01 The example: a restaurant inside a small hotel
Whether a restaurant inside a hotel charges the lower rate without credit or the higher rate with credit depends on the hotel's declared room tariffs under the rate notification for restaurant services in force for the period. Monthly sales are about ₹12 lakh to ₹7 lakh dine-in and ₹5 lakh through food delivery platforms.
The restaurant has charged 5% GST on every bill since opening, on the view that "most rooms are cheap". It has also been claiming ITC on kitchen equipment, raw materials and rent.
02 Three common gaps
Gap 1: the wrong rate. Whether a restaurant inside a hotel charges the lower rate without credit or the higher rate with credit depends on the hotel's declared room tariffs under the rate notification for restaurant services in force for the period. The test looks at the published tariff of the hotel's rooms, not what guests actually pay. If the boutique hotel qualifies, the restaurant should have charged the higher rate from day one.
Gap 2: credit claimed at the wrong rate. At the 5% rate, input tax credit is not available. A restaurant charging 5% and claiming credit has a second problem. If the correct rate is 18%, the same credit may become available once the rate is corrected, so the order of correction matters: rate first, then credit.
Gap 3: platform sales not matched. Sales through delivery apps must be matched each month with the platform's settlement reports and with what the restaurant reports in its returns. Who pays the tax on app orders depends on section 9(5) and the services notified under it; check the position for your period. Unmatched figures are a common trigger for a notice.
03 What the exposure looks like
| Item | Example |
|---|---|
| Sales over nine months | about ₹1.08 crore |
| Rate difference if 18% applied (13 percentage points) | worked out on the sales above once the correct rate is settled |
| Interest on tax paid late | 18% a year from the due date |
| Credit claimed at 5% | about ₹1.6 lakh, to be re-examined at the correct rate |
| Penalty | depends on the period and the section used; see below |
These are round sample numbers. Your own figures come from your returns and billing data.
04 How a self-correction works
- Collect the data: billing data, platform settlement reports and returns for every month. A GST audit structures this.
- Settle the rate: check the hotel's declared room tariffs against the rate notification in force for each period.
- Recalculate the credit at the correct rate: what was claimed, what was available but missed, and what must be reversed.
- Match the platform sales: each month's settlement report against the returns, invoice by invoice where amounts differ.
- Correct and pay: amend the returns, and pay the differential tax with interest using Form GST DRC-03 before any notice. Keep the acknowledgement.
- Fix the cause: change the billing system rate, set a monthly platform reconciliation and a periodic review. If the GST registration details are wrong, correct those too.
05 Documents to keep
- a note of the hotel's declared room tariffs for each period
- the revenue-sharing and rent agreements
- billing data for the period, and screenshots of the billing system rate setting before and after
- GSTR-1, GSTR-3B and GSTR-2B for each month
- the credit register
- platform settlement reports and any platform statements
- bank statements for sales reconciliation
- return amendment workings and DRC-03 challans
- the written note on the rate
06 Why this pattern is common
- The specified-premises rule is counter-intuitive. Whether the hotel counts depends on its declared room tariffs, not on what most guests pay.
- Billing systems are often set to 5% for restaurants. Unless someone checks the setting before going live, every bill carries the wrong rate.
- Platform reconciliation takes manual effort. Without a monthly match, gaps build up unnoticed.
07 Common mistakes
- Applying the standalone-restaurant rate inside a hotel Check the hotel's declared room tariffs first.
- Not checking the billing system's GST setting before the first bill.
- Skipping the monthly platform match.
- Waiting for a notice. Paying before a notice keeps penalty to the minimum; after a notice and an order, the costs and penalty rise, and an appeal needs a pre-deposit. If a demand has been confirmed, read how to file a GSTAT appeal and GSTAT pre-deposit rules.
- No periodic review. A short review each quarter catches rate, credit and platform gaps early.
08 Penalties by period
Which section applies depends on the financial year of the tax. Section 73 and section 74 apply to tax for periods up to 2023-24; section 74A applies from 2024-25 onwards. The example (a restaurant open in 2025-26) falls under section 74A.
| Point | Section 74A (2024-25 onwards) | Section 73 / 74 (up to 2023-24) |
|---|---|---|
| No fraud alleged | 10% of tax or ₹10,000, whichever is higher; none if tax and interest are paid within 60 days of the notice (section 74A(5), (8)) | Section 73: 10% or ₹10,000; none if paid within 30 days of the notice |
| Fraud or suppression alleged | Equal to the tax; 15% before the notice, 25% within 60 days of the notice, 50% within 60 days of the order (section 74A(5), (9)) | Section 74: equal to the tax; 15% before the notice, 25% within 30 days of the notice, 50% within 30 days of the order |
| Paid before any notice | No fraud: no penalty; fraud: 15% (section 74A(8), (9)) | Section 74: 15% |
| Interest | 18% a year on tax paid late | 18% a year |
A self-correction with full records showing how the error arose helps show the error was a genuine mistake, not evasion.
09 If a demand has already come
The same three questions apply to an existing demand: was the rate right, was the credit valid at the correct rate, and do the platform figures reconcile? Answer the notice with that analysis; see restaurant billing notices. If the order goes against you, the first appeal and then the GST Appellate Tribunal can look again at the tariff card, billing data and platform reports. A Tribunal appeal must be filed within 3 months of the first-appeal order being communicated. The special 31 July 2026 date for orders communicated before 1 May 2026 has passed; a late appeal needs condonation for sufficient cause within a further 3 months. After that date, section 112(6) lets the Tribunal admit an appeal within a further three months if there was sufficient cause; whether any route remains beyond that depends on the facts of the case.
For the law on restaurant rate disputes at the Tribunal, read our restaurant GST rate penalties guide.
10 Key takeaways
- Three linked gaps: the wrong rate, credit claimed at the wrong rate, and unmatched platform sales.
- Check the hotel's declared room tariffs before choosing the rate.
- Correct the rate first, then the credit.
- From 2024-25 onwards demands fall under section 74A, with 60-day windows for reduced or nil penalty.
- Paying with interest before a notice keeps penalty to the minimum.
11 Need help with your restaurant's GST?
We review the rate, the credit and the platform figures, prepare the corrections, and draft notice replies or appeal papers if a demand has come. Appeals and representation support: our CA team can appear for you before GST officers, at the first appeal and before the GSTAT, depending on the location and legal requirements. Call +91 945 945 6700, or see GSTAT appeal filing, GSTAT appeals for restaurants and GSTAT appeals for a restaurant startup.
Read next: Pending GSTAT cases · GSTAT state benches · Appealing ITC denial at GSTAT
