Talk to an expert

Tell us what you need and we will call you back.

🇮🇳 +91

    GST on cotton forward contract settlements: ruling by Punjab AAR

    The Punjab Authority for Advance Ruling held that cash settlements of cotton forward contracts are taxable under GST only when the sale-side rate is set at the seller's discretion.

    Ruling
    ORDER NO. AAR/GST/PB/001 Dated 28.09.2018 (Punjab Authority for Advance Ruling; AAR No. AAR/Punjab/18/246-51 dated 01/10/18 on the covering letter)
    Dated
    Authority
    Authority for Advance Ruling

    Read the original order (opens in a new tab)

    Add Patron Accounting as a preferred source on Google

    This page was written by Patron Accounting’s AI from the official release and reviewed before publishing. It explains the document in plain language. It is not the document itself. Where this page and the original differ, the original governs.

    The short version

    1. The company asked whether GST applies to cash differences paid when cotton contracts are settled without delivery.
    2. Purchase contracts settled at the prevailing market rate were held not chargeable to GST.
    3. Sale contracts settled at a discretionary rate, different from market price, were held taxable as a service.
    4. The ruling rests on the contract terms the company supplied and may not cover contracts with different terms.
    5. The order itself says the company had not shown its contracts were traded on a recognised exchange.

    In short

    This GST advance ruling looks at whether money paid to close a cotton contract early, without any cotton changing hands, is taxable. A forward contract is an agreement to buy or sell at a fixed future time, and many traders settle the price difference in cash instead of delivering the goods. The company asked how GST treats that cash payment on both its buy side and its sell side.

    What has changed

    How it worked before

    The position was not settled. The tax office had argued that these payments could count as a taxable service under the 'use of money' limb, while the company argued that the payments were exempt securities transactions.

    What has changed

    The Authority said closing a cotton contract without delivery is not a supply of goods, since nothing is sold or transferred. On the purchase side, a settlement at the market rate on the settlement day was treated as an exempt transaction in securities. On the sale side, a settlement at a rate the seller fixes itself was treated as a taxable service, because it looked like an agreement to do or tolerate an act for payment.

    Who this affects

    Cotton traders and other commodity dealers who use forward contracts and settle the difference in cash, especially where one side of the deal is priced at the market and the other is priced by the seller.

    An example

    A Bathinda cotton trader agrees to sell 100 bales in three months at a fixed price, and the buyer later cancels the deal and pays the trader a cash difference. If the difference is calculated from the exchange price on the settlement day, the ruling suggests it would be treated like the purchase-side settlements and not charged GST. If the trader itself chooses a settlement rate that differs from the market price, the ruling suggests that sale-side payment could be taxed as a service. The trader would still need to check its own contract terms before relying on this.

    What you should do

    Do not treat this ruling as settling the law for your business. A ruling binds only the company that asked and its own tax office, and the Authority tied its answer to the specific contract terms it was given. Compare your own contract terms, especially who sets the settlement rate and whether the contract is traded on a recognised exchange, with those described in the order, and ask a tax professional before changing how you invoice or pay GST on settlements.

    If you do nothing

    If you assume this ruling covers your contracts when it does not, your tax officer may treat your cash settlements as taxable services and demand GST with interest. Because the order itself is partly inconsistent about the exchange-trading requirement, an officer may also question the exemption you claim on the purchase side. Correcting this later can mean paying tax, interest and penalties on several years of settlements.

    The terms explained

    advance ruling
    A written answer from a state or central tax authority on how GST applies to a specific question a business has asked, which binds only that business and its own tax office.
    forward contract
    An agreement to buy or sell goods at a set price on a future date, which can end with physical delivery or with a cash payment of the price difference.
    net settlement
    Closing a contract by paying only the difference between the agreed price and the market price, instead of delivering the goods.
    securities (under GST)
    A defined list of financial instruments, including some commodity derivatives, which GST treats differently from goods and services and which can be exempt.
    supply of services
    Any activity done for payment that is not a supply of goods, such as agreeing to do or to refrain from doing something, and which GST can tax.

    The ruling in detail

    Authority for Advance Ruling

    M/s Louis Dreyfus Company India Private Limited, Ground Floor, House No. 378, Model Town, Phase-1, Bhatinda, Punjab 151001 (GSTIN 03AAACL7361E1ZV)

    ORDER NO. AAR/GST/PB/001 Dated 28.09.2018 (Punjab Authority for Advance Ruling; AAR No. AAR/Punjab/18/246-51 dated 01/10/18 on the covering letter) · Punjab

    Questions before the authority

    • Whether GST is applicable on the differential payment received by a party to a cotton purchase or sale contract from the other party on the event of settlement, washout or closure of the contract by it (Form GST ARA-01, Sr. No. 14).

    Facts

    The applicant buys and sells cotton and enters into customised forward contracts that end either in physical delivery or in a settlement by payment of a differential sum. Under the sale contracts the applicant may settle at a rate it fixes at its discretion, usually by reference to the MCX or CAI price on the settlement day. Under the purchase contracts the settlement rate is the market rate on the commodities exchange on the day of settlement.

    Ruling

    QuestionWhat the authority ruled
    Forward cotton sale contracts settled by payment of the differential between the forward rate and the prevailing market rate on the settlement dateNot chargeable to GST, as the transaction falls within 'securities' under section 2(101)
    Ruling (i). The Authority's reasoning is that such settlement is a commodity derivative, but it also observed that the applicant had not shown the contracts were traded or settled on a recognised stock exchange (see reasoning).
    Forward cotton sale contracts settled by payment of the differential between the forward rate and a rate fixed by the applicant at its discretion, different from the market price on the settlement dateChargeable to GST; not 'securities' under section 2(101)
    Ruling (ii). Treated as a supply of services under Schedule II, para 5(e), by agreeing to an obligation to refrain from an act, tolerate an act or situation, or do an act.
    Forward cotton purchase contracts settled by payment of the differential between the forward rate and the prevailing market rate on the settlement dateNot chargeable to GST, as the transaction falls within 'securities' under section 2(101)
    Ruling (iii). Same reasoning as ruling (i). The Authority noted that the purchase contract settlement terms match FAQ No. 37.

    The Authority held that differential payments on forward cotton purchase contracts settled at the prevailing market rate fall within 'securities' and are not chargeable to GST. Differential payments on forward cotton sale contracts settled at a discretionary rate different from the market price are not 'securities' and are chargeable to GST as a supply of services. The ruling is stated to be based on the contract conditions furnished by the applicant and may not apply to contracts with differing conditions.

    Reasoning

    The Authority first held that closure of a cotton contract without delivery is not a supply of goods, because it is not a sale, transfer or disposal. It then tested the settlement as a service. It accepted that 'securities' include commodity derivatives under the SCRA, read with the notification covering cotton, and that the 'use of money' limb cited by the jurisdictional officer must be read with the specific exclusion. However, it also said the applicant had not shown that the contracts were traded or settled on a recognised exchange under section 18A of the SCRA, which cast doubt on the applicant's exclusion claim. It relied on CBIC FAQ Nos. 36 and 37 as executive relief for net-settled forward contracts, and held that the relief extends only as far as the FAQ, which covers settlement at the market rate. For a discretionary sale-contract rate, the settlement was held to be an agreement to refrain from or tolerate an act, or to do an act, under Schedule II para 5(e).

    Provisions relied on

    • CGST Act, 2017 section 7(1)(a), (c) and (d) (scope of supply)
    • CGST Act, 2017 section 9 (levy of tax)
    • CGST Act, 2017 section 2(52) (goods)
    • CGST Act, 2017 section 2(101) (securities)
    • CGST Act, 2017 section 2(102) (services)
    • CGST Act, 2017 Schedule II, para 5(e)
    • CGST Act, 2017 section 98(4)
    • Securities Contracts (Regulation) Act, 1956 section 2(h), 2(ac), 2(bc), 2(ea) and 18A
    • Notification S.O. 3068(E) dated 27.09.2016, Entry No. 59 (cotton complex)
    • CBIC FAQ Nos. 36 and 37 on financial services
    • Finance Act, 1994 Chapter V, as referred to by the applicant (Education Guide para 6.7.1, non-compete example)

    For the practitioner

    This order helps cotton traders on both sides of the market. It supports treating a market-rate net settlement of a forward contract as exempt, and treating a discretionary-rate settlement on the sale side as taxable. It does not settle the position for contracts with different terms. The order is also internally inconsistent on whether the SCRA exclusion applies at all, since it says the exchange-trading requirement is not shown but still rules the purchase and market-rate settlements exempt. Practitioners should check the exact contract terms and the stated reliance on FAQ 37 before relying on the order.

    Source

    This is a summary prepared from the published order, which is a scanned document. It is a reading aid and not the authority: where the two differ, the order governs. Verify every provision against the original before relying on it.

    Original order: https://www.gstcouncil.gov.in/sites/default/files/AAR/aar_gst_pb_01_28.09.2018_louis_dreyfus.pdf

    Legibility of the scan, as read: high.

    Prepared 25-10-2026.

    About Patron Accounting LLP

    Patron Accounting LLP is a CA and CS-led accounting and compliance firm that has been working with businesses across India since 2019. We handle the work that keeps a company correct with every department it answers to: day-to-day bookkeeping and accounting, GST registration and returns, income tax filing and assessments, TDS, payroll and PF/ESI, company and LLP incorporation, ROC and MCA compliance, statutory and internal audit, physical stock and inventory audits, trademark and other registrations, and the certificates and reports that banks, buyers and regulators ask for.

    Our clients range from a first proprietorship registering for GST to established companies running operations across several states. Much of our work is exactly this: reading what a department has published and telling a business, in plain terms, whether it changes anything for them.

    We operate from five offices and serve clients across the rest of India remotely:

    • Pune (HQ): RTC Silver, B4-708, Sai Satyam Park, Wagholi, Pune, Maharashtra 412207
    • Mumbai: 1st Floor, Rajshila Building, 104/597, Jagannath Shankar Seth Rd, Marine Lines, Mumbai 400002
    • Delhi: First Floor, Plot No. C-134-A, A-1 Block, Qutub Vihar Phase-1, New Delhi 110071
    • Gurugram: 705, 7th Floor, ILD Trade Centre, Sohna Road, Sector 47, Gurugram 122018
    • Ahmedabad: Phoenix Tower, 1107, near Commerce Six Road, Drive In Road, Navrangpura, Ahmedabad, Gujarat 380009

    If anything on this page affects you and you would like somebody to look at your own position, we are glad to help. Call +91 94594 56700, write to sales@patronaccounting.com, or visit patronaccounting.com. The first conversation costs nothing.

    More in Advance rulings (AAR)

    All Advance rulings (AAR) →

    Does this ruling mean I can settle my cotton contracts without paying GST?

    Not necessarily. The ruling covers settlements at the market rate on the purchase side, and it taxed settlements at a rate the seller sets itself on the sale side. Your contracts must match the terms the Authority considered before you rely on the same result.

    Is this ruling binding on my state's tax officers?

    No. The ruling binds only the company that asked and its own tax office in Punjab. Other officers and other states are not bound, although the reasoning may be useful to read.

    What if my tax officer disagrees with this ruling?

    The officer is not bound by this ruling for your business, so they can still treat your settlements as taxable. You would then need to argue your case with the facts and contract terms of your own transactions.

    Does this apply to cotton only, or to other commodities too?

    The ruling is about cotton contracts, and the Authority relied on a notification that covers cotton. It does not state the same result for other commodities, so do not extend it to them without advice.

    Why does the order rely on FAQ 36 and 37 from the tax department?

    The Authority used the tax department's published FAQs as a form of relief for net-settled forward contracts. It held that the relief stops at settlements made at the market rate, so a discretionary rate falls outside it.