Talk to an expert

Tell us what you need and we will call you back.

🇮🇳 +91

    Glossary · Audit & Assurance

    Audit Recommendation and Management Action Plan

    Definition

    An audit recommendation is the internal auditor's proposal for what should change to fix a finding. The management action plan is management's written response to it: the specific action it will take, the person responsible and the target date. Together they turn an audit finding into a commitment that can be tracked.

    • Written by CA Suyash Agrawal, reviewed by CA Puja Pradhan

    Read the full entry

    At a glance

    Category
    Audit & Assurance
    Main provision
    Section 138, Companies Act 2013
    In this entry
    What it means Where the law or the standard sets it · A simple example

    In detail

    01 What it means

    The two parts have different owners:

    • The recommendation belongs to the auditor. It should address the root cause, not just the symptom, and be practical for the business.
    • The action plan belongs to management. Management may accept the recommendation, propose a different fix that deals with the same risk, or, rarely, accept the risk and not act. In the last case, the decision and who took it are recorded and reported to the audit committee.

    A good action plan is:

    • Specific: "configure a system block on credit above the approved limit", not "improve credit control".
    • Owned: one named role responsible.
    • Dated: a realistic target, shorter for high-risk findings.
    • Verifiable: it is clear what evidence will show it is done.

    Open actions are tracked in a register and reported to the audit committee each quarter, with overdue items flagged.

    The provision

    02 Where the law or the standard sets it

    No law prescribes the format. Where internal audit is required under section 138 of the Companies Act 2013, read with Rule 13 of the Companies (Accounts) Rules 2014, recommendations and agreed actions reach the audit committee or board through the internal audit report. Rule 13 requires it for every listed company, and for unlisted public and private companies whose previous year's turnover was ₹200 crore or more or whose bank or public financial institution borrowings exceeded ₹100 crore at any point. An unlisted public company is also covered at paid-up capital of ₹50 crore or more or deposits of ₹25 crore or more. ICAI's Standards on Internal Audit, issued by its Internal Audit Standards Board, cover reporting and follow-up. They are still recommendatory: the ICAI Council has not yet notified the date from which they become mandatory.

    Worked example

    03 A simple example

    An example, not advice on your facts.

    FindingRecommendationManagement actionOwnerDue
    Vendor master changes made without reviewRequire second-person approval for every bank detail changeTwo-level approval set in ERP; monthly change report reviewed by CFOFinance controller30 November

    Two months later, the follow-up review checks the ERP setting and three monthly reports, and closes the item.

    In detail

    04 Why it matters to a company

    Findings without owned, dated actions tend to reappear in next year's report. A clear action plan, and a register the audit committee watches, is what makes internal audit change things.

    Need help with audit recommendations and management action plans? See our Internal Audit Service.

    Review and sources

    Written by CA Suyash Agrawal, reviewed by CA Puja Pradhan

    Sources: ICAI Compendium of Standards on Internal Audit (as on 1 Oct 2022), Preface.

    Talk to an expert

    Tell us what you need and the right person calls you back.

    🇮🇳 +91

      By sending this form you agree to our privacy policy.