This page was written by Patron Accounting’s AI from the official release and reviewed before publishing. It explains the document in plain language. It is not the document itself. Where this page and the original differ, the original governs.
The short version
- The company asked what value to use for goods sent to branches outside Tamil Nadu.
- The Authority held that open market value is the default for these transfers.
- The 90 per cent option applies only where the branch resells the goods as such.
- The two provisos to Rule 28 must be read together, not separately.
- The company cannot declare any transfer value it chooses on the invoice.
In short
This Goods and Services Tax (GST) advance ruling from the Tamil Nadu Authority for Advance Ruling asks what value a business must put on goods it moves to its own branches in other states. The company is a Chennai optician that buys lenses, frames, sunglasses and contact lenses, then sends them to branches that sell them to customers. It wanted to declare its own transfer value on the invoice, such as its cost price.
What has changed
How it worked before
The order does not say how widely businesses relied on declaring their own transfer value for stock sent between their own branches. The company argued that the second proviso to Rule 28 let it do so. That point was not clearly settled before this ruling, so many businesses were likely unsure.
What has changed
The Authority decided that the branches outside Tamil Nadu are distinct persons, so the transfers must be valued at open market value under Rule 28(a). The 90 per cent option is open only where the branch will supply the goods further as they are. The provisos cannot be used on their own to pick a value, so a business cannot declare any figure it likes. In practice, the value should follow what the same goods sell for to unrelated buyers at the same time.
Who this affects
Any GST-registered business that sends stock from its Tamil Nadu office to branches it owns in other states, such as opticians, electronics and clothing chains, and wholesalers with their own outlets. The ruling is most relevant to those who sell the same goods to outside customers in Tamil Nadu, because the Authority relied on those sales to find an open market value.
An example
A Coimbatore spectacle retailer opens a branch in Kerala and wants to invoice the stock it sends there at its own purchase cost. It sells the same frames to unrelated customers in Coimbatore at a higher price. Under this ruling, the Authority would likely ask for that market price to be used, not the purchase cost. The retailer should therefore value the transfer at the open market price and check the figure with its adviser.
What you should do
Do not treat this ruling as law for your business. A ruling binds only the company that asked and its own tax office, so the Authority's view is persuasive, not automatic. Read the full order, and check your own transfers against the open market value test with your tax adviser before you raise any invoice. If you have no sales of the same goods to unrelated buyers, the order does not tell you how to prove open market value, so get specific advice.
If you do nothing
If you assume this ruling covers your transfers when it does not, a tax officer may recalculate the tax on a higher value and demand the shortfall. Interest and penalties may follow if the invoice value was wrong. Because the ruling binds only the company that asked, a different outcome is possible for you.
The terms explained
- Distinct persons
- Separate businesses or branches that the GST law treats as different taxpayers, even when one owner controls them all. Moving goods between them can count as a supply.
- Open market value
- The price at which the same goods are sold to unrelated buyers at about the same time. The law uses it as the default value for transfers between related businesses.
- Related persons
- Businesses linked by ownership, control or family, so that a price between them may not reflect a normal market sale. The GST law applies stricter valuation rules to them.
- Input tax credit
- The GST already paid on purchases that a business can set off against the GST it must pay on its own sales. The proviso on full input tax credit is one of the rules the Authority read alongside the valuation rule.
The ruling in detail
Authority for Advance Ruling
M/s. Specsmakers Opticians Private limited
ORDER No. 27 /AAR/2019 DATED: 24.06.2019 · Tamil Nadu
Questions before the authority
- What value is to be adopted in respect of transfer of goods (lenses, frames, sun glasses, contact lenses, reading glasses, complete spectacles) to the applicant's branches located outside Tamil Nadu?
Facts
The applicant, a Chennai-based retailer, imports and locally procures lenses, frames, sunglasses, contact lenses, reading glasses and complete spectacles for resale. It transfers these goods to its branches outside Tamil Nadu, which sell them to ultimate customers. The applicant contended that under the second proviso to Rule 28 it could declare a transfer value in the invoice, such as its cost price, without applying the open market value test.
Ruling
| Question | What the authority ruled |
|---|---|
| Value to be adopted for transfer of goods to branches located outside Tamil Nadu | Open market value under Rule 28(a) of the CGST Rules 2017 (and TNGST Rules), read with Explanation (a) to Chapter IV and Section 15. Alternatively, 90 per cent of the price charged by the recipient to its unrelated customer. The 90 per cent option is available only where the goods are intended for further supply as such by the recipient. Where the recipient is eligible for full input tax credit, the invoice value under that option is deemed to be the open market value. |
The Authority held that supplies to the out-of-state branches, which are distinct persons, must be valued at open market value under Rule 28(a). The 90 per cent option in the first proviso is available only where the goods are intended for further supply as such by the recipient. The two provisos must be read together and not independently, so the applicant cannot rely on the second proviso alone to declare any value.
Reasoning
The Authority treated the out-of-state branches as distinct persons under Section 25(4) of the CGST Act and as related persons under the Explanation to Section 15. Section 15(4) and Rule 28 therefore govern valuation. Rule 28(a) requires open market value, which the Authority found was available because the same goods were sold to unrelated customers in Tamil Nadu at the same time, so Rules 28(b) and (c) were not reached. The first proviso's 90 per cent option, and the further proviso on full input tax credit, were held to operate together and not as alternatives chosen at will. Reading the provisos independently would allow any value to be declared and defeat the rule that the value 'shall' be the open market value.
Provisions relied on
- Section 25(4) of the CGST Act 2017 (distinct persons)
- Section 15(1), 15(4) and 15(5) of the CGST Act 2017 (value of supply)
- Explanation (a) to Section 15 (related persons)
- Rule 28(a), (b) and (c) of the CGST Rules 2017 (value between distinct or related persons)
- First and further provisos to Rule 28 of the CGST Rules 2017
- Rules 30 and 31 of the CGST Rules 2017 (referred to in Rule 28(c))
- Explanations (a) and (b) to Chapter IV of the CGST Rules 2017 (open market value; like kind and quality)
- Rule 104(1) of the CGST and TNGST Rules 2017 (application fee)
- Section 100(1) of the CGST/TNGST Act 2017 (appeal period, noted in the order)
For the practitioner
This ruling helps Tamil Nadu businesses that transfer stock to distinct-person branches in other states, since it confirms that open market value is the default and that the 90 per cent alternative cannot be combined with the full-ITC proviso to declare an arbitrary invoice value. It is only a non-binding advance ruling, and it does not settle how open market value is to be proved where no comparable sale exists, or how the 90 per cent computation applies where the recipient's sales are not of like kind and quality. Practitioners should read the full order and consider the 30-day appeal period under Section 100 if relying on or contesting it.
Source
This is a summary prepared from the published order, which is a scanned document. It is a reading aid and not the authority: where the two differ, the order governs. Verify every provision against the original before relying on it.
Original order: https://www.gstcouncil.gov.in/sites/default/files/AAR/tn-27-aar-2019-sopl.pdf
Legibility of the scan, as read: high.
Prepared 04-11-2026.
About Patron Accounting LLP
Patron Accounting LLP is a CA and CS-led accounting and compliance firm that has been working with businesses across India since 2019. We handle the work that keeps a company correct with every department it answers to: day-to-day bookkeeping and accounting, GST registration and returns, income tax filing and assessments, TDS, payroll and PF/ESI, company and LLP incorporation, ROC and MCA compliance, statutory and internal audit, physical stock and inventory audits, trademark and other registrations, and the certificates and reports that banks, buyers and regulators ask for.
Our clients range from a first proprietorship registering for GST to established companies running operations across several states. Much of our work is exactly this: reading what a department has published and telling a business, in plain terms, whether it changes anything for them.
We operate from five offices and serve clients across the rest of India remotely:
- Pune (HQ): RTC Silver, B4-708, Sai Satyam Park, Wagholi, Pune, Maharashtra 412207
- Mumbai: 1st Floor, Rajshila Building, 104/597, Jagannath Shankar Seth Rd, Marine Lines, Mumbai 400002
- Delhi: First Floor, Plot No. C-134-A, A-1 Block, Qutub Vihar Phase-1, New Delhi 110071
- Gurugram: 705, 7th Floor, ILD Trade Centre, Sohna Road, Sector 47, Gurugram 122018
- Ahmedabad: Phoenix Tower, 1107, near Commerce Six Road, Drive In Road, Navrangpura, Ahmedabad, Gujarat 380009
If anything on this page affects you and you would like somebody to look at your own position, we are glad to help. Call +91 94594 56700, write to sales@patronaccounting.com, or visit patronaccounting.com. The first conversation costs nothing.
