Germination Loss, Damage and Valuation
A seed write-off is supported by a germination test on the specific lot, run close to the valuation date and read against the standard for that crop. It is also supported by storage records that explain the loss and disposal records that show where the failed seed went. Seed is the one inventory where every bag can be present and sound to the eye while the lot has lost most of its value, because what the buyer pays for is the ability to grow.
That makes a seed write-off different from writing off damaged cartons or expired packs. The count proves quantity; only a test proves value. An auditor therefore looks at three questions in turn: did the lot actually fail, why did it fail, and was the failed seed valued and disposed of correctly. The general accounting rules for writing off unsaleable stock are covered in the guide to slow-moving, dead and obsolete stock; this guide deals with what is particular to seed.
Germination as the Value Test
Under the Seeds Act, 1966, seed of a notified kind or variety can be sold only if it meets the minimum germination and purity standards it is labelled to. A lot that falls below its standard is not a lower grade of seed; it cannot lawfully be sold as seed at all. The standard differs from crop to crop, so the applicable figure has to be looked up for each crop and class of seed, never assumed from another one.
- The test identifies the lot. The report names the lot number written off, not a neighbouring lot or the crop in general.
Lot match - The test is recent. A result from before the storage period in which the loss happened says nothing about the seed today. Under the Indian Minimum Seed Certification Standards, 2013, a germination test at initial certification is valid for nine months from the date of the test, extendable by six months if a retest shows the lot still meets the standards, and rule 13(1) of the Seeds Rules, 1968 bars selling seed after the date on its label up to which it is expected to keep the prescribed germination.
Date - The test is independent where the amount matters. A recognised seed testing laboratory carries more weight than a germination tray in the company's own store, and a material write-off resting only on an internal result will be challenged.
Laboratory - The sample represents the lot. Samples drawn from the top and outer bags of a stack describe the seed kept in the driest, coolest positions, not the lot.
Sampling
What the test measures, and why a falling percentage is the loss, is explained under germination loss.
Storage Damage and Its Causes
Most viability is lost through storage conditions rather than time alone, and those conditions leave records. The records decide whether the loss is presented as unavoidable or as a control failure, which matters to the auditor, to an insurer and to a lender with a charge over the stock.
Moisture and heat
Seed stored damp or hotSeed above its safe moisture level respires and heats, and in an unventilated godown viability falls fast. Moisture readings and stack temperature logs are the first records asked for.
Pests
Insects and rodents in the stackPests eat seed and also raise the moisture and temperature around them. Fumigation and pest control records date the problem.
Structure
Leaks, damp walls and floorsBags below a leak, against a damp wall or at the base of a stack fail first. Where these sit is where the count has to look.
Missing storage records are a finding in their own right. Without them nobody can say whether the loss could have been prevented, and the write-off has nothing behind it except the test.
Carryover Stock Between Seasons
Seed left unsold when the sowing window closes is carried over to the next season, and carryover is where most valuation questions sit. A lot that met its standard comfortably at the start of one season can fall below it after months in store, so a test done a year earlier cannot support carrying it at seed value. Before the next window opens, each carryover lot reaches one of three outcomes.
- Retested and still above standard: carried as seed, at cost or net realisable value if lower, with the new test on file.
- Below standard but recoverable: cleaned, graded or re-treated where the cost of doing so is less than the difference between seed value and the value of the seed as it stands, then retested.
- Below standard and not worth reprocessing: written down to what it will actually fetch, segregated and either sold for another use or disposed of.
Timing decides which outcome is still available. A lot tested and treated before the window opens can be sold that season. The same lot tested after the window closes is carried for another year with a further season of decline ahead of it. How the count is timed around the sowing calendar is a separate question from how a failed lot is valued.
Valuing Seed That Fails
Under AS 2 and Ind AS 2, inventory is carried at the lower of cost and net realisable value. For a lot that can no longer be sold as seed, the realisable value is what it will fetch in its next use, less the cost of getting it there. The common mistake runs in both directions: writing failed seed down to nil when it still has a buyer, or assuming it is worth its grain price when it is not.
Untreated seed
May still have a useSeed never treated with chemicals can often be sold for another purpose. The write-down is to that price, less the cost of selling, and the difference from seed value is the loss.
Treated seed
Usually has no food or feed valueSeed coated with fungicide or insecticide is normally unfit for food or feed. Its realisable value may be nil, and safe disposal can add a cost on top of the loss.
Partial failure
Only some lots below standardWhere only some lots of a variety fail, each lot is valued on its own test. Averaging good and failed lots hides the loss.
A reduction to realisable value while the seed is still held is a stock write-down; removing it from the books when it has been destroyed or sold off is a stock write-off. The two happen at different times and are supported by different documents, and confusing them is how the same lot ends up being written off twice, or never.
Evidence a Write-Off Requires
Each part of the write-off and the record behind it
A part with no record behind it is the part an auditor will question.
Part of the write-off
- The lot failed
- Why it failed
- What it is now worth
- Who approved it
- Where the seed went
- Quantity removed from the books
Record that supports it
- Dated test report naming the lot
- Moisture, heat and fumigation logs
- Price for its next use, or disposal cost
- Approval given before disposal
- Sale invoice or witnessed destruction
- Disposal matched to the write-off
The last line is the one that most often exposes a problem. If more seed was written off than the disposal records account for, the difference is seed that left the books while it may still be in the godown and still be sold. That is a different finding from a valuation error, and it is why failed lots are counted and reconciled rather than simply written down from a list.
Handling a Seed Write-Off Properly
- Test before the count. Draw samples from the lots you expect to fail well before the count date, so the results are back when the physical position is fixed and both can be reconciled in one exercise.
- Sample from the whole stack. Include bags from the base, the walls and any damp patch, not only the bags that are easy to reach.
- Segregate failed lots as results arrive. Move them to a marked area and block them in the system, so they are neither counted as saleable nor sold by mistake. The control is the same one used for quarantine stock.
- Value each lot on its own result and record whether it is treated or untreated, because that decides what it can still fetch.
- Approve, then dispose, then reconcile. Approval comes first, disposal is witnessed or invoiced, and the quantity disposed of is matched to the quantity written off.
Where a lender holds a charge over the seed, how the stock statement and the bank's audit treat failed lots is covered in the guide for working capital borrowers.
When a write-off is large, when a lender or insurer relies on the figure, or when failed seed has to be shown to have left the godown and not just the books, an independent count with lot-level testing settles it. A stock audit for seed, fertiliser and agro-input businesses counts the lots, ties each failed lot to its test and reconciles what was written off to what was disposed of.
