Accepting the operator’s report as verification
It is a statement by the party holding the goods.
Stock audit glossary · Stock held elsewhere
noun · also “stock held by third parties”
Third-party or 3PL held stock is inventory a business owns but a logistics provider stores for it under a warehousing agreement. Placing goods in someone else’s building does not pass ownership, so they stay in the depositor’s stock and under any charge a lender holds over them. Because one warehouse usually stores goods for several clients, working out whose goods are whose comes before any count there.
Meaning
Outsourcing the warehouse does not outsource the goods. Stock in a building run by an outside operator still belongs to the business that sent it there, stays in its accounts and remains security for any lender with a charge over it. What changes is visibility: nobody from the business sees the stock from one month to the next, and the position is known only through the operator’s reports.
That is why these locations are verified rather than accepted on report. One building often holds goods for several clients at once, frequently of similar description, so attributing stock has to happen before counting, not as a tidy-up afterwards. The storage agreement, the receiving records and the physical markings settle it. A building total that does not resolve whose goods are whose gives a figure no lender can advance against.
Ownership
Ownership and custody sit with different businesses.
In practice
What is held, how it is reported, who bears loss, and the right to attend and count.
They stay in the depositor’s stock and under any lender’s charge.
So attribution does not depend on the operator’s records alone.
Against the business’s own despatch and receipt records each period.
The count proves quantity; the agreement, records and markings prove the goods are the depositor’s.
Worked example
One company, four sites, one attended.
| Evidence | Covers (INR) | Weight |
|---|---|---|
| Operator’s stock statement | 6,40,00,000 | Low: made by the party holding the goods |
| Confirmation sent straight to the auditor | 6,40,00,000 | Moderate: outside, but from the holder |
| Attendance at the count, site 1 | 1,90,00,000 | Strong for that site |
| Sites 2 to 4, not attended | 4,50,00,000 | No first-hand evidence |
The operator’s confirmation covers everything on paper, but it comes from whoever has custody of the goods, so it supports rather than proves. Attendance at one site gives strong evidence for 1,90,00,000 and none for the other 4,50,00,000.
Where a lender’s security sits largely at third-party premises, the coverage figure is what to report. “All four sites confirmed” reads as far more assurance than one site counted actually gives.
Watch out
Outsourcing the storage does not outsource the responsibility.
It is a statement by the party holding the goods.
Both the stock figure and the lender’s security are understated.
Goods belonging to other clients are swept in.
Attribution depends entirely on the operator’s records.
An operator can simply refuse a count.
A remedy under the agreement may be lost.
Patron Accounting LLP. This page makes no regulatory statement.
Sources: general warehousing and audit practice; no statutory statement is made on this page. General information, not professional advice.
Need help with third-party held stock? See our stock audit service. A stock audit attends third-party sites and reports coverage by value.