
01 Who files what
| Taxpayer | GSTR-9 | GSTR-9C |
|---|---|---|
| Regular taxpayer, aggregate turnover above ₹5 crore | Yes | Yes, self-certified, with GSTR-9 |
| Regular taxpayer, above ₹2 crore up to ₹5 crore | Yes | No |
| Regular taxpayer, up to ₹2 crore (FY 2024-25 onwards) | Exempt | No |
| Composition taxpayer | No; files GSTR-4 as its annual return, by 30 June after the year (from FY 2024-25) | No |
| Input Service Distributor, TDS or TCS deductor or collector, casual or non-resident taxable person | No (rule 80(1)) | No |
The annual return is filed for each GSTIN. The ₹5 crore test for GSTR-9C is on aggregate turnover, which is worked out across registrations with the same PAN.
02 Due date, late fee and the three-year bar
- Due date: 31 December after the end of the financial year, unless extended by notification.
- Late fee in the Act (section 47(2)): ₹100 a day under CGST, capped at a quarter per cent of turnover in the State or Union territory. The State law levies the same.
- Reduced late fee (Notification 7/2023-Central Tax, annual returns from FY 2022-23):
| Aggregate turnover | CGST late fee | Cap |
|---|---|---|
| Up to ₹5 crore | ₹25 a day | 0.02% of turnover in the State or UT |
| Above ₹5 crore up to ₹20 crore | ₹50 a day | 0.02% of turnover in the State or UT |
| Above ₹20 crore | ₹100 a day (the Act's rate) | 0.25% of turnover in the State or UT |
The same amount applies again under the State GST law.
- Three-year bar: an annual return cannot be furnished more than three years after its due date (section 44(2), from 1 October 2023), unless the Government allows it by notification. The GST portal has enforced this since 1 December 2025.
03 Our team's view: seven points that decide a good annual return
- Do the credit review before 30 November, not after. Credit on an invoice for the year cannot be taken after 30 November following the year, or after the annual return is filed, whichever is earlier (section 16(4)). Filing GSTR-9 in October closes the door on any credit you have not yet taken. So finish the credit review, take what is still due in the October return, and then file.
- Reconcile turnover month by month, not just in total. A difference that nets to nil over the year can hide an omission in one month and a double count in another.
- Separate timing differences from real omissions. March invoices reported in April, and credit notes issued after the year, are timing items. Sales never invoiced are omissions. Only the second kind means tax to pay.
- Pay additional tax before filing. Where the reconciliation shows tax short paid, pay it with interest through DRC-03 before filing, and show it in the return. A DRC-03 payment later made against a demand can be linked to that demand through DRC-03A.
- Check credit against GSTR-2B and the blocked list. Credit claimed beyond what suppliers reported, or blocked under section 17(5), should be reversed or explained before the department asks.
- Track rule 37A reversals. Credit on invoices from suppliers who did not file GSTR-3B by 30 September after the year is reversed by 30 November, and reclaimed once the supplier files. Both legs should be visible in the year's working.
- Treat GSTR-9C as the officer's first read. It is self-certified, but it compares your audited accounts with your returns line by line. Each difference needs a written reason.
04 The differences we see most often
| Difference | Usual cause | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Books turnover above GSTR-1 | Invoices missed in monthly filings; scrap or asset sales not invoiced | Report the supply; pay tax and interest through DRC-03 |
| GSTR-1 turnover above books | Advances, or credit notes booked in a different period | Reconcile period by period; correct the books or the returns |
| Credit in GSTR-3B above GSTR-2B | Credit taken before the supplier reported, or wrong supplier GSTIN | Follow up suppliers; reverse what cannot be supported |
| Credit in books above GSTR-3B | Eligible credit not yet claimed | Claim it before the section 16(4) cut-off if still in time |
| Reverse-charge tax in books not paid in GSTR-3B | Reverse-charge purchases missed | Pay in cash with interest; the credit follows if eligible |
| Supplies between own GSTINs missing | Stock transfers or shared services not invoiced | Distinct persons: a supply even without consideration (Schedule I para 2); value under rule 28 |
05 Worked example
A trading company's books show sales of ₹6,20,00,000. Its GSTR-1 filings for the year total ₹6,05,00,000. The ₹15,00,000 gap is explained:
| Item | Amount | Treatment |
|---|---|---|
| Exempt sales correctly not taxed | ₹4,00,000 | Reported as exempt |
| March invoices reported in April's GSTR-1 | ₹6,50,000 | Shown as this year's supplies declared in the next year |
| Credit notes for the year issued next year | ₹1,50,000 | Same |
| Scrap sales never invoiced | ₹3,00,000 | Real omission: tax and interest paid through DRC-03 |
Only the scrap is an omission. Without the line-by-line explanation, the whole ₹15,00,000 would look like unreported sales.
06 How we prepare GSTR-9 and GSTR-9C
- Download the year's GSTR-1, GSTR-3B and GSTR-2B, and take the trial balance, registers and financial statements.
- Reconcile turnover, tax paid and credit, by month and by GSTIN.
- Work out any tax short paid, with interest, and pay it through DRC-03.
- Complete the credit review before 30 November.
- Prepare GSTR-9 from the reconciled figures, including this year's items declared in the next year's returns.
- Prepare GSTR-9C where turnover is above ₹5 crore, with reasons for each difference.
- Review with the client, then file with DSC or EVC by 31 December.
07 Common mistakes
- Filing early and losing credit still due for the year.
- Copying auto-filled figures without reconciling them with the books.
- Ignoring supplies between your own GSTINs.
- Leaving GSTR-9C differences unexplained.
- Leaving an old return unfiled until the three-year bar applies.
If an annual-return difference later turns into a notice, proceedings run under sections 73, 74 or 74A depending on the period and the facts.
08 Sources
- CGST Act, 2017: sections 16(4), 17(5), 44, 47(2), 73, 74 and 74A; Schedule I, paragraph 2
- CGST Rules, 2017: rules 28, 37A and 80
- Notification 15/2025-Central Tax (GSTR-9 exemption up to ₹2 crore from FY 2024-25)
- Notification 7/2023-Central Tax (reduced late fee for annual returns)
- Notification 12/2024-Central Tax (Form DRC-03A)
- GSTN advisory, 29 October 2025 (three-year bar on the portal)
09 Related
- GST annual return filing (GSTR-9 and GSTR-9C)
- GSTR-9C reconciliation
- GSTR-2B vs GSTR-3B reconciliation
- ITC time limit under section 16(4)
- GST audit
For the monthly and quarterly returns that feed the annual return, see our GST returns service.
