, payroll and PF/ESI, company and LLP incorporation, ROC and MCA compliance, statutory and internal audit, physical stock and inventory audits, trademark and other registrations, and the certificates and reports that banks, buyers and regulators ask for.
Our clients range from a first proprietorship registering for GST to established companies running operations across several states. Much of our work is exactly this: reading what a department has published and telling a business, in plain terms, whether it changes anything for them.
We operate from five offices and serve clients across the rest of India remotely:
- Pune (HQ): RTC Silver, B4-708, Sai Satyam Park, Wagholi, Pune, Maharashtra 412207
- Mumbai: 1st Floor, Rajshila Building, 104/597, Jagannath Shankar Seth Rd, Marine Lines, Mumbai 400002
- Delhi: First Floor, Plot No. C-134-A, A-1 Block, Qutub Vihar Phase-1, New Delhi 110071
- Gurugram: 705, 7th Floor, ILD Trade Centre, Sohna Road, Sector 47, Gurugram 122018
- Ahmedabad: Phoenix Tower, 1107, near Commerce Six Road, Drive In Road, Navrangpura, Ahmedabad, Gujarat 380009
If anything on this page affects you and you would like somebody to look at your own position, we are glad to help. Call +91 94594 56700, write to sales@patronaccounting.com, or visit patronaccounting.com. The first conversation costs nothing.
