Talk to an expert

Tell us what you need and we will call you back.

🇮🇳 +91
    Advance rulings (AAR) Uttar Pradesh

    GST advance ruling UP_AAR_19: Lucknow Metro fare system taxed at 12%

    Uttar Pradesh's advance ruling treats a Lucknow Metro fare system contract as a 12% GST works contract, for that company only.

    Ruling
    Order No. 19, dated 14.12.2018 (Authority for Advance Ruling, Uttar Pradesh)
    Dated
    Authority
    Authority for Advance Ruling

    Read the original order (opens in a new tab)

    Add Patron Accounting as a preferred source on Google

    This page was written by Patron Accounting’s AI from the official release and reviewed before publishing. It explains the document in plain language. It is not the document itself. Where this page and the original differ, the original governs.

    The short version

    1. The company asked if its Lucknow Metro fare system contract is a works contract.
    2. The authority held it is a works contract, taxed at 12% GST.
    3. Goods and services that depend on each other can form one composite supply, even with separate prices.
    4. A contract signed before GST can still be treated as composite under GST if the conditions are met.
    5. The ruling binds only the company and its own tax office.

    In short

    A GST advance ruling from Uttar Pradesh looked at whether one contract to supply and install a metro fare collection system is a works contract. The company argued the main part of the deal is a service, which would attract 18% GST. The authority disagreed, because the system is fixed permanently to the station building, which makes the contract a works contract.

    What has changed

    How it worked before

    It was unclear how much weight separate pricing of goods and services in a contract carries under GST. The company had billed goods and services separately before GST, so it was not settled whether that history would carry into GST.

    What has changed

    The authority held that goods and services that depend on each other form one composite supply, even if the bill of quantities shows separate values. It also held that a contract signed before GST can be treated as composite under GST if it meets the same conditions. Because the fare system is attached to the station building for permanent use, the contract is a works contract, and the order reads the rules as taxing it at 12% when supplied to a government entity. In practice, separate price lines do not by themselves split a contract, and whether equipment is fixed to a building matters.

    Who this affects

    Contractors on metro, railway or other government works that combine goods and services, where equipment is fixed to stations or buildings. It also matters to firms whose contracts list goods and services separately in the bill of quantities.

    An example

    A company supplies and fixes ticket gates at a state transport depot under one government contract, and the bill of quantities prices the gates and the installation separately. It would ask whether the contract is one composite supply and what rate applies. The ruling suggests that if the gates are permanently fixed to the building and the goods and services depend on each other, the contract may be a works contract at 12%. That company is not bound by this ruling, so it would still need to check the notification and its own facts.

    What you should do

    Do not treat this ruling as law for your business. Under section 103, an advance ruling binds only the company that asked and its own tax office, for the transaction described. Before relying on the 12% rate, check the full text of entry 3 of Notification No. 8/2017, as amended by Notification No. 20/2017 and Notification No. 1/2018, because the order's account of the amendments is not entirely clear. Ask your tax adviser to compare your contract facts with the ruling.

    If you do nothing

    If you assume the 12% rate applies to your contract because this ruling says so, and your tax officer applies 18%, you may be asked to pay the shortfall. The officer is not bound by a ruling given to another company. Checking the rule and your own contract first is much cheaper than correcting the tax after an audit.

    The terms explained

    advance ruling
    A written decision by a tax authority on how GST applies to one business's specific question, which the business can ask for before it acts. It binds only that business and its own tax office.
    composite supply
    A single supply made up of goods and services that are linked, so that together they form one deal taxed at one rate. Here, the goods and services depend on each other to complete the main supply.
    works contract
    A contract to build, install or fix something on land or in a building, where the job is treated as a works contract for tax rather than as a plain sale of goods.
    bill of quantities (BOQ)
    A document in a construction or supply contract that lists the items of work or goods and their prices. Separate prices on it do not automatically decide how the contract is taxed.
    attached to the earth
    Fixed to land or a building so that it is not easily moved. The authority used this test to decide that the fare system is part of the station building, not separate equipment.

    The ruling in detail

    Authority for Advance Ruling

    M/s Datamatics Global Services Limited, H.No. 1/100, Vinay Khand, Gomti Nagar, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh 226010 (GSTN 09AAACD4471B1Z0)

    Order No. 19, dated 14.12.2018 (Authority for Advance Ruling, Uttar Pradesh) · Uttar Pradesh

    Questions before the authority

    • Whether a contract can be treated as a composite contract under GST if it involves supply of goods and services that are inter-connected and inter-dependent, even though the BOQ shows separate values for goods and services.
    • Whether a pre-GST period contract can be treated as a composite contract in GST even though there was separate sale and service billing in the pre-GST period.
    • Whether a contract for designing, installation and setting up of the Automatic Fare Collection System for the Lucknow Metro Project is a composite contract with the principal supply being a supply of service or a works contract.
    • What GST rate applies to the LMRC project, 18% or 12%, after considering Notification No. 1/2018-Integrated Tax (Rate) dated 25.01.2018 and other GST provisions.

    Facts

    The applicant, an IT solutions company, and its consortium partner were awarded a contract by the Lucknow Metro Rail Corporation Limited (LMRC) for design, manufacture, supply, installation, testing and commissioning of the Automatic Fare Collection System for Phase 1A of the Lucknow Metro Rail Project. The applicant argued that the Automatic Fare Collection System is movable equipment whose essential element is service, so the principal supply is a service and the 18% rate applies. The Department's jurisdictional officer commented on the application, and the applicant was heard in person on 04.12.2018.

    Ruling

    QuestionWhat the authority ruled
    Q1: Composite contract where goods and services are inter-connected and inter-dependent, despite separate BOQ valuesYes, it is a composite contract under GST
    Applies even though the BOQ mentions separate values for goods and services.
    Q2: Pre-GST contract treated as composite contract in GST despite separate sale and service billingYes, if it satisfies the condition of composite supply
    The pre-GST billing split does not by itself prevent composite treatment; the composite supply test must be met.
    Q3: Contract for designing, installation and setting up of the Automatic Fare Collection System for Lucknow MetroIt amounts to a works contract
    The Authority rejected the applicant's view that the principal supply is a service; the system is treated as attached to immovable property (the station building).
    Q4: GST rate on the LMRC project (18% or 12%)12%, under Notification No. 01/2018-Integrated Tax (Rate) dated 25.01.2018
    Applies because the work is a composite service supplied to a Government entity procured in relation to work entrusted by the Central and State Governments.

    The Authority held that a contract is a composite contract under GST where its goods and services are inter-connected and inter-dependent, even if the BOQ states separate values. A pre-GST contract is treated as a composite contract in GST if it satisfies the composite supply conditions. The contract for the Automatic Fare Collection System is a works contract, and the supply is taxable at 12% as a composite supply of works contract to a Government entity.

    Reasoning

    The Authority applied the definitions of composite supply in section 2(30) and mixed supply in section 2(74) of the CGST Act, 2017, and held that inter-dependent goods and services completing a principal supply form a composite supply. For the Automatic Fare Collection System, it applied the definition of works contract in section 2(119), and it relied on the Supreme Court in Solid and Correct Engineering Works (2010) 252 ELT 481 (SC) on attachment to the earth, holding the system is affixed to the station building for its permanent beneficial enjoyment and has no separate existence. It also relied on the Rajasthan AAR ruling reported as 2018 (16) GSTL 623 on permanence of plant. For the rate, it relied on entry 3 of Notification No. 8/2017-Integrated Tax (Rate), as amended by Notification No. 20/2017 and Notification No. 1/2018 dated 25.01.2018, which the order reads as covering composite works contracts supplied to Government entities at 12%. The order's account of the amendment wording is not entirely clear, so the full notification should be checked.

    Provisions relied on

    • Section 98, CGST Act, 2017 (advance ruling)
    • Section 2(30), CGST Act, 2017 (composite supply)
    • Section 2(74), CGST Act, 2017 (mixed supply)
    • Section 2(119), CGST Act, 2017 (works contract)
    • Notification No. 8/2017-Integrated Tax (Rate) dated 28.06.2017, entry 3
    • Notification No. 20/2017-Integrated Tax (Rate) dated 22.08.2017
    • Notification No. 1/2018-Integrated Tax (Rate) dated 25.01.2018
    • Section 2(36), General Clauses Act, 1887 (immovable property)
    • Section 3, Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (attached to the earth)
    • Solid and Correct Engineering Works (2010) 252 ELT 481 (SC)
    • Rajasthan AAR ruling reported as 2018 (16) GSTL 623 (AAR-GST)

    For the practitioner

    The order is useful for contractors on metro, railway or other Government works contracts that involve integrated equipment fixed to a station or building, since it sets out the composite supply test, the attachment-to-earth test for works contracts, and the 12% rate position. Under section 103 an advance ruling binds only the applicant and the jurisdictional officer for the transaction described, so it does not settle the position for other contractors. It does not decide valuation, input tax credit, or the precise scope of the notification wording, and the order's own description of the notification amendments should be checked against the gazette text before reliance.

    Source

    This is a summary prepared from the published order, which is a scanned document. It is a reading aid and not the authority: where the two differ, the order governs. Verify every provision against the original before relying on it.

    Original order: https://www.gstcouncil.gov.in/sites/default/files/AAR/up_aar_19_14.12.2018_dgsl.pdf

    Legibility of the scan, as read: medium.

    Prepared 27-10-2026.

    About Patron Accounting LLP

    Patron Accounting LLP is a CA and CS-led accounting and compliance firm that has been working with businesses across India since 2019. We handle the work that keeps a company correct with every department it answers to: day-to-day bookkeeping and accounting, GST registration and returns, income tax filing and assessments, TDS, payroll and PF/ESI, company and LLP incorporation, ROC and MCA compliance, statutory and internal audit, physical stock and inventory audits, trademark and other registrations, and the certificates and reports that banks, buyers and regulators ask for.

    Our clients range from a first proprietorship registering for GST to established companies running operations across several states. Much of our work is exactly this: reading what a department has published and telling a business, in plain terms, whether it changes anything for them.

    We operate from five offices and serve clients across the rest of India remotely:

    • Pune (HQ): RTC Silver, B4-708, Sai Satyam Park, Wagholi, Pune, Maharashtra 412207
    • Mumbai: 1st Floor, Rajshila Building, 104/597, Jagannath Shankar Seth Rd, Marine Lines, Mumbai 400002
    • Delhi: First Floor, Plot No. C-134-A, A-1 Block, Qutub Vihar Phase-1, New Delhi 110071
    • Gurugram: 705, 7th Floor, ILD Trade Centre, Sohna Road, Sector 47, Gurugram 122018
    • Ahmedabad: Phoenix Tower, 1107, near Commerce Six Road, Drive In Road, Navrangpura, Ahmedabad, Gujarat 380009

    If anything on this page affects you and you would like somebody to look at your own position, we are glad to help. Call +91 94594 56700, write to sales@patronaccounting.com, or visit patronaccounting.com. The first conversation costs nothing.

    More in Advance rulings (AAR)

    All Advance rulings (AAR) →

    Does this ruling mean my metro or railway contract is taxed at 12%?

    Not automatically. Under section 103, the ruling binds only the company that asked and its own tax office, for the transaction described. Your contract needs its own review against the same tests.

    If our bill of quantities shows goods and services separately, are they two contracts for GST?

    The ruling says no in this case: where goods and services depend on each other, the contract can be a composite supply even when the bill of quantities shows separate values. Your own facts will decide how this applies to you.

    We billed goods and services separately before GST. Does that stop our contract being treated as composite now?

    The ruling says a contract signed before GST can be treated as composite under GST if it meets the composite supply conditions. Earlier separate billing does not by itself settle the question.

    Is the 12% rate certain for government works contracts?

    The order says entry 3 of the rate notification covers composite works contracts supplied to government entities at 12%. However, the order's description of the amendments is not entirely clear, so the full notification text should be checked before you rely on it.

    What if our tax officer disagrees with this ruling?

    The officer is not bound by a ruling given to another company, so they can take their own view of your contract. If you are unsure, you can apply for your own advance ruling under section 98.