Talk to an expert

Tell us what you need and we will call you back.

🇮🇳 +91

    Kasturba Health Society GST ruling: college treated as separate person

    The Maharashtra appellate authority held that Kasturba Health Society and its medical college MGIMS are separate persons, and declined to answer the rest.

    Ruling
    ORDER NO. MAH/AAAR/SS-RJ/19/2019-20, dated 13.12.2019
    Dated
    Authority
    Appellate Authority for Advance Ruling

    Read the original order (opens in a new tab)

    Add Patron Accounting as a preferred source on Google

    This page was written by Patron Accounting’s AI from the official release and reviewed before publishing. It explains the document in plain language. It is not the document itself. Where this page and the original differ, the original governs.

    The short version

    1. The society asked whether it must register for GST and file returns.
    2. The authority held the society and MGIMS, the medical college it helps run, are separate persons.
    3. Governance and funding decided which body actually provides the education and health services.
    4. The authority refused to decide the questions about the society's own obligations.
    5. It also refused to decide whether fees, patient charges and medicine recoveries are exempt.

    In short

    This GST advance ruling from the Appellate Authority for Advance Ruling in Maharashtra asked whether Kasturba Health Society, a charity that helps run a medical college, must register under Goods and Services Tax (GST) law. The society had taken voluntary GST registration in July 2017 but filed no returns until March 2019, arguing that its activity was not business or a taxable supply. It also asked whether fees, patient charges and small recoveries were exempt as education or health care.

    What has changed

    How it worked before

    The position was unsettled. Charitable societies running colleges or hospitals were often unsure whether their fees and patient charges counted as taxable supplies, and whether the society or the institution it supports had to register.

    What has changed

    The authority held that the society and MGIMS are separate persons under GST law. It based this on MGIMS's Governing Council, where the society nominates five members and the Centre and State nominate five, and on the 50:25:25 joint venture funding. Because MGIMS, not the society, provides the education and health services, the authority refused to answer the questions about the society's own obligations and about the exemption for MGIMS's charges. In practice, the ruling shows that management control by a society does not automatically make the society the supplier.

    Who this affects

    Charitable societies or trusts that run a medical, nursing or other teaching institution through a separately governed college, unit or joint venture, where government or another body shares control.

    An example

    A charitable trust runs a nursing school through a unit whose governing council has half its members nominated by the state government. The trust asks whether it must register for GST because it collects fees from students. The Kasturba ruling suggests the answer may depend on whether the trust or the separately governed unit is the supplier, judged by governance and funding. The ruling does not say what the answer is for this trust.

    What you should do

    Do not treat this ruling as law for your organisation. It binds only Kasturba Health Society and its own tax office. If your set-up is similar, check who actually supplies the services, how the governing body is formed and who funds the unit, then get a ruling for your own case or advice from a tax professional before deciding on registration or returns.

    If you do nothing

    If you assume this ruling covers your organisation when it does not, a tax officer may treat your fees and patient charges as taxable supplies and ask for registration, returns and tax. Because the authority declined to decide the exemption questions, no ruling protects you on those points. Waiting too long to register or file can lead to penalties and interest, as the society's own late filings show.

    The terms explained

    advance ruling
    A decision by a tax authority on a business's specific question before it acts. It binds only the business that asked and its own tax office.
    distinct person
    A separate legal entity that GST law treats as its own supplier, even if it is linked to another organisation.
    Appellate Authority for Advance Ruling
    The higher body that hears appeals against advance rulings issued by the lower GST authority in a state.
    not maintainable
    A question the authority refuses to answer because it falls outside what the law allows it to decide, usually because the matter concerns someone other than the applicant.

    The ruling in detail

    Appellate Authority for Advance Ruling

    M/s. Kasturba Health Society (Appellant)

    ORDER NO. MAH/AAAR/SS-RJ/19/2019-20, dated 13.12.2019 · Maharashtra

    Questions before the authority

    • Whether the applicant, a charitable society whose main object is imparting medical education and which satisfies the criteria of an 'Educational Institution', is engaged in business so as to be obliged to comply with the CGST Act, 2017 and MGST Act, 2017 in totality.
    • Whether such a charitable society is liable for registration under section 22 of the CGST/MGST Act, 2017, or can remain outside registration under section 23 as there is no taxable supply.
    • Whether fees and other charges received from students, and recoupment charges received from patients (who are an essential clinical material for education laboratory), constitute 'outward supply' under section 2(83), and if so whether they fall under Sr. No. 66, or the nominal amount received from such patients falls under Sr. No. 74, of Notification 12/2017 Central Tax dated 28.6.2017.
    • Whether the cost of medicines and consumables recovered from OPD patients, with nominal charges for pathological and other investigations (CT-Scan, MRI, Colour Doppler, Angiography, Gastroscopy, Sonography), during the course of diagnosis and treatment, is a 'composite supply' qualifying for exemption as educational and/or health care services.
    • Whether nominal charges received from patients towards an 'Unparallel Health Insurance Scheme', to retain patient flow for medical education and provide concessional rates for investigation and treatment, are 'supply' eligible for exemption as educational and/or health care services.
    • Whether the nominal amount received for making space available for essential facilities (banking, parking, refreshment etc.) supporting the main activities, and the amount received for disposal of wastage, are 'supply' qualifying for exemption as educational and/or health care services.

    Facts

    The Appellant, Kasturba Health Society, is a charitable society registered in 1964 under the Societies Registration Act, 1860 and the Bombay Public Trust Act, 1950. It runs the Mahatma Gandhi Institute of Medical Sciences (MGIMS), a medical college funded as a joint venture by the Central Government (50%), the State Government (25%) and the Society (25%, met largely from student fees and patient recoupment charges), with a clinical laboratory named Kasturba Hospital. The Society took voluntary GST registration from 21 July 2017 and had filed no returns until March 2019, contending that its activity was not a business or supply. The Appellant's core position was that MGIMS and the Society are one legal person.

    Ruling

    QuestionWhat the authority ruled
    (i) Whether the Society, a charitable educational society, is engaged in business so as to be bound by CGST/MGST Acts in totalityNot answered
    Held not proper and correct because the Society does not itself provide medical education; MGIMS does.
    (ii) Whether the Society is liable for registration under s.22, or outside registration under s.23 as there is no taxable supplyNot answered
    Not answered for the reasons given at question (i).
    (iii)(a) Whether student fees and patient recoupment charges are outward supply, and whether they fall under Sr. No. 66 or Sr. No. 74 of Notification 12/2017-Central TaxNot maintainable
    Under s.95(a) because the transaction does not pertain to the Appellant but to MGIMS.
    (iii)(b) Whether medicine and consumable costs with investigation charges during diagnosis and treatment are a composite supply exempt as educational and/or health care servicesNot maintainable
    Under s.95(a); the transaction is not pertaining to the Appellant.
    (iii)(c) Whether nominal charges under the Unparallel Health Insurance Scheme are exempt supply as educational and/or health care servicesNot maintainable
    Under s.95(a); the transaction is not pertaining to the Appellant.
    (iii)(d) Whether nominal space and facility charges, and wastage disposal receipts, are exempt supply as educational and/or health care servicesNot maintainable
    Under s.95(a); the transaction is not pertaining to the Appellant.

    The Appellate Authority agreed with the lower authority that the Society and MGIMS are separate persons under GST law, because MGIMS, governed by a Governing Council with government nominees, is the entity actually providing medical education and health care. On that basis it declined to answer the first two questions, which concern the Society's own obligations, as improper. It held that questions (iii)(a) to (iii)(d) are not maintainable under section 95(a) because the transactions pertain to MGIMS and not to the Appellant. The delay of 26 days in filing the appeal was condoned.

    Reasoning

    The Authority treated the central issue as whether the Society and MGIMS are distinct persons under GST law. It relied on the Governing Council structure, with five members nominated by the Society and five by the Centre and State, and on the joint venture funding arrangement, to find that MGIMS provides the education and health services. It also relied on the Bombay High Court (Nagpur Bench) decision in Ajay Gambhir v Dean, MGIMS, which treated MGIMS as a State instrumentality, and held that management control by the Society does not make MGIMS a non-separate person, citing the analogy of parent and subsidiary companies under section 25. It distinguished the Supreme Court decisions in Queen's Educational Society and Aditanar Educational Institution, as those involved the societies themselves running the institutions. Because the transactions were MGIMS's, the questions were held not maintainable under section 95(a).

    Provisions relied on

    • Section 95(a) of the CGST Act, 2017 and MGST Act, 2017 (scope of advance ruling; basis for holding questions not maintainable)
    • Section 25 of the CGST Act, 2017 (distinct persons)
    • Section 2(83) of the CGST Act, 2017 (outward supply), as framed in the questions
    • Section 22 and Section 23 of the CGST Act, 2017 (liability to register and exemption from registration), as framed in the questions
    • Notification 12/2017-Central Tax dated 28.6.2017, Sr. No. 66 and Sr. No. 74, as framed in the questions
    • Section 100 proviso to sub-section (2) of the CGST Act, 2017 (condonation of delay in filing appeal)
    • Ajay Gambhir v Dean, MGIMS (Bombay High Court, Nagpur Bench, 1985)
    • Queen's Educational Society v CIT (Supreme Court, 2015) and Aditanar Educational Institution v ACIT (Supreme Court), distinguished

    For the practitioner

    The order is useful for a charitable society that operates a teaching institution through a separately constituted or government-linked unit, since it shows the Authority will look at governance and funding to decide which body supplies the services. It does not decide whether medical education or health care is exempt, because the Authority declined to answer the substantive exemption questions. A practitioner should note that a society's management role over a joint-venture college may not by itself make the society the supplier.

    Source

    This is a summary prepared from the published order, which is a scanned document. It is a reading aid and not the authority: where the two differ, the order governs. Verify every provision against the original before relying on it.

    Original order: https://www.gstcouncil.gov.in/sites/default/files/2024-02/mah_aaar_ss-rj_19_2019-20_13.12.2019.pdf

    Legibility of the scan, as read: high.

    Prepared 15-11-2026.

    About Patron Accounting LLP

    Patron Accounting LLP is a CA and CS-led accounting and compliance firm that has been working with businesses across India since 2019. We handle the work that keeps a company correct with every department it answers to: day-to-day bookkeeping and accounting, GST registration and returns, income tax filing and assessments, TDS, payroll and PF/ESI, company and LLP incorporation, ROC and MCA compliance, statutory and internal audit, physical stock and inventory audits, trademark and other registrations, and the certificates and reports that banks, buyers and regulators ask for.

    Our clients range from a first proprietorship registering for GST to established companies running operations across several states. Much of our work is exactly this: reading what a department has published and telling a business, in plain terms, whether it changes anything for them.

    We operate from five offices and serve clients across the rest of India remotely:

    • Pune (HQ): RTC Silver, B4-708, Sai Satyam Park, Wagholi, Pune, Maharashtra 412207
    • Mumbai: 1st Floor, Rajshila Building, 104/597, Jagannath Shankar Seth Rd, Marine Lines, Mumbai 400002
    • Delhi: First Floor, Plot No. C-134-A, A-1 Block, Qutub Vihar Phase-1, New Delhi 110071
    • Gurugram: 705, 7th Floor, ILD Trade Centre, Sohna Road, Sector 47, Gurugram 122018
    • Ahmedabad: Phoenix Tower, 1107, near Commerce Six Road, Drive In Road, Navrangpura, Ahmedabad, Gujarat 380009

    If anything on this page affects you and you would like somebody to look at your own position, we are glad to help. Call +91 94594 56700, write to sales@patronaccounting.com, or visit patronaccounting.com. The first conversation costs nothing.

    More in Appellate orders (AAAR)

    All Appellate orders (AAAR) →

    Does this ruling mean my charitable trust is exempt from GST?

    No. The authority declined to decide whether education or health care fees are exempt. The ruling only addresses which body is the supplier in this case.

    Is this ruling binding on my state's tax office?

    No. It binds only Kasturba Health Society and its own tax office in Maharashtra. Other businesses and offices are not bound by it.

    If I have a society that controls a college, does that make me the supplier?

    Not automatically. The authority said that management control by the society did not make it the supplier, because the governing council and joint funding showed the college was the separate body providing services.

    What if my tax officer disagrees with this ruling?

    You can point to the ruling, but your tax officer may decide your case differently. Since the ruling is not law for you, it is wise to get your own advance ruling or professional advice.