01 What changed: the main points for startups
| # | Change | What it means for a startup | Why it matters at the Tribunal |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Time bar on filing old returns | Old unfiled returns can no longer be filed | You cannot appeal a return you never filed, file pending ones now |
| 3 | Lower e-invoicing threshold | growing startups must generate an IRN for B2B invoices | an invoice without an IRN can cost the buyer its credit |
| 4 | Rate slabs rationalised | products and services need reclassifying | wrong-rate disputes from the change-over can reach the Tribunal |
| 5 | Longer HSN / SAC codes | product master needs remapping | mismatches across returns and invoices invite scrutiny |
| 6 | Credit only if it appears in GSTR-2B | supplier defaults cost you credit | supplier-default denials are a common appeal ground |
| 7 | Invoice Management System | accept or reject supplier invoices before GSTR-2B | your accept / reject record becomes evidence |
| 8 | Tribunal running | a second appeal forum is now available | appeal within 3 months of the order |
| 9 | Budget 2026 GST amendments | may change export and discount positions for some startups | may bear on pending disputes: check with a CA |
| 10 | Section 128A waiver (closed) | waived interest and penalty on some old section 73 demands | an alternative to appeal while it was open |
02 Each change explained
Time bar on old returns. The portal now refuses returns filed more than three years after their due date (section 39(11)). Once a return is barred, credit for that period may be lost and the officer can assess from the data available. Action: list every return from the oldest open period and file anything close to the cut-off.
E-invoicing. Above the threshold, every B2B, export and SEZ invoice needs an Invoice Reference Number from the Invoice Registration Portal. Without it the invoice is not valid for the buyer's credit, and a penalty can apply. Action: connect your billing system before you cross the threshold.
Rate changes. The GST Council simplified the slabs. Action: map every product and service to its current rate and update billing and marketplace settings.
HSN / SAC codes. Longer codes are now required on invoices and returns. Action: assign the specific code to each item and check suppliers' codes in GSTR-2B.
If your startup is still at GST registration, set up filing from day one so none of this builds up. Startups with lean accounting teams are most exposed.
03 Who is most affected?
- SaaS and IT startups with export revenue, place of supply and credit on cross-border services
- D2C and e-commerce startups near the e-invoicing threshold, e-invoicing and marketplace TCS reconciliation
- Food startups: rate changes on packaged food
- Manufacturing startups with many suppliers: credit matching
- Startups with unfiled returns from older years, the time bar
- Startups with demand orders from earlier years, appeal time limits
For the full filing process, read how to file a GSTAT appeal. For the startup view of an appeal, see GSTAT appeal implications for startups.
04 Penalties that can follow
| Situation | Provision | What can be charged |
|---|---|---|
| Tax short paid, no fraud (periods up to FY 2023-24) | section 73 | 10% of tax or ₹10,000, whichever is higher (section 73(9)); none if tax and interest are paid within 30 days of the notice (section 73(8)), except self-assessed tax unpaid 30 days after its due date (section 73(11)) |
| Tax short paid with fraud or suppression (up to FY 2023-24) | section 74 | Equal to the tax (section 74(1)); 15%, 25% or 50% of the tax if paid before the notice, within 30 days of it, or within 30 days of the order (section 74(5), (8), (11)) |
| Any demand for FY 2024-25 onwards | section 74A | non-fraud: 10% / ₹10,000, nil if paid within 60 days of the notice; fraud: 100%, reduced if paid within 60 days |
| Late payment of tax | section 50(1) | interest at 18% a year |
| Late returns | section 47 | late fee per day |
| E-invoice or invoice errors, wrong HSN | section 122 | penalty |
| Returns not filed | section 62 | best-judgment assessment |
Several small gaps in the same year can stack into one larger demand. That is the main reason to fix them early.
05 How these changes turn into Tribunal appeals
- Credit denied for supplier default. A genuine buyer may argue that credit should not be lost only because the supplier defaulted. This is a common ground of appeal; the outcome depends on your evidence. See also appealing ITC denial at GSTAT.
- Section 74 used for a genuine mistake. If fraud or suppression is not established, section 75(2) requires the tax to be worked out as if the notice had been issued under section 73.
- Best-judgment assessments. Where returns were not filed, you can put your actual records before the Tribunal to challenge the computation. A best-judgment order is treated as withdrawn if a valid return is filed within 60 days of its service, or within a further 60 days with an extra late fee (section 62(2)).
- Penalty-only orders. A separate pre-deposit rule applies to appeals against penalty-only orders from 1 October 2025.
If you want help putting the appeal together, see GSTAT appeal filing or GSTAT e-filing assistance.
06 Action plan for startups
- Check filing status. List every GSTR-1, GSTR-3B and GSTR-9 from the oldest open year and file anything near the cut-off.
- Reconcile the three ledgers monthly and clear negative balances before filing GSTR-3B.
- Set up e-invoicing before you cross the threshold. Test before going live.
- Map products to the right HSN / SAC codes and update billing.
- Check rates for every product and service after the slab changes.
- Use IMS to accept or reject supplier invoices before GSTR-2B is generated.
- Review every demand order. If a first appeal has gone against you, diary the Tribunal date: 3 months from the order being communicated. Work out the deposit with our GSTAT pre-deposit rules guide.
07 Documents to maintain
- Filing tracker for GSTR-1, GSTR-3B and GSTR-9 for every open period
- Monthly reconciliation of the credit, reversal-and-reclaim and reverse-charge ledgers
- E-invoice log: IRN, QR code and acknowledgement for each invoice
- HSN / SAC master with the code for each product and service
- Monthly GSTR-2B vs purchase register reconciliation, invoice by invoice
- IMS accept / reject log
- Marketplace TCS reconciliation, monthly
- Demand orders and first-appeal orders, for appeal review
- Section 128A application records, if you applied while the scheme was open
08 Timeline
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 1 Nov 2024 | Tribunal pre-deposit cut to 10% of the remaining tax in dispute; cap cut to ₹20 crore (CGST Act; for IGST, ₹40 crore per appeal) |
| 2025 | Rate slabs rationalised |
| 2025-26 | Tribunal portal opened and hearings began |
| 1 Oct 2025 | Separate pre-deposit rule for penalty-only orders |
| 2026 | Return time bar, GSTR-3B blocking and HSN changes in force |
| 2026 | Budget 2026 GST amendments |
| 31 Jul 2026 (passed) | Last date for Tribunal appeals against orders communicated before 1 May 2026 |
09 Common mistakes
- Assuming the time bar does not apply to you. It is enforced by the portal.
- Leaving e-invoicing too late. Your customers' credit depends on it; plan the set-up before you cross the threshold.
- Ignoring IMS. It is the simplest way to keep supplier errors out of your GSTR-2B.
- Not comparing the waiver with an appeal. While the section 128A scheme was open, it waived interest and penalty on section 73 demands for July 2017 to March 2020 if the tax was paid; it did not cover section 74 demands. The window has closed.
- Missing the Tribunal time limit. The special 31 July 2026 date for orders communicated before 1 May 2026 has passed. For orders communicated since, the normal 3-month limit applies, and a late appeal can be admitted only within a further 3 months for sufficient cause. Whether any route remains after that depends on the facts of the case. See our Form APL-05 guide for the filing itself.
10 Tribunal appeal vs the section 128A waiver
| Point | Tribunal appeal | Section 128A waiver |
|---|---|---|
| Demands covered | section 73, 74 and 74A orders, and penalty-only orders | section 73 demands for July 2017 to March 2020 only; not erroneous refunds |
| What you pay first | admitted tax plus 10% of the remaining tax in dispute | the full tax, by the notified date |
| What you get | a decision on the merits | interest and penalty waived; tax stands |
| Open today? | yes: within the time limit | no: the window has closed |
| Best for | disputes on the tax itself, section 74 / 74A cases | (was) cases where the tax was accepted |
11 Key takeaways
- Recent GST changes make small compliance gaps more likely to become demands.
- Stacked gaps in one year can mean a large demand under section 73, 74 or 74A.
- The section 128A waiver covered only some old section 73 demands and has closed.
- Regular reconciliation of returns, ledgers, credit and HSN codes is the cheapest protection.
12 Talk to us about a GST demand
We can review your demand order, work out the pre-deposit and prepare the appeal papers. Appeals and representation support: our CA team can appear for you before the GST Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), depending on the location and legal requirements. Call +91 945 945 6700, or see GSTAT appeal filing.
Read next: Pending GSTAT cases · GSTAT state benches
