Talk to an expert

Tell us what you need and we will call you back.

🇮🇳 +91

    Free checker

    GST Refund Rejection Analyzer

    Got a Form GST RFD-06 rejection order? This decision-tree tool walks through the 14 most common rejection grounds (time-bar, drawback bar, export duty, IDS exclusions, GSTR mismatch, deficiency memo, computation errors, place-of-supply disputes, LUT issues, and more) and identifies the right remedy: refile within remaining limitation, file first appeal in APL-01 under Section 107 with 10% pre-deposit, escalate to GSTAT under Section 112, or pursue writ jurisdiction under Article 226. Each verdict cites statutory section, limitation period and pre-deposit calculation.

    Written by Subham Jhunjhunwala · reviewed by CA Sundram Gupta · Updated: 8 May 2026

    Analyze Your Rejection & Find the Right Remedy

    Answer a few questions about the rejection grounds in your Form GST RFD-06. The tool branches through the statutory framework and recommends the optimal remedy: refile, appeal, or writ.

    Step 1
    Start
    Want a CA to review this output before it goes into your file?
    A Chartered Accountant can check the figures with you. No obligation.

    Framework

    Refund Rejection Framework: Forms, Timeline, Remedies

    When a refund application filed in Form GST RFD-01 on the GST Portal (see gst.gov.in) is rejected, the proper officer issues the rejection through Form GST RFD-06. The process is governed by Rule 92 of the CGST Rules read with Section 54 of the CGST Act 2017, with detailed procedural guidance issued by CBIC. Every rejection must follow due process: show-cause notice in RFD-08, opportunity of hearing, and reasoned order in RFD-06. Departures from this framework are themselves grounds for appeal or writ.

    The Rejection Lifecycle

    FormStageTimelineAction Required
    RFD-01Initial refund applicationWithin 2 years from relevant dateFiled by taxpayer on GST Portal
    RFD-02Acknowledgment15 days from RFD-01Auto-generated by system
    RFD-03Deficiency memo15 days from RFD-01Cure deficiencies, refile RFD-01
    RFD-04Provisional refund order7 days from RFD-0290% of refund credited (zero-rated cases)
    RFD-08Show-cause noticeBefore RFD-06 rejectionReply via RFD-09 within 15 days
    RFD-09Reply to SCN15 days from RFD-08Submit reasoning + supporting documents
    RFD-06Final sanction/rejection order60 days from complete RFD-01Operative document for appeal
    RFD-05Payment adviceAfter RFD-06 sanctionBank credit by Centre
    RFD-07Withhold orderAnytime per Section 54(10)/(11)File reply; possible appeal

    Four Routes to Remedy

    • Refile: For curable defects (missing docs, computation, GSTR mismatch). Under the proviso to Rule 90(3), the time from filing the original claim to the date the deficiency memo is communicated is excluded from the two-year limit. Available only if within remaining 2-year limitation.
    • First Appeal under Section 107: File Form GST APL-01 within 3 months of order communication. Pre-deposit 10% of disputed tax (capped at ₹20 Cr per Finance (No 2) Act 2024). Heard by First Appellate Authority. Order in Form GST APL-04.
    • GSTAT under Section 112: Escalate APL-04 within 3 months. Further 10% pre-deposit (capped at ₹20 Cr). GST Appellate Tribunal benches now operational.
    • Writ Petition under Article 226: High Court jurisdiction for jurisdictional errors, portal failures, natural-justice breaches, Article 14 violations. No pre-deposit but discretionary.

    Don't miss the 3-month appeal clock. Section 107(4) condones delay only up to 1 additional month with sufficient cause. Beyond 4 months total, the appeal route closes. Diary the appeal deadline immediately on receiving RFD-06.

    Rejection Grounds

    14 Common Rejection Grounds

    Departments routinely reject refund claims on a finite set of statutory grounds, many overlapping with RBI Master Direction requirements on export remittance. Knowing the ground determines the right remedy. Below is the practitioner taxonomy used in the analyzer above.

    Substantive Eligibility Grounds (Hard to Cure)

    1. Time-bar (Section 54(1)): Filed beyond 2 years from relevant date. Test COVID extension under Notification 13/2022.
    2. Drawback or Notification benefit availed (Rule 96(10), omitted from 8 October 2024): IGST refund was blocked for double-benefit; how the omission applies to earlier periods depends on the facts. Test whether drawback was higher-rate (with central tax) or customs-only.
    3. Export duty on goods (Section 54(15)): Both ITC and (post FA No 2 of 2024) IGST refund blocked.
    4. Output nil-rated or fully exempt (first proviso to S.54(3)): IDS refund blocked. Test whether output is genuinely exempt or zero-rated.
    5. Same goods at different rates (Circular 135/2020): IDS refund blocked where same HSN. Concessional notification exception per Circular 173/2022.
    6. Output in Notification 5/2017 list: Specific HSNs excluded from IDS refund. Verify current notification status.
    7. Below ₹1,000 threshold (Section 54(14)): Refund applications below threshold not entertained. Accumulate within FY.

    Procedural / Curable Grounds

    1. ITC mismatch / GSTR reconciliation: GSTR-1 vs GSTR-3B vs GSTR-2B inconsistency. Often curable.
    2. Documentation deficiency (RFD-03 not cured): Missing BRC/FIRC, shipping bill, statements, CA certificate. Refile after curing.
    3. Computation error in formula: Wrong Rule 89(4) or Rule 89(5) application. May be appealable if department applied wrong formula.
    4. Wrong category / classification: Department reclassifies refund category. Refile under correct category or appeal.

    Disputed Grounds (Often Appealable / Writ-Friendly)

    1. Unjust enrichment burden: Tax burden allegedly passed on. Strengthen with CA certificate per Rule 89(2)(m).
    2. Place of supply / export status disputed: Department challenges Section 13 IGST analysis. Strong appeal ground with documentation.
    3. LUT not in place: Exports without valid LUT. Appeal if LUT was filed but system rejected; refile + pay IGST + claim S.54 refund if filing was missed.

    Mapping Ground to Remedy

    Rejection grounds 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 are typically sustained on facts: no remedy unless underlying premise is wrong. Grounds 8-11 are typically curable through refile. Grounds 2, 12, 13 are typically appealable on merits. Ground 14 depends on facts. Writ jurisdiction is layered on top: available where alternative remedy is inadequate, jurisdictional error exists, or natural-justice breaches occurred.

    Refund rejected? Time-sensitive: appeal clock ticking

    Patron's GST team handles APL-01 first appeals, RFD-01 refilings, GSTAT appeals, and writ petitions for portal/jurisdictional rejections.

    Appeal Process

    The Appeal Process: Section 107 in Detail

    The first appeal is the standard remedy for an RFD-06 rejection on substantive grounds. Filed in Form GST APL-01 on the GST Portal under Services → User Services → Appeals, the appeal is heard by the First Appellate Authority (the Commissioner (Appeals) for orders by an Assistant or Deputy Commissioner; the Additional or Joint Commissioner (Appeals) for orders by a Superintendent).

    Filing Requirements

    1. Copy of RFD-06 rejection order with date of communication
    2. Form GST APL-01 (online form on GST Portal)
    3. Form GST APL-01A: detailed grounds of appeal with legal arguments
    4. Pre-deposit challan: 10% of disputed tax via electronic cash or credit ledger
    5. Authorisation letter if filed by an authorised representative
    6. Supporting documents: invoices, GSTR returns, BRC/FIRC, CA certificates, case-law citations

    Timeline Within Appeal

    Once APL-01 is filed and pre-deposit paid, the First Appellate Authority schedules hearings (in-person or online). The taxpayer or representative presents grounds. The Authority may call additional documents. Final order is issued in Form GST APL-04. Where the appeal is allowed, refund is processed with Section 56 interest on delayed disposal. Where rejected, escalation lies to GSTAT.

    Pre-Deposit Computation

    The 10% pre-deposit is computed on the disputed tax amount only. For partial rejection cases, only the rejected portion is the disputed amount. Pre-deposit may be paid through electronic cash ledger or electronic credit ledger (per CBIC guidance). The pre-deposit is capped at ₹20 crore of central tax (Finance (No. 2) Act, 2024).

    Disputed Amount10% Pre-DepositNotes
    ₹10 lakh₹1 lakhStandard 10%
    ₹1 crore₹10 lakhStandard 10%
    ₹50 crore₹5 croreStandard 10%
    ₹500 crore₹20 croreCapped at ₹20 Cr per FA (No 2) 2024

    Pre-Deposit Refund on Success

    When the appeal succeeds, the pre-deposit is refunded under Section 115 with 6% interest from the date of payment.

    GSTAT Escalation under Section 112

    Where APL-04 is unfavourable, the taxpayer may appeal to the GST Appellate Tribunal under Section 112. The appeal must be filed within 3 months of APL-04 (extendable by 3 months for sufficient cause). An additional pre-deposit of 10% of the remaining tax in dispute applies, up to ₹20 crore (section 112(8), as amended from 1 November 2024). The Principal Bench is at New Delhi; State Benches sit in major cities across India.

    Practical Steps

    Practical Steps After a Refund Rejection

    Practitioner Implications

    • Always preserve RFD-08 vs RFD-06 comparison. Note any ground in RFD-06 that was not in RFD-08.
    • Save portal screenshots and error logs. They are the main evidence where a portal failure caused the rejection.
    • For older IDS rejections, check whether the amended Rule 89(5) formula can be argued for the period. CBIC Circular 181/2022 treats it as prospective from 5 July 2022.
    • Track CBIC Notification 11/2025 (March 2025) on Rule 164: partial appeal withdrawal now permitted.
    • Maintain reconciliation working as primary evidence. ITC mismatch rejections require granular invoice-level reconciliation.

    Common Mistakes Post-Rejection

    Filing a Fresh RFD-01 Instead of Appeal

    Where rejection is on substantive grounds (drawback, export duty, IDS exclusion), a fresh RFD-01 will be rejected on the same grounds. The correct remedy is appeal. Conversely, where rejection is for curable defects (deficiency memo, computation), filing a fresh RFD-01 with corrections is faster and cheaper than appeal. Misjudging this wastes time and costs.

    Missing the 3-Month Appeal Window

    Section 107(1) prescribes 3 months from communication of order. Section 107(4) condones up to 1 additional month with sufficient cause. Beyond 4 months, the route is foreclosed. Many practitioners diary the order date but miss the communication date; the latter starts the clock. Preserve postal envelope or portal acknowledgment as communication evidence.

    Underpaying Pre-Deposit

    The 10% pre-deposit is computed on disputed tax. Some practitioners compute on disputed total amount including interest and penalty, leading to underpayment that makes the appeal not maintainable. Others miscompute on the full original claim instead of just the rejected portion. Verify computation against the RFD-06 line-item breakdown.

    Filing Writ Without Exhausting Appeal

    Writ jurisdiction under Article 226 is generally not entertained where alternative remedy of appeal is available. Exceptions: jurisdictional error, natural-justice breach, portal failure. For routine rejections where appeal is open, file APL-01 first. Writ as substitute for appeal is dismissed at threshold by most High Courts.

    Not Citing Recent Case Law

    Appeal grounds drafted in APL-01A should cite the statutory provisions and verified case law. Pre-deposit cases should reference Section 115. IDS cases should reference VKC Footsteps SC 2021. Generic appeals without specific case law are weaker.

    Ignoring the COVID Extension

    For older claims with relevant date in 2019-2021, the COVID extension under Notification 13/2022 (excluding 1 March 2020 to 28 February 2022 from limitation) may convert a time-barred rejection to a live claim. Always run the COVID overlap test before accepting time-bar rejection. Use the Patron GST Refund Time-Bar Calculator for precise computation.

    Not Tracking ARN Status

    The GST Portal updates ARN status through the lifecycle: RFD-02 → RFD-03 → RFD-04 → RFD-08 → RFD-06. Some practitioners only check status occasionally, missing the RFD-08 SCN window (which has a strict 15-day reply timeline under RFD-09). Set up automated email alerts on ARN status changes to avoid missing SCN replies that lead to ex-parte rejection.

    Talk to a CA

    Refund Appeal & Refile

    Questions

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What is Form GST RFD-06?

    Form GST RFD-06 is the final Refund Sanction or Rejection Order issued by the proper officer after scrutinizing a refund application filed in Form GST RFD-01. The order specifies the amount sanctioned, the amount rejected, and reasons for rejection. RFD-06 is the operative document for any appeal or writ proceedings. It is preceded by an RFD-08 show-cause notice, to which the taxpayer must reply via RFD-09 within fifteen days before final order.

    What is the time limit to appeal a refund rejection?

    The first appeal under Section 107 of the CGST Act 2017 must be filed within three months from the date of communication of the rejection order in Form GST RFD-06. The Appellate Authority may condone delay up to one additional month if sufficient cause is shown. Beyond four months, appeals are usually not accepted. The appeal is filed in Form GST APL-01 on the GST Portal along with the grounds in Form GST APL-01A and required pre-deposit.

    What is the pre-deposit for a refund appeal?

    Section 107(6) requires a pre-deposit of 10 percent of the disputed tax, capped at ₹20 crore of central tax (Finance (No. 2) Act, 2024). It is paid through the electronic cash or credit ledger before filing APL-01. For penalty-only disputes, 10 percent applies on the disputed penalty. For GSTAT escalation under Section 112, a further 10 percent of the tax still in dispute applies, capped at ₹20 crore of central tax.

    When should I refile instead of appealing?

    Refile when the rejection is due to a curable defect such as missing documents, wrong category selection, computation error, or GSTR reconciliation gaps. Refile is allowed if you are within the two-year limitation under Section 54(1) and the deficiency memo Rule 90(3) protection preserves your original filing date. Refile is faster, cheaper, and avoids litigation. Appeal when rejection is on substantive grounds disputing eligibility: drawback bar, export duty, IDS exclusions, time-bar interpretation, or the officer applies wrong law.

    When is a writ petition appropriate?

    Writ jurisdiction under Article 226 is appropriate where the alternative appeal remedy is inadequate, ineffective, or where there is a violation of natural justice or fundamental rights. Grounds commonly raised in writ petitions include GST Portal technical glitches, jurisdictional errors, departmental reliance on outside material not mentioned in the SCN, a deficiency-memo rejection applying the wrong limitation, and Article 14 violations.

    Can I refile if the deficiency memo (RFD-03) was issued?

    Yes. When Form GST RFD-03 deficiency memo is issued within fifteen days of the original filing, the original RFD-01 application is treated as not filed under Rule 90(3). The taxpayer must refile a fresh RFD-01 after curing deficiencies. Importantly, under the proviso to Rule 90(3), the time from filing the original claim to the date the deficiency memo is communicated is excluded from the two-year limit. This protects taxpayers from time-bar where deficiency memo is delayed.

    How do I appeal if my refund was rejected partially?

    When RFD-06 sanctions part of the refund and rejects part, you can appeal only the rejected portion. The pre-deposit is computed on the disputed amount only, not the full original claim. File APL-01 specifying the rejected amount as disputed tax and pay 10 percent pre-deposit on that. The sanctioned portion is processed through RFD-05 payment advice separately. Notification 11/2025 also allows partial appeal withdrawal.

    Is pre-deposit refundable on success?

    Yes. The pre-deposit paid under Section 107(6) is refundable on favourable disposal of the appeal. Section 115 provides for automatic refund with interest at 6 percent per annum from the date of payment. Practitioners should preserve pre-deposit challan and file refund as a routine step post-appellate success.

    Can I file appeal without paying pre-deposit?

    Section 107(6) mandates pre-deposit and the GST Portal will not accept APL-01 without it. The standard rule is no pre-deposit equals no appeal. For very large disputed amounts where the 10 percent is unaffordable, practitioners sometimes pursue parallel writ petition challenging the rejection directly under Article 226 to avoid the pre-deposit requirement.

    What if rejection is due to ITC mismatch with GSTR-2B?

    ITC mismatch rejections are typically curable rather than appealable. The recommended approach is to identify the specific invoices causing mismatch, coordinate with suppliers to file correctly in their GSTR-1, wait for the correction to flow to GSTR-2B, and refile RFD-01 once reconciled. For FY 2017-18 and 2018-19, Circular 183/15/2022-GST lets you prove supplier-side ITC with a CA or supplier certificate; these may be cited in appeal where supplier cannot be brought into compliance. Maintain reconciliation working as primary evidence.

    Does the amended Rule 89(5) formula help old refund claims?

    It may. CBIC Circular 181/2022 treats the amendment under Notification 14/2022 as prospective from 5 July 2022, and whether it applies to earlier periods has been argued before the courts. If you have a rejected inverted duty claim for a period before July 2022, check the current position before choosing between refile and appeal.

    What if I missed the 3-month appeal deadline?

    The First Appellate Authority has limited power under Section 107(4) to condone delay up to one additional month if sufficient cause is shown: illness, unavoidable absence, or portal access issues. Beyond four months total, the appellate route is closed. The remaining option is writ jurisdiction under Article 226 alleging natural-justice breach, jurisdictional error, or Article 14 violation. High Courts are reluctant to entertain writs as substitute for time-barred appeals.

    Talk to a chartered accountant

    Tell us what you need help with and a chartered accountant from our team calls you back.

    🇮🇳 +91

      By sending this form you agree to our privacy policy.

      Get compliance due-date alerts on WhatsApp. Join →